Evaluate Arguments - GED Reasoning Through Language Arts

  1. "Crime fell after the new mayor took office, so the mayor caused the drop." Which fallacy is this?
    False cause (post hoc): it assumes that because one event followed another, the first caused the second.
  2. What is circular reasoning?
    An argument that uses its own conclusion as its evidence, such as "This law is fair because it is just."
  3. What two tests should evidence pass to support a claim well?
    It must be relevant (actually related to the claim) and sufficient (enough in amount and quality to justify the claim).
  4. "We should ignore her tax plan because she was once fired from a job." Which fallacy is this?
    Ad hominem: it attacks the person instead of the argument.
  5. "Either we cut every school program or the town goes bankrupt." Which fallacy is this?
    False dilemma: it presents only two options when other choices exist.
  6. Is "The new park cost 2 million dollars" a fact or an opinion?
    A fact. It can be checked against records; it contains no judgment of value.
  7. Opponents say the plan needs review; a writer replies, "They want to block all progress." Which fallacy is this?
    Straw man: the writer distorts the opponents' position into a weaker one that is easier to attack.
  8. "My uncle smoked for 60 years and was never sick, so smoking is harmless." Which fallacy is this?
    Hasty generalization: a broad conclusion is drawn from a single case.
  9. "Millions of people use this supplement, so it must work." Which fallacy is this?
    Bandwagon (appeal to popularity): popularity is not evidence that a claim is true.
  10. In an argument, what is the difference between a claim and evidence?
    The claim is the position the author wants readers to accept; evidence is the facts, data, examples or expert testimony offered to support it.
  11. Is "The new park is a waste of money" a fact or an opinion?
    An opinion. "Waste" is a judgment that cannot be proved true or false.
  12. "If we allow one food truck downtown, soon the streets will be full of them and restaurants will close." Which fallacy is this?
    Slippery slope: it claims, without evidence, that one step will lead to a chain of extreme results.

Study these flashcards