Evaluate Arguments - GED Reasoning Through Language Arts
- "Crime fell after the new mayor took office, so the mayor caused the drop." Which fallacy is this?
- False cause (post hoc): it assumes that because one event followed another, the first caused the second.
- What is circular reasoning?
- An argument that uses its own conclusion as its evidence, such as "This law is fair because it is just."
- What two tests should evidence pass to support a claim well?
- It must be relevant (actually related to the claim) and sufficient (enough in amount and quality to justify the claim).
- "We should ignore her tax plan because she was once fired from a job." Which fallacy is this?
- Ad hominem: it attacks the person instead of the argument.
- "Either we cut every school program or the town goes bankrupt." Which fallacy is this?
- False dilemma: it presents only two options when other choices exist.
- Is "The new park cost 2 million dollars" a fact or an opinion?
- A fact. It can be checked against records; it contains no judgment of value.
- Opponents say the plan needs review; a writer replies, "They want to block all progress." Which fallacy is this?
- Straw man: the writer distorts the opponents' position into a weaker one that is easier to attack.
- "My uncle smoked for 60 years and was never sick, so smoking is harmless." Which fallacy is this?
- Hasty generalization: a broad conclusion is drawn from a single case.
- "Millions of people use this supplement, so it must work." Which fallacy is this?
- Bandwagon (appeal to popularity): popularity is not evidence that a claim is true.
- In an argument, what is the difference between a claim and evidence?
- The claim is the position the author wants readers to accept; evidence is the facts, data, examples or expert testimony offered to support it.
- Is "The new park is a waste of money" a fact or an opinion?
- An opinion. "Waste" is a judgment that cannot be proved true or false.
- "If we allow one food truck downtown, soon the streets will be full of them and restaurants will close." Which fallacy is this?
- Slippery slope: it claims, without evidence, that one step will lead to a chain of extreme results.