Analyze Source Arguments - GED Reasoning Through Language Arts
- What is a rebuttal?
- The author's response to a counterargument, showing why the opposing view is wrong or less convincing.
- A study concluding that sugary drinks are harmless was paid for by a soft-drink maker. What weakness does this suggest?
- Possible bias: the funder has a financial interest in the result, which is a conflict of interest.
- What makes a source credible on a topic?
- Relevant expertise, reliable and current evidence, and no strong conflict of interest. Expertise in an unrelated field does not make a source credible on the topic.
- Why does the date of a source matter when it gives statistics?
- Data can become outdated. Older figures may no longer reflect current conditions, which weakens their value as evidence.
- What is a counterargument?
- An opposing view that disagrees with the author's claim. A strong argument acknowledges it and answers it.
- "The city should add bike lanes because that will reduce traffic." What assumption must be true for this reasoning to work?
- That people will actually ride bikes on the new lanes instead of driving.
- What is an appeal to pathos?
- An appeal to the audience's emotions, such as fear, pity or pride.
- When judging which of two arguments is better supported, what should decide the answer?
- The quality and relevance of each side's evidence and reasoning, not whether you personally agree with its position.
- Which is stronger support: "Experts agree that the plan works" or "A 2022 state audit found the plan cut costs by 12 percent"?
- The audit statement. It names a specific source and gives a measurable result; "experts agree" is vague and unverifiable.
- What is an appeal to logos?
- An appeal to logic and reason, using facts, statistics and logical reasoning.
- What is an unstated assumption in an argument?
- A belief the author takes for granted but does not say, which must be true for the reasoning to work.
- What is an appeal to ethos?
- An appeal to the speaker's credibility or character, such as citing one's own expertise or experience.