01 / 20

Stability from
Phase Lines

Classify equilibrium points of \(\dfrac{dy}{dt}=f(y)\) as stable, unstable, or semi-stable by reading arrow directions on a phase line.

Differential Equations

What Is an Autonomous ODE?

An autonomous ordinary differential equation has the form \(\dfrac{dy}{dt}=f(y)\). The right-hand side depends only on \(y\), not on the independent variable \(t\).

\(f(y) > 0\)
\(y\) is increasing: arrow points up.
\(f(y) < 0\)
\(y\) is decreasing: arrow points down.
\(f(y) = 0\)
\(y\) is at equilibrium: constant solution.

Equilibrium Points

An equilibrium point (critical point) is a value \(y^*\) where \(f(y^*)=0\). At such a point \(\dfrac{dy}{dt}=0\), so \(y(t)=y^*\) is a constant solution for all \(t\).

The central question: if a solution starts near \(y^*\), does it approach \(y^*\) or drift away? That is the question of stability.

Anatomy of a Phase Line

A phase line is a vertical number line for \(y\). Mark each equilibrium as a dot and draw arrows showing the sign of \(f(y)\) in every interval.

y
\(y^*=2\)
stable
\(y^*=0\)
unstable
\(f(y)< 0\)
\(f(y)> 0\)
\(f(y)< 0\)
= stable = unstable

Three Types of Stability

Stable (Sink)
Arrows on both sides point toward the equilibrium. Nearby solutions converge.
Unstable (Source)
Arrows on both sides point away. Nearby solutions diverge.
Semi-stable
Arrows point toward on one side, away on the other. Partial attraction.

The Classification Rule

Look at the arrows in the intervals immediately above and immediately below each equilibrium \(y^*\):

1
Both arrows toward \(y^*\): the equilibrium is stable (asymptotically stable).
2
Both arrows away from \(y^*\): the equilibrium is unstable.
3
One toward, one away: the equilibrium is semi-stable.

Stable vs Unstable vs Semi-stable

Stable Unstable Semi-stable

How to Apply the Method

1
Find equilibria: Solve \(f(y)=0\) for all roots \(y^*\).
2
Draw the number line: Mark each \(y^*\) as a dot on a vertical axis.
3
Test each interval: Pick a sample value between (and beyond) equilibria. Evaluate the sign of \(f\).
4
Draw arrows: Up if \(f>0\), down if \(f<0\).
5
Classify: Read arrow patterns around each dot: both toward = stable, both away = unstable, mixed = semi-stable.

Example 1: \(\dfrac{dy}{dt}=y(2-y)\)

Step 1: \(f(y)=y(2-y)=0\) gives equilibria \(y^*=0\) and \(y^*=2\).

Step 2: Test the sign of \(f\) in each region:

\(y=-1\)
\(f(-1)=(-1)(3)=\)\(-3\)
\(y=1\)
\(f(1)=(1)(1)=\)\(+1\)
\(y=3\)
\(f(3)=(3)(-1)=\)\(-3\)

Example 1: Phase Line

y
\(y^*=2\)
stable
\(y^*=0\)
unstable

Example 2: \(\dfrac{dy}{dt}=y^2-1\)

Step 1: \(f(y)=y^2-1=(y-1)(y+1)=0\). Equilibria: \(y^*=-1\) and \(y^*=1\).

Step 2: Sign tests:

\(y=-2\)
\(f(-2)=3\): positive
\(y=0\)
\(f(0)=-1\): negative
\(y=2\)
\(f(2)=3\): positive

Example 3: \(\dfrac{dy}{dt}=(y-1)^2\)

Step 1: \(f(y)=(y-1)^2=0\) gives a single equilibrium \(y^*=1\) (double root).

Step 2: Since \((y-1)^2\ge 0\) for all \(y\), we have \(f(y)>0\) everywhere except at \(y=1\). So arrows point up on both sides.

y
\(y^*=1\)
semi-stable
\(f(y)> 0\)
\(f(y)> 0\)

The \(f'(y^*)\) Shortcut

When \(y^*\) is a simple root of \(f\) (meaning \(f'(y^*) \neq 0\)), you can classify without drawing the full phase line:

\(f'(y^*) < 0\)
Equilibrium is stable.
\(f'(y^*) > 0\)
Equilibrium is unstable.

Common Mistakes

✕ Confusing arrow direction
An up arrow means \(f>0\) (\(y\) increasing), not that the solution "goes to the equilibrium above."
✕ Skipping outer intervals
You must test the sign of \(f\) below the smallest \(y^*\) and above the largest \(y^*\), not just between them.
✕ Derivative test on repeated roots
Applying \(f'(y^*) < 0 \Rightarrow \text{stable}\) when \(f'(y^*) = 0\) gives a wrong answer. Use the sign chart instead.

Summary Table

Property Stable Unstable Semi-stable
Arrow pattern Both toward Both away One each way
Phase line dot ● filled ○ open ○ open
\(f'(y^*)\) test \(< 0\) \(> 0\) \(=0\) (inconclusive)
Long-term behavior Solutions converge Solutions diverge One-sided convergence
Physical analogy Ball in valley Ball on hilltop Ball on ledge

Question 1 of 5

Consider \(\dfrac{dy}{dt}=y(1-y)(y-3)\). Which values are equilibria?

Question 2 of 5

On a phase line, arrows point toward an equilibrium from both sides. The equilibrium is:

Question 3 of 5

For \(\dfrac{dy}{dt}=y^2-4\), the equilibria are \(y^*=\pm 2\). Using \(f'(y)=2y\), classify \(y^*=2\).

Question 4 of 5

For \(\dfrac{dy}{dt}=(y-1)^2\), the only equilibrium is \(y^*=1\). What is its stability?

Question 5 of 5

For \(\dfrac{dy}{dt}=\sin(y)\), classify the equilibrium at \(y^*=\pi\).