01 / 21

Defenses to Payment of
Negotiable Instruments

Understand the real and personal defenses that obligors can raise when asked to pay on a negotiable instrument, and why holder in due course status matters.

CPA Regulation (REG)

What Is a Negotiable Instrument?

A negotiable instrument is a written, unconditional promise or order to pay a fixed amount of money. The most common examples are promissory notes and checks. These instruments can be transferred from one party to another, and the rights and defenses that attach depend on how the instrument was transferred and who holds it.

Promissory Note
A promise by the maker to pay a specified sum to the payee or holder.
Check / Draft
An order by the drawer directing the drawee (bank) to pay a specified sum.

How Instruments Change Hands

Maker / Drawer Issues Payee Negotiates Holder If requirements met HDC (Super-Holder)

Why Defenses Matter

When a holder demands payment on an instrument, the person obligated to pay (the obligor) may try to refuse. The law divides the obligor's defenses into two categories, and the type of holder determines which defenses are available:

Real Defenses
Valid against all holders, including an HDC. These go to the very existence or validity of the instrument.
Personal Defenses
Valid only against an ordinary holder. An HDC takes free of personal defenses.

The Core Rule: UCC Article 3

REAL DEFENSES Good vs. ALL holders (incl. HDC) 1. Infancy (minority) 2. Duress 3. Incapacity (adjudicated) 4. Illegality 5. Fraud in the factum 6. Discharge in bankruptcy 7. Forgery 8. Material alteration PERSONAL DEFENSES Good vs. ordinary holders ONLY 1. Breach of contract 2. Lack of consideration 3. Fraud in the inducement 4. Theft / unauthorized completion 5. Non-delivery 6. Payment / cancellation 7. Mental incapacity (not adjudicated)

Real Defenses in Depth

1
Infancy (Minority): A minor's obligation on a negotiable instrument is voidable, just as in general contract law.
2
Duress: Extreme duress (e.g., signing at gunpoint) renders the instrument void, not merely voidable.
3
Adjudicated Incapacity: A court has declared the person legally incompetent before the instrument was signed.
4
Illegality: The underlying transaction is illegal under state law, making the instrument void.

Real Defenses: Fraud, Forgery, & More

5
Fraud in the Factum: The signer was tricked about the nature of the document itself. Example: told they were signing a receipt, but actually signed a promissory note.
6
Discharge in Bankruptcy: Once the obligor has been discharged through bankruptcy, the debt on the instrument is extinguished against all holders.
7
Forgery: A forged signature is wholly inoperative. The person whose name was forged has no liability.
8
Material Alteration: An unauthorized change to the terms (amount, date, payee). An HDC can enforce the original terms.

Personal Defenses in Depth

1
Breach of Contract: The payee failed to deliver goods or services. This is a dispute between the original parties.
2
Lack of Consideration: The instrument was given as a gift or without adequate exchange of value.
3
Fraud in the Inducement: The signer knew they were signing a note, but was lied to about the underlying deal. Example: told goods were genuine when they were counterfeit.
4
Non-delivery / Theft: The instrument was lost or stolen before the payee received it, and a non-HDC holder now possesses it.

Key Distinction: Factum vs. Inducement

Fraud in the Factum Fraud in the Inducement
Type Real defense Personal defense
What was the lie? The nature of the document The quality/value of the deal
Signer awareness Did not know they signed an instrument Knew they signed an instrument
Good vs. HDC? Yes: beats HDC No: HDC takes free
Example "Sign this receipt" (really a note) "This car is brand new" (really used)

How to Apply the Rules

1
Identify the holder: Is the person demanding payment an ordinary holder or a Holder in Due Course (HDC)?
2
Identify the defense: What reason is the obligor giving for not paying? Classify it as real or personal.
3
Match: If the defense is real, it works against any holder. If personal, it only works if the holder is not an HDC.
4
Apply the exception for material alteration: An HDC can still enforce the original terms of a materially altered instrument.
5
Check for the FTC Rule: In consumer transactions, the FTC Holder Rule preserves all defenses against HDCs (a major exception).

Example 1: Basic Application

1
Holder status: Carol is an HDC.
2
Defense type: Alice knew she was signing a note. She was lied to about the car's quality. This is fraud in the inducement (personal).
3
Result: Personal defenses do not work against an HDC. Alice must pay Carol.

Example 2: Real Defense Wins

1
Holder status: Frank is an HDC.
2
Defense type: Infancy (minority) is a real defense.
3
Result: Real defenses are valid against all holders, including an HDC. Dan does NOT have to pay Frank.

Example 3: Material Alteration

1
Defense: Material alteration is a real defense.
2
HDC exception: An HDC can enforce the instrument according to its original terms.
3
Result: Grace must pay Irene $500 (original amount), not $5,000. Against an ordinary holder, Grace could refuse to pay entirely.

The FTC Holder Rule

The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) Holder Rule is a major exception. In consumer credit transactions, the FTC requires sellers to include a notice in the contract preserving all claims and defenses the consumer could raise against the seller. This means:

Consumer Protection
Personal defenses like breach of contract and fraud in the inducement can be raised against an HDC in consumer deals.
Commercial Exception
The FTC Rule does not apply to commercial (business-to-business) transactions. Standard HDC rules apply.

Common Mistakes

✕ Confusing the Two Frauds
Fraud in the factum (real) vs. fraud in the inducement (personal). The key: did the signer know they were signing an instrument?
✕ Forgetting the FTC Rule
In consumer transactions, personal defenses are preserved against HDCs. Don't apply standard HDC rules without checking.
✕ Material Alteration Overreach
An HDC can enforce the original terms. Students often think the entire instrument is void. Against a non-HDC, it is.

Summary Table

Defense Type vs. Holder vs. HDC
Infancy Real ✓ ✓
Duress Real ✓ ✓
Fraud in Factum Real ✓ ✓
Forgery Real ✓ ✓
Discharge in Bankruptcy Real ✓ ✓
Breach of Contract Personal ✓ ✕
Fraud in Inducement Personal ✓ ✕
Lack of Consideration Personal ✓ ✕

Question 1 of 5

A maker of a promissory note was induced to sign the note by the payee's fraudulent misrepresentation that the goods being purchased were of a higher quality than they actually were. The note was subsequently negotiated to a holder in due course. Which defense can the maker assert against the HDC?

Question 2 of 5

Tom, a 17-year-old, signed a promissory note payable to Seller Corp. for a laptop. Seller Corp. negotiated the note to Bank, which qualifies as an HDC. Can Tom avoid payment to Bank?

Question 3 of 5

Maria signed what she believed was a lease agreement, but it was actually a promissory note. The note was negotiated to an HDC. What type of defense does Maria have?

Question 4 of 5

A check was originally written for $200. The payee altered it to $2,000 and negotiated it to an HDC. How much can the HDC collect from the drawer?

Question 5 of 5

A consumer purchased a defective appliance with a promissory note. The seller negotiated the note to a finance company that qualifies as an HDC. The consumer claims breach of warranty. Under the FTC Holder Rule, can the consumer raise this defense?