01 / 22

Sales-Type &
Direct Financing Leases

Master lessor accounting for sales-type and direct financing leases under ASC 842, including recognition of selling profit, net investment, and interest income.

CPA FAR

What Is a Lease from the Lessor's Perspective?

Under ASC 842, a lessor classifies every lease into one of three categories depending on whether the lease transfers substantially all risks and rewards of ownership to the lessee.

Sales-Type
Control transfers to lessee: recognize selling profit or loss at commencement.
Direct Financing
Control transfers but no selling profit exists. The lessor earns only interest income over the lease term.
Operating
Lessor retains asset: recognize rental income on a straight-line basis.

The Five Classification Criteria

A lease is sales-type (or direct financing) if it meets any one of these five tests. Otherwise, it is an operating lease.

1
Transfer of ownership: The lease transfers ownership to the lessee by end of term.
2
Purchase option: The lessee has an option to purchase the asset it is reasonably certain to exercise.
3
Lease term: The lease term is for the major part (≥ 75%) of the asset's remaining economic life.
4
PV of payments: The PV of lease payments ≥ substantially all (≥ 90%) of the asset's fair value.
5
Specialized asset: The asset has no alternative use to the lessor at end of term.

Sales-Type vs Direct Financing: The Decision

Once a lease passes at least one of the five criteria, the next question is: Is there a selling profit or loss?

Meets ANY of 5 criteria? Yes No Operating Fair Value ≠ Carrying Amount (i.e., selling profit/loss exists)? Yes No Sales-Type Lease Recognize selling profit at commencement Direct Financing No selling profit. Recognize interest income. Both collect residual value guarantee (if any) and derecognize the underlying asset.

Net Investment in the Lease

At lease commencement, the lessor records a Net Investment in Lease equal to the sum of two components:

Sales-Type Lease: Day-One Entries

At commencement, the lessor derecognizes the asset, records the net investment, and recognizes selling profit or loss immediately.

Dr
Lease Receivable (PV of lease payments)
Dr
Cost of Goods Sold (Carrying Amount − PV of Unguaranteed Residual)
Cr
Sales Revenue (PV of Lease Payments)
Cr
Underlying Asset (Inventory) (Carrying Amount)

Direct Financing Lease: Day-One Entries

The lessor derecognizes the asset but recognizes no selling profit. Initial direct costs are included in the net investment and reduce the implicit rate.

Dr
Lease Receivable (Gross lease payments receivable)
Dr
Unguaranteed Residual Asset (if any)
Cr
Underlying Asset (Carrying Amount)
Cr
Unearned Interest Income (Total interest to be earned)

Key Distinction: Profit Recognition Timing

Sales-Type Direct Financing
Selling Profit/Loss Immediate at commencement None (FV = Carrying Amt)
Initial Direct Costs Expensed immediately Deferred: included in net investment
Interest Income Effective interest on net investment Effective interest (adjusted rate)
Revenue/COGS Recognized Day 1 No revenue/COGS entry
When FV = Carrying Amt No selling profit: same as DF in substance This is the normal scenario

Interest Income Over the Lease Term

After commencement, both lease types earn interest income using the effective interest method. Each period:

Year 0 Record Net Inv. Year 1 Interest Income Year 2 Interest Income End Residual Return Net Investment decreases each period

Step-by-Step Application Checklist

1
Apply the 5 criteria. Does the lease meet any one? If no: operating lease. If yes: continue.
2
Compare Fair Value to Carrying Amount. If FV ≠ Carrying Amount: Sales-Type. If FV = Carrying Amount: Direct Financing.
3
Compute the Net Investment. PV of lease payments + PV of unguaranteed residual value.
4
Record Day-One entries. Derecognize asset, record receivable. For sales-type: recognize revenue/COGS. For DF: record unearned income.
5
Subsequent periods: Interest income = Beginning Net Investment × Rate. Reduce receivable by cash collected minus interest.

Example 1: Sales-Type Lease Setup

Alpha Corp leases equipment to Beta Inc. on January 1. Determine the lessor's journal entry.

Fair Value
\( \$100{,}000 \)
Carrying Amt
\( \$75{,}000 \)
Annual Payment
\( \$23{,}740 \) (end of year)
Lease Term
5 years; implicit rate = 6%

Example 1: Day-One Journal Entry

Dr
Lease Receivable \( \$100{,}000 \)
Dr
Cost of Goods Sold \( \$75{,}000 \)
Cr
Sales Revenue \( \$100{,}000 \)
Cr
Inventory (Equipment) \( \$75{,}000 \)

Example 2: Direct Financing Lease Setup

Gamma Bank leases a machine to Delta Corp. The bank purchased the machine at fair value (no manufacturer's margin).

Fair Value
\( \$80{,}000 \)
Carrying Amt
\( \$80{,}000 \)
Annual Payment
\( \$21{,}104 \) (end of year)
Terms
5 years; rate = 10%; IDC = \$2,000

Example 2: Day-One Journal Entry

Dr
Lease Receivable \( \$105{,}520 \)
Cr
Equipment \( \$80{,}000 \)
Cr
Cash (IDC) \( \$2{,}000 \)
Cr
Unearned Income \( \$23{,}520 \)

Example 3: Amortization Schedule

Continuing Example 1 (Sales-Type, 6%, \( \$100{,}000 \) net investment, \( \$23{,}740 \)/year):

Year Beg. Balance Interest (6%) Payment End Balance
1 \( \$100{,}000 \) \( \$6{,}000 \) \( \$23{,}740 \) \( \$82{,}260 \)
2 \( \$82{,}260 \) \( \$4{,}936 \) \( \$23{,}740 \) \( \$63{,}456 \)
3 \( \$63{,}456 \) \( \$3{,}807 \) \( \$23{,}740 \) \( \$43{,}523 \)
4 \( \$43{,}523 \) \( \$2{,}611 \) \( \$23{,}740 \) \( \$22{,}394 \)
5 \( \$22{,}394 \) \( \$1{,}346 \) \( \$23{,}740 \) \( \approx 0 \)

Common Mistakes to Avoid

✗ Recognizing profit in DF lease
Direct financing leases have no selling profit by definition (FV = CA). All income earned is interest income over the lease term.
✗ Expensing IDC in DF lease
Initial direct costs are expensed immediately only in sales-type leases. In DF leases, they are capitalized into the net investment.
✗ Using straight-line interest
Both lease types use the effective interest method, not straight-line. Interest income changes each period as the balance declines.

Summary Comparison

Feature Sales-Type Direct Financing Operating
Criteria met? Yes (any 1 of 5) Yes (any 1 of 5) None met
FV vs Carrying Amt FV ≠ CA FV = CA N/A
Day-1 Profit Recognized None None
Initial Direct Costs Expensed Capitalized Capitalized
Asset Derecognized? Yes Yes No
Income Pattern Interest (effective) Interest (effective) Straight-line rental

Question 1 of 5

A lessor leases equipment with a fair value of \( \$200{,}000 \) and a carrying amount of \( \$150{,}000 \). The lease meets the 75% useful life test. How should this lease be classified?

Question 2 of 5

In a direct financing lease, how are initial direct costs treated by the lessor?

Question 3 of 5

A lessor records a sales-type lease. The PV of lease payments is \( \$120{,}000 \) and the carrying amount of the asset is \( \$90{,}000 \). What is the selling profit recognized at commencement?

Question 4 of 5

A lessor has a net investment in a sales-type lease of \( \$50{,}000 \) at the beginning of Year 2. The implicit rate is 8%. What is the interest income for Year 2?

Question 5 of 5

Which of the following is NOT one of the five criteria for classifying a lease as sales-type or direct financing?