01 / 20

Inventory Valuation
& Write-Downs

Master the rules for measuring inventory on the balance sheet: the Lower of Cost or Net Realizable Value framework, when to write down, and how it flows through the financial statements.

CPA FAR

What Is Inventory Valuation?

Inventory valuation determines the dollar amount at which a company reports its inventory on the balance sheet and the corresponding cost of goods sold on the income statement. Getting this right matters because inventory is often one of the largest current assets.

Cost
The original purchase price plus all costs to bring inventory to its present location and condition.
Market Value
What the inventory could be sold for (or replaced at) in the current marketplace.

Key Terms: NRV, Cost, & Market

Historical Cost
Purchase price + freight-in + duties + direct handling costs.
NRV
Estimated selling price minus estimated costs of completion and selling expenses.
Replacement Cost
The current cost to repurchase the same inventory in the open market.

Why Write-Downs Matter

The conservatism principle (prudence) requires that losses be recognized as soon as they are probable, even before the inventory is sold. A write-down ensures the balance sheet does not overstate the value of assets.

Historical Cost
\( \$10{,}000 \)
Compare Cost vs. NRV NRV
\( \$8{,}500 \)
Write-Down Required
\( \text{Loss} = \$1{,}500 \)

The Core Rule: Lower of Cost or NRV

The formula is straightforward:

Visual: LCNRV Decision Flow

Determine Cost & NRV
\( \text{NRV} < \text{Cost?} \)
(compare)
Yes No Write Down to NRV Recognize loss in COGS Report at Cost No adjustment needed Balance Sheet: Inventory at Lower Value

LCNRV vs. LCM: Which Rule Applies?

LCNRV (ASC 330) LCM (Older Rule)
Applies to FIFO, weighted-average, specific ID LIFO & retail inventory method
Ceiling NRV NRV (same)
Floor Not applicable \(\text{NRV} - \text{Normal Profit}\)
"Market" Simply NRV Replacement cost, capped by ceiling & floor
Reversal Not permitted (U.S. GAAP) Not permitted (U.S. GAAP)

The LCM Three-Step Market Test

For companies using LIFO or the retail inventory method, "market" is defined as replacement cost, constrained between a ceiling and a floor:

1
Ceiling (NRV): \(\text{Selling Price} - \text{Costs to Complete} - \text{Selling Costs}\). Market cannot exceed this.
2
Floor: \(\text{NRV} - \text{Normal Profit Margin}\). Market cannot fall below this.
3
Designated Market: Replacement cost, but clamped between ceiling and floor. Then compare to cost.

How to Apply: Step-by-Step

1
Identify the cost basis: Determine the inventory's historical cost under the company's method (FIFO, LIFO, weighted-average).
2
Determine which rule applies: FIFO / weighted-average → LCNRV. LIFO / retail → LCM.
3
Calculate NRV: \(\text{Selling Price} - \text{Costs to Complete} - \text{Selling Expenses}\).
4
Compare and report: If NRV (or market) < Cost, write down to NRV. Record the loss in COGS or as a separate line item.
5
No reversal: Under U.S. GAAP, once written down, the new lower value becomes the new cost basis. No write-back permitted.

Example 1: Basic LCNRV

A retailer using FIFO has 200 units of Product X. Determine the reported inventory value.

Cost per Unit
\(\$45\)
Selling Price
\(\$50\)
Selling Costs
\(\$12\) per unit

Example 2: LCM Three-Step Test

A company using LIFO has inventory with these facts:

Cost
\(\$100\)
Replacement Cost
\(\$82\)
NRV (Ceiling)
\(\$95\)
NRV - Normal Profit (Floor)
\(\$80\)

Example 3: RC Above Ceiling

Same framework, but now replacement cost exceeds the NRV ceiling.

Cost
\(\$100\)
Replacement Cost
\(\$98\)
NRV (Ceiling)
\(\$90\)
Floor
\(\$78\)

Recording the Write-Down

There are two common approaches to recording inventory write-downs under U.S. GAAP:

Method 1: Direct
Dr. Cost of Goods Sold
    Cr. Inventory

The loss is buried inside COGS. Most common approach.
Method 2: Separate Loss
Dr. Loss on Inventory Write-Down
    Cr. Inventory

Loss shown separately on the income statement for transparency.

U.S. GAAP vs. IFRS Inventory Rules

U.S. GAAP (ASC 330) IFRS (IAS 2)
Measurement Lower of cost or NRV (most); LCM for LIFO/retail Lower of cost or NRV
LIFO allowed? Yes No
Write-down reversal Not permitted Permitted (up to original cost)
Costing methods FIFO, LIFO, weighted-avg, specific ID FIFO, weighted-avg, specific ID

Common Mistakes to Avoid

✕ Wrong Rule Applied
Using LCNRV for LIFO inventory or LCM for FIFO. Always check the costing method first.
✕ Reversing Under GAAP
U.S. GAAP does not allow write-down reversals. The new lower value becomes permanent cost.
✕ Forgetting Selling Costs
NRV must subtract both costs to complete and costs to sell, not just one.

Question 1 of 5

A company uses FIFO. Inventory has a cost of \(\$50{,}000\), estimated selling price of \(\$48{,}000\), and selling costs of \(\$3{,}000\). What amount should be reported on the balance sheet?

Question 2 of 5

Under U.S. GAAP, if a company writes inventory down to NRV and the market later recovers, what happens?

Question 3 of 5

For a LIFO company, given: Cost = \(\$200\), Replacement Cost = \(\$170\), NRV (ceiling) = \(\$180\), Floor = \(\$160\). What is the designated market value?

Question 4 of 5

Which inventory costing method(s) still require the lower of cost or market (LCM) test with ceiling and floor under ASC 330?

Question 5 of 5

Net Realizable Value (NRV) is calculated as: