01 / 20

Loss
Contingencies

Learn how to evaluate, classify, and record loss contingencies under ASC 450: the framework every CPA must master.

CPA FAR

What Is a Contingency?

A contingency is an existing condition, situation, or set of circumstances involving uncertainty as to a possible gain or loss that will ultimately be resolved when one or more future events occur or fail to occur.

Loss vs. Gain Contingencies

Loss Contingency
A potential decrease in assets or increase in liabilities. May be accrued or disclosed depending on likelihood and estimability.
Gain Contingency
A potential increase in assets. Under conservatism, gain contingencies are never accrued: they are only disclosed in the notes.

Why Do Loss Contingencies Matter?

1
Financial statement accuracy: Unrecorded losses can overstate net income and assets, misleading investors.
2
Regulatory compliance: The SEC and auditors scrutinize contingency disclosures: errors can trigger restatements.
3
CPA exam tested: Loss contingencies appear on virtually every FAR exam, testing your ability to classify and record them.

The Three Likelihood Categories

Probable
The future event is likely to occur. Think: "more likely than not" in practice.
Reasonably Possible
The chance is more than remote but less than likely. Falls in the middle zone.
Remote
The chance is slight. The future event is unlikely to occur.

The Decision Framework

Loss Contingency? Probable? YES NO Estimable? YES ACCRUE + Disclose NO DISCLOSE Only Reasonably Possible? YES DISCLOSE Only NO NOTHING (Remote) Accrue + Disclose Disclose Only No Action

Two Conditions for Accrual

Under ASC 450-20, a loss contingency must be accrued (recorded as a liability and expense) when both of these conditions are met:

1
Probable: It is probable that an asset has been impaired or a liability has been incurred at the balance sheet date.
2
Reasonably Estimable: The amount of the loss can be reasonably estimated.

Recording the Journal Entry

When both conditions are met, the entity records:

Account Debit Credit Loss from Lawsuit XXX Estimated Liability XXX (Loss appears on Income Statement; Liability appears on Balance Sheet)

Accrue vs. Disclose vs. Ignore

Scenario Accrue? Disclose?
Probable + Estimable ✓ Yes ✓ Yes
Probable + Not Estimable ✕ No ✓ Yes
Reasonably Possible ✕ No ✓ Yes
Remote ✕ No ✕ No*

Step-by-Step Approach

1
Identify the contingency: Is there an existing condition involving uncertainty about a potential loss?
2
Assess likelihood: Is the loss probable, reasonably possible, or remote?
3
Estimate the amount: Can the loss be reasonably estimated? Is there a single best estimate or a range?
4
Apply the rule: If both conditions met: accrue. If only probable or only reasonably possible: disclose. If remote: generally no action.
5
Check for exceptions: Guarantee obligations, unasserted claims, and subsequent events may alter treatment.

Example 1: Pending Lawsuit

Acme Corp. is being sued for \( \$500{,}000 \). Legal counsel advises the loss is probable and estimable at \( \$500{,}000 \).

Account Debit Credit Lawsuit Loss
\(500{,}000\)
Estimated Liability
\(500{,}000\)
Both conditions met: Probable ✓ Estimable ✓ → Accrue

Example 2: Range Estimate

Beta Inc. faces a probable environmental cleanup. Legal counsel estimates the cost at between \( \$200{,}000 \) and \( \$600{,}000 \), with no best estimate within that range.

1
Probable? ✓ Yes
2
Estimable? ✓ Yes (a range exists)
3
Best estimate within range? ✕ No

Example 3: Disclosure Only

Gamma Corp. is involved in patent litigation. Management believes the outcome is reasonably possible (not probable). Estimated damages range from \( \$100{,}000 \) to \( \$300{,}000 \).

Likelihood
Reasonably possible: not high enough for accrual, but more than remote.
Treatment
No journal entry. Disclose the nature and estimated range in footnotes.

Common Mistakes

✕ Accruing Gain Contingencies
Gains are never accrued: only disclosed. Conservatism forbids recording gains before realization.
✕ Accruing the Maximum of a Range
When no best estimate exists, accrue the minimum of the range, not the maximum or midpoint.
✕ Ignoring Remote Guarantees
Guarantees of others' debts must be disclosed even when the likelihood of loss is remote.

Summary: Quick Reference

Likelihood Estimable Not Estimable
Probable Accrue + Disclose Disclose Only
Reasonably Possible Disclose Only Disclose Only
Remote No Action* No Action*

Question 1 of 5

A company is being sued. Legal counsel states the loss is probable and can be reasonably estimated at \( \$750{,}000 \). What should the company do?

Question 2 of 5

A loss contingency is probable, but the amount cannot be reasonably estimated. What is the correct treatment?

Question 3 of 5

An entity estimates a probable loss between \( \$100{,}000 \) and \( \$400{,}000 \), with no amount in the range more likely than another. What amount should be accrued?

Question 4 of 5

Which of the following loss contingencies generally requires no disclosure in the financial statements?

Question 5 of 5

A company receives notice it will likely win a \( \$2{,}000{,}000 \) lawsuit. The gain is probable and estimable. How should this be treated?