01 / 21

Permanent & Temporary
Differences

Master the distinction between items that never reverse and those that reverse over time: the foundation of income tax accounting under ASC 740.

CPA FAR

What Are Book-Tax Differences?

Companies prepare two sets of income calculations: book income (per GAAP) and taxable income (per the Internal Revenue Code). The gap between these two numbers creates book-tax differences.

Two Categories of Differences

Permanent Differences
Items recognized for book OR tax purposes, but never both. They never reverse and do not create deferred taxes.
Temporary Differences
Items recognized for both book and tax, but in different periods. They reverse over time and do create deferred taxes.

Why Does This Matter?

Book Income (GAAP Pretax) Taxable Income (IRC / Tax Return) GAP Permanent Diff. Affects ETR only Temporary Diff. Creates DTA / DTL Effective Tax Rate Balance Sheet DTAs/DTLs

Permanent differences change the effective tax rate but create no deferred items. Temporary differences create deferred tax assets (DTAs) or deferred tax liabilities (DTLs) on the balance sheet.

Permanent Differences: The Core Rule

1
Tax-exempt interest: Municipal bond interest is book income but is never taxed.
2
Life insurance proceeds: Proceeds on officer life insurance are book income but not taxable.
3
Non-deductible fines/penalties: Expensed on books but never deductible for tax.
4
Meals & entertainment (50% disallowed): The disallowed portion is a permanent difference.

Temporary Differences: The Core Rule

1
Depreciation: Accelerated for tax (MACRS) vs. straight-line for books.
2
Warranty expense: Accrued on books when sold; deducted for tax when paid.
3
Unearned revenue: Taxed when cash received; recognized as book revenue when earned.
4
Bad debt expense: Estimated on books; deducted for tax when written off.

Permanent vs. Temporary

Permanent Temporary
Reversal Never reverses Reverses in future
Creates DTA/DTL? No Yes
Affects ETR? Yes No (ETR stays at statutory rate)
Reconciliation Rate reconciliation Deferred tax provision
Example Municipal bond interest Depreciation timing diff.

DTA vs. DTL: Which One?

Temporary Difference Book basis vs. Tax basis Deferred Tax Asset Future tax benefit
\( \text{Book Exp.} > \text{Tax Ded.} \) now
Deferred Tax Liability Future tax payment
\( \text{Tax Ded.} > \text{Book Exp.} \) now
EXAMPLES Warranty accrual Bad debt allowance Unearned revenue (taxed early) EXAMPLES Accelerated depreciation Installment sales Prepaid expenses (deducted early)

The Key Formulas

Taxable Income
$$ \begin{array}{l} \text{Book pretax income} \\ \pm \text{ Permanent differences} \\ \pm \text{ Temporary differences} \\ \hline = \textbf{Taxable income} \end{array} $$
Income Tax Expense
$$ \begin{array}{l} \text{Current tax expense} \\ + \text{ Deferred tax expense (benefit)} \\ \hline = \textbf{Total income tax expense} \end{array} $$

How to Apply the Rules

1
Start with book pretax income. This is your GAAP income before tax provision.
2
Identify each difference. Ask: "Will this ever appear on the tax return?" If no, it is permanent. If yes but in a different period, it is temporary.
3
Adjust to taxable income. Add back non-deductible expenses, subtract exempt income, and adjust for timing differences.
4
Compute current tax. Taxable income \(\times\) enacted tax rate.
5
Compute deferred tax. Temporary difference \(\times\) enacted tax rate = DTA or DTL. Determine if net change is expense or benefit.
6
Record the journal entry. Dr. Income Tax Expense, Cr. Income Tax Payable (current), and Dr./Cr. DTA or DTL.

Example 1: Permanent Difference

Alpha Corp. has book pretax income of \(\$500{,}000\). Included in this amount is \(\$20{,}000\) of municipal bond interest (tax-exempt). The enacted tax rate is 21%.

1
Taxable income: \(\$500{,}000 - \$20{,}000 = \$480{,}000\). The exempt interest is subtracted (permanent: never taxed).
2
Current tax expense: \(\$480{,}000 \times 21\% = \$100{,}800\).
3
Deferred tax: \(\$0\). No temporary difference exists, so no DTA or DTL.
4
Total tax expense: \(\$100{,}800\). Effective tax rate: \(\frac{\$100{,}800}{\$500{,}000} = 20.16\%\) (less than 21% because of the permanent difference).

Example 2: Temporary Difference

Beta Corp. has book pretax income of \(\$600{,}000\). Book depreciation is \(\$40{,}000\) but tax depreciation (MACRS) is \(\$70{,}000\). Tax rate: 21%. No other differences exist.

1
Temporary difference: Tax depreciation exceeds book by \(\$70{,}000 - \$40{,}000 = \$30{,}000\).
2
Taxable income: \(\$600{,}000 - \$30{,}000 = \$570{,}000\). (Extra tax deduction reduces taxable income now.)
3
Current tax: \(\$570{,}000 \times 21\% = \$119{,}700\).
4
Deferred tax liability: \(\$30{,}000 \times 21\% = \$6{,}300\). (Future taxable amount: this deduction reverses.)
5
Total tax expense: \(\$119{,}700 + \$6{,}300 = \$126{,}000\). This equals \(\$600{,}000 \times 21\%\): the ETR stays at the statutory rate.

Example 3: Both Together

Gamma Corp. reports book pretax income of \(\$800{,}000\). It includes \(\$10{,}000\) of tax-exempt interest (permanent) and has a \(\$50{,}000\) excess tax depreciation (temporary). Tax rate: 21%.

1
Taxable income: \(\$800{,}000 - \$10{,}000 - \$50{,}000 = \$740{,}000\).
2
Current tax: \(\$740{,}000 \times 21\% = \$155{,}400\).
3
Deferred tax liability: \(\$50{,}000 \times 21\% = \$10{,}500\). (Only the temporary difference creates a DTL.)
4
Total tax expense: \(\$155{,}400 + \$10{,}500 = \$165{,}900\). ETR: \(\frac{\$165{,}900}{\$800{,}000} = 20.74\%\). Below 21% because of the permanent difference.

The Journal Entry

Using Gamma Corp. from Example 3:

Dr
Income Tax Expense \(\$165{,}900\)
Cr
Income Tax Payable \(\$155{,}400\) (current portion)
Cr
Deferred Tax Liability \(\$10{,}500\) (temporary difference portion)

Effective Tax Rate Reconciliation

Permanent differences cause the effective tax rate to differ from the statutory rate. Here is how the reconciliation works:

Item Rate Amount
Statutory rate applied to pretax income 21.00% \(\$168{,}000\)
Tax-exempt interest (\(\$10{,}000 \times 21\%\)) (0.26%) (\(\$2{,}100\))
Effective rate / Total expense 20.74% \(\$165{,}900\)

Common Mistakes

Mistake: Creating DTAs for Permanent Items
Municipal bond interest or fines will never reverse. Recording a deferred tax asset or liability for these items is always wrong.
Mistake: Using the Wrong Tax Rate
Deferred taxes use the enacted future rate, not the current year's rate. If a rate change is enacted, you must remeasure all DTAs and DTLs.
Mistake: Confusing DTA and DTL
If \( \text{book expense} > \text{tax deduction} \) now, the extra deduction comes later (\( \text{future benefit} = \text{DTA} \)). If \( \text{tax deduction} > \text{book expense} \) now, you pay more later (DTL).

Question 1 of 5

A company earns \(\$15{,}000\) of municipal bond interest. How should this be treated for income tax purposes?

Question 2 of 5

Delta Corp. uses straight-line depreciation for books and MACRS for tax. The excess tax depreciation in Year 1 is \(\$25{,}000\). At a 21% tax rate, what deferred tax item is created?

Question 3 of 5

A company pays a \(\$30{,}000\) government fine that is not deductible for tax purposes. What is the effect on the effective tax rate (ETR)?

Question 4 of 5

Epsilon Corp. accrues \(\$40{,}000\) in warranty expense for books in Year 1 but deducts warranty costs for tax only when paid in Year 2. At 21%, what is recorded in Year 1?

Question 5 of 5

Zeta Corp. has book pretax income of \(\$1{,}000{,}000\). It includes \(\$50{,}000\) of tax-exempt interest and has a \(\$100{,}000\) temporary difference (excess tax depreciation). At 21%, what is the total income tax expense?