01 / 21

Account For
Changes In Estimates

Master how businesses revise accounting estimates prospectively, understand the journal entries, and learn why this differs from error corrections and policy changes.

CPA FAR

What Is a Change in Estimate?

A change in accounting estimate occurs when new information, experience, or developments cause a company to revise a previously established estimate used in financial reporting. These revisions are a normal part of accounting: they do not indicate errors in prior periods.

Common Examples of Estimate Changes

Useful Life
Revising how many years an asset will serve the company
Salvage Value
Updating the expected residual value at the end of the asset's useful life
Bad Debts
Changing the estimated percentage of uncollectible receivables

Why Prospective Treatment?

Estimates are inherently uncertain. When a company revises an estimate, it is not correcting a mistake: the original estimate was the best available at the time. Therefore, prior-period financial statements remain valid and should not be changed.

Prior Periods No restatement Revision Current + Future Apply new estimate

The Core Rule: ASC 250

1
Identify the change: Determine that new information warrants revising a previously used estimate.
2
Apply prospectively: Adjust the accounting in the current period and future periods only.
3
Do not restate: Prior financial statements remain unchanged. No cumulative catch-up adjustments.
4
Disclose: If material, disclose the nature and amount of the change in the period of revision.

Revised Depreciation Formula

When the useful life or salvage value of an asset changes, compute the new annual depreciation using the asset's current book value at the date of revision:

Current Book Value Cost - Accum. Depr. − New Salvage Value Revised estimate New Remaining Life From date of revision

Three Types of Accounting Changes

Change in Estimate Change in Policy Error Correction
Standard ASC 250 ASC 250 ASC 250
Treatment Prospective Retrospective Restatement
Prior Periods Not restated Restated Restated
Example Useful life change FIFO to weighted-average Math error found

Step-by-Step Application

1
Compute current book value: Original cost minus accumulated depreciation to date of the change.
2
Determine new estimates: Identify the revised salvage value and/or remaining useful life.
3
Calculate new depreciation: \(\dfrac{\text{Book Value} - \text{New Salvage}}{\text{New Remaining Life}}\)
4
Record the entry: Debit Depreciation Expense, Credit Accumulated Depreciation at the new amount each period.
5
Disclose if material: Note the nature of the change and its effect on income in the financial statement footnotes.

Example 1: Useful Life Revision

A machine was purchased for \(\$120{,}000\) with a \(\$10{,}000\) salvage value and a 10-year useful life using straight-line depreciation. After 4 years, the company revises the total useful life to 8 years (4 remaining). Salvage value stays the same.

Example 1: Journal Entry

Starting in Year 5, the company records the revised depreciation each year:

Account Debit Credit Depreciation Expense $16,500 Accumulated Depreciation $16,500 Recorded each year for the remaining 4 years

Example 2: Salvage + Life Change

Equipment cost: \(\$200{,}000\). Original salvage: \(\$20{,}000\). Original life: 10 years. After 6 years, salvage is revised to \(\$8{,}000\) and remaining life is revised to 6 more years.

Example 3: Bad Debt Estimate

A company estimated bad debt expense at 2% of credit sales. In Year 3, based on new collection data, they revise this to 3.5%. Year 3 credit sales are \(\$500{,}000\).

Old Estimate
\(2\% \times \$500{,}000 = \$10{,}000\)
New Estimate
\(3.5\% \times \$500{,}000 = \$17{,}500\)

Visualizing the Depreciation Shift

Book Value ($) Year 120k 90k 60k 30k 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Revision Original ($11k/yr) Revised ($16.5k/yr)

Disclosure Requirements

When a change in estimate is material, the company must disclose:

1
Nature of the change: What estimate was revised and why.
2
Effect on income: The impact on income from continuing operations, net income, and earnings per share for the current period.
3
Future effect: If reasonably estimable, disclose the expected impact on future periods.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Restating Prior Periods
Changes in estimates are never applied retrospectively. Only error corrections and policy changes require restatement.
Using Original Cost in Formula
The numerator uses current book value (cost minus accumulated depreciation), not the original cost of the asset.
Confusing with Error Correction
A bad estimate is not an error. Errors involve mathematical mistakes or misapplication of GAAP, not revised judgments.

Summary Reference Table

Topic Key Point
Standard ASC 250
Treatment Prospective only
Formula \(\dfrac{\text{BV} - \text{New Salvage}}{\text{New Remaining Life}}\)
Prior Periods Not restated
Depr. Method Change Treated as change in estimate
Disclosure Nature, effect on income, future impact
Examples Useful life, salvage, bad debts, warranties

Question 1 of 5

A company changes the estimated useful life of a building from 40 years to 30 years. How should this change be accounted for?

Question 2 of 5

Equipment cost \(\$80{,}000\) with \(\$5{,}000\) salvage and a 10-year life. After 5 years, the remaining life is revised to 3 years (salvage unchanged). What is the new annual depreciation?

Question 3 of 5

Which of the following is not an example of a change in accounting estimate?

Question 4 of 5

When a company changes its depreciation method from double-declining balance to straight-line, how is this treated under U.S. GAAP?

Question 5 of 5

A machine with a book value of \(\$60{,}000\) has its salvage value revised from \(\$10{,}000\) to \(\$0\) with 4 years of remaining useful life. What is the new annual depreciation expense?