01 / 21

Changes in
Accounting Principle

Learn how to recognize, apply, and report changes in accounting principle under ASC 250, including retrospective application and its impact on financial statements.

CPA FAR

What Is an Accounting Principle?

An accounting principle is a specific recognition, measurement, or presentation method used to prepare financial statements. Examples include inventory costing methods (FIFO vs. weighted average) and depreciation methods.

FIFO
First-In, First-Out: oldest costs flow to COGS first
Weighted Average
Average cost per unit applied to all inventory equally

Why Do Companies Change Principles?

1
New GAAP standard issued: A new ASU mandates a different method, requiring adoption by all entities.
2
Preferable method available: Management determines a new method better represents economic reality.
3
Comparability improvement: Aligning with industry peers enhances comparability for investors.

The ASC 250 Framework

ASC 250: Accounting Changes Change in Principle Retrospective Change in Estimate Prospective Error Correction Restatement Adjust all prior periods as if new principle had always been used ✓ Our focus today Affect current and future periods only (no retrospective adj.) Restate prior period financials to correct the error

The Core Rule: Retrospective Application

Under ASC 250-10-45-5, a change in accounting principle must be reported through retrospective application to all prior periods presented, unless it is impracticable to do so.

Principle vs. Estimate vs. Error

Change in Principle Change in Estimate Error Correction
Definition Switch from one GAAP method to another Revision of an estimate (e.g., useful life) Correction of a mistake in prior statements
Treatment Retrospective Prospective Restatement
Retained Earnings Adjust opening balance No adjustment Adjust opening balance
Disclosure Nature, justification, effect Nature, effect on income Nature, effect on each line item

When Principle and Estimate Are Inseparable

Sometimes a change in accounting principle is inseparable from a change in estimate. For example, switching from straight-line to double-declining depreciation involves both a new principle and a new estimate of the pattern of benefit consumption.

Separable
FIFO to weighted average: apply retrospectively
Inseparable
SL to DDB depreciation: apply prospectively

How to Apply Retrospective Application

1
Compute the cumulative effect: Determine the difference between retained earnings under the old principle and the new principle as of the beginning of the earliest period presented.
2
Adjust opening retained earnings: Record the cumulative effect (net of tax) as an adjustment to the opening balance of retained earnings for the earliest period presented.
3
Recast prior period financials: Present all prior periods as if the new principle had always been used.
4
Disclose: Nature of change, justification for preferability, effect on income and EPS for each period presented.

Example 1: FIFO to Weighted Average

Apex Corp. changes from FIFO to weighted average for inventory in 2024. Comparative statements show 2023 and 2024. The tax rate is \(25\%\).

Pre-2023 2023 2024 Change adopted Cumulative Effect COGS diff: $40,000 Tax (25%): $10,000 Net: $30,000 2023 Recast Recalculate COGS using weighted avg. as if always used 2024 Forward Apply weighted avg. directly: no special adjustment needed

Example 1: Journal Entry

The cumulative pretax effect of switching from FIFO to weighted average increases COGS by \(\$40{,}000\) for all periods before 2023. At a \(25\%\) tax rate, the net-of-tax adjustment is \(\$30{,}000\).

Dr
Retained Earnings: \(\$30{,}000\) (net-of-tax cumulative effect)
Dr
Deferred Tax Asset: \(\$10{,}000\) (tax effect: \(\$40{,}000 \times 25\%\))
Cr
Inventory: \(\$40{,}000\) (pretax COGS difference)

Example 2: Revenue Recognition Method Change

BuildMax Inc. changes its revenue recognition method for long-term contracts in 2024. The company presents comparative statements for 2022, 2023, and 2024.

2021 2022 2023 2024 Cumulative Effect Pre-2022 diff: $120K Net of tax: $90K Recast 2022 Recalculate revenue under new method Recast 2023 Recalculate revenue under new method Required Disclosures Nature and reason for change, effect on net income, effect on EPS, cumulative effect on retained earnings

The Impracticability Exception

Retrospective application is impracticable when the entity cannot determine the effects on prior periods despite making every reasonable effort. ASC 250 defines three conditions:

1
Unattainable assumptions: The effects depend on assumptions about management intent that cannot be independently verified for prior periods.
2
Missing information: Significant estimates required for the calculation cannot be objectively determined for prior periods because data was not collected.
3
Excessive effort: The entity cannot determine the period-specific effects without hindsight estimates or assumptions not available at the time.

Disclosure Requirements

Nature
Describe the old and new accounting principles and why the change was made
Justification
Explain why the new principle is preferable to the old one
Financial Effect
Report effect on income from continuing operations, net income, and EPS for each period

Direct vs. Indirect Effects

Direct Effects Applied retrospectively Examples: - Inventory valuation diff - COGS recalculation - Tax effect of change - Revenue restatement Adjust prior periods vs. Indirect Effects Recognized currently Examples: - Profit-sharing bonuses - Royalty payments tied to reported income - Contract-based fees Record in period of change

Common Mistakes to Avoid

✕ Prospective Instead of Retrospective
Applying a change in principle prospectively instead of retrospectively (unless impracticable or inseparable from estimate)
✕ Forgetting Tax Effects
Computing the cumulative effect on a pretax basis without recording the deferred tax asset or liability
✕ Indirect Effects Retroactively
Applying indirect effects (like bonus adjustments) retrospectively instead of recognizing them in the period of change

Summary Comparison

Change in Principle Principle + Estimate
Example FIFO to weighted average Straight-line to DDB
Application Retrospective Prospective
Retained Earnings Cumulative adj. (net of tax) No adjustment
Prior Period F/S Recast as presented Not restated
Disclosure Nature, justification, EPS effect Nature, current period effect
Impracticable? Apply prospectively from earliest date N/A (already prospective)

Question 1 of 5

Under ASC 250, a change in accounting principle is generally accounted for using which method?

Question 2 of 5

A company switches from straight-line depreciation to double-declining balance. How should this change be treated?

Question 3 of 5

When applying a change in accounting principle retrospectively, where is the cumulative effect for periods before those presented reported?

Question 4 of 5

Apex Corp. changes inventory methods. The pretax cumulative effect is \(\$80{,}000\) and the tax rate is \(25\%\). What is the net-of-tax cumulative adjustment to retained earnings?

Question 5 of 5

Which of the following is an example of an indirect effect of a change in accounting principle?