Fraud and
Compliance Rules
Learn to identify fraud, abuse, HIPAA protections, ABNs, and NCCI edit rules that keep medical coding honest and legal.
What is Fraud & Abuse?
In medical coding, two terms describe wrongful billing. The key difference is intent. Fraud is done knowingly and willfully. Abuse happens without that intent but still costs the system money.
Key Compliance Terms
Why Compliance Matters
Improper coding can lead to denied claims, repayments, large fines, and even criminal charges. The False Claims Act allows penalties of thousands of dollars per false claim.
The Intent Rule
The single test that separates fraud from abuse is whether the act was done knowingly. Think of it as a simple logical statement:
HIPAA Core Rule
HIPAA's Privacy Rule protects Protected Health Information (PHI). PHI can only be shared for Treatment, Payment, and Operations (TPO) — or with patient authorization.
The ABN Rule
An Advance Beneficiary Notice (ABN) is given to a Medicare patient before a service that Medicare likely won't cover. It lets the patient choose whether to accept financial responsibility.
Fraud vs Abuse
| Fraud | Abuse | |
|---|---|---|
| Intent | Knowing & willful | No proven intent |
| Example | Billing for services never given | Routinely unbundling codes |
| Proof needed | Yes — intent must be shown | No — pattern is enough |
| Penalty | Criminal + civil | Civil, repayment |
NCCI Edits
NCCI edits prevent improper code pairs. The most common is the unbundling edit: a comprehensive code already includes its component services, so you can't bill them separately.
How to Apply the Rules
Example 1: Fraud or Abuse?
A coder knowingly reports a higher-level office visit code than the documentation supports to earn more reimbursement. This is called upcoding.
Example 2: NCCI Edit
A provider bills a surgical procedure code and a separate code for the routine wound closure that is already included in the surgery. NCCI flags this as unbundling.
Example 3: ABN Decision
A patient wants a screening that Medicare covers only once per year, and they had it 6 months ago. Medicare will likely deny it.
Common Mistakes
Summary Table
| Rule | Purpose | Key Point |
|---|---|---|
| HIPAA | Protect privacy | Share PHI only for TPO |
| ABN | Inform patient | Issue before service |
| NCCI | Correct coding | No improper unbundling |
| Fraud | Stop intentional theft | Requires intent |
| Abuse | Stop wasteful billing | No intent needed |
Question 1 of 5
What single factor separates fraud from abuse?
Question 2 of 5
When must an ABN be given to a Medicare patient?
Question 3 of 5
Under HIPAA, PHI may be shared without authorization for which purposes?
Question 4 of 5
Billing separately for a service already included in a comprehensive code is called:
Question 5 of 5
A coder knowingly reports a higher visit level than documented. This is: