Experimental Design: Controls, Replicates, and Confounds - Biochemistry
- Treated samples are always processed in the morning and controls in the afternoon. What design flaw is this?
- Confounding. Processing time varies with treatment, so any difference could come from the time of processing rather than the treatment.
- A researcher varies temperature and measures enzyme activity at each setting. Which is the independent variable?
- Temperature. It is set by the researcher, and enzyme activity is the measured dependent variable.
- A gene is knocked down with an siRNA. What is the appropriate negative control?
- A non-targeting (scrambled) siRNA delivered the same way, which controls for effects of transfection and of siRNA itself.
- What is a biological replicate?
- An independent sample from a separate biological source (a different culture, animal or donor), which captures biological variability.
- What is a confounding variable?
- A factor that differs between groups along with the treatment and also affects the outcome, so its effect cannot be separated from the treatment's.
- What is the purpose of a positive control in an experiment?
- To confirm the assay can detect a known effect, so a negative result is not simply a failed assay (a false negative).
- What is the purpose of a negative control in an experiment?
- To show the result expected when the effect is absent, so background signal or false positives can be recognized.
- A drug is dissolved in DMSO before being added to cells. What should the control cells receive?
- The same volume of DMSO without the drug (a vehicle control), so any effect of the solvent itself is accounted for.
- Why are technical replicates alone not enough to generalize a result?
- They are repeated measurements of the same sample, so they capture measurement error but not biological variability between samples.
- What is the main purpose of randomly assigning samples to treatment groups?
- To spread unknown or unmeasured confounding factors evenly across groups so they do not systematically bias the comparison.
- Why is a housekeeping gene measured alongside a target gene in qPCR?
- It serves as a normalization control that corrects for differences in RNA input and reverse transcription between samples.
- What bias does blinding the person scoring the results protect against?
- Observer (measurement) bias, where knowing a sample's group influences how its result is judged or recorded.