01 / 20

Warranty Liability
Express & Implied

Learn how the UCC creates seller promises about goods — and how to spot an express warranty versus an implied one on the bar exam.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is a Warranty?

A warranty is a seller's assurance or promise about the quality, characteristics, or title of goods being sold. If the goods fail to meet that promise, the buyer may sue the seller for breach of warranty.

Two Families of Warranties

Express Warranties
Created by the seller's words or conduct — affirmations, descriptions, samples, or models that become part of the bargain.
Implied Warranties
Imposed by law automatically — the seller need not say anything for them to attach to the sale.

Mapping the Warranty Landscape

Warranties Express Implied Affirmation, description, sample, or model Merchantability (merchant seller) Fitness for a Particular Purpose

Rule: Express Warranty (UCC § 2-313)

An express warranty is created when a seller makes a statement of fact or promise, gives a description, or provides a sample/model that becomes part of the basis of the bargain.

1
Affirmation of fact or promise relating to the goods.
2
Description of the goods (e.g., "stainless steel").
3
Sample or model shown to the buyer.

Implied Warranty of Merchantability

Under UCC § 2-314, this warranty is implied only when the seller is a merchant who deals in goods of that kind. The goods must be fit for their ordinary purpose.

Implied Warranty of Fitness for a Particular Purpose

Under UCC § 2-315, this warranty arises when the seller has reason to know the buyer's particular purpose and that the buyer is relying on the seller's skill or judgment to select suitable goods.

1
Seller knows the buyer's particular purpose.
2
Buyer relies on the seller's expertise to choose the goods.

Express vs. Implied: The Core Test

Express
Comes from the seller's own words, descriptions, or samples. Look for what the seller affirmatively communicated.
Implied
Comes from operation of law. Look for a merchant seller (merchantability) or buyer reliance (fitness).

How to Analyze a Warranty Question

1
Is it a sale of goods? If yes, the UCC applies.
2
Did the seller say or show anything? Test for an express warranty (fact vs. puffery).
3
Is the seller a merchant? If yes, merchantability is implied.
4
Did the buyer rely on the seller's judgment for a particular use? If yes, fitness applies.
5
Was the warranty breached? Compare the promise to the actual goods.

Worked Example: The Description

A camera shop's catalog describes a lens as "weatherproof, sealed against rain." The buyer purchases it; the first time it rains, water leaks in and ruins the lens.

Worked Example: The Merchant

A grocery store sells canned soup. A buyer opens a can and finds it spoiled and inedible, with no special promise about the soup made by the store.

Worked Example: The Reliance

A hiker tells a hardware clerk, "I need boots that will keep my feet dry on a 3-day glacier trek." The clerk picks a pair. They soak through on day one because they are casual hiking boots unsuited for glaciers.

Common Mistakes

✕ Treating Puffery as Express
"Best deal in town" is opinion, not a factual affirmation — no express warranty.
✕ Requiring Merchant for Fitness
Fitness for a particular purpose needs reliance, not merchant status — any seller can give it.
✕ Applying Merchantability to Casual Sellers
A private, one-time seller is not a merchant — no implied merchantability warranty.

Summary Comparison

Express Merchantability Fitness
UCC Section§ 2-313§ 2-314§ 2-315
SourceSeller's wordsLawLaw
Merchant required?NoYesNo
Buyer reliance?BargainNoYes

A Note on Disclaimers

Implied warranties can often be disclaimed. Phrases like "as is" or "with all faults" disclaim implied warranties. To specifically disclaim merchantability in writing, the term "merchantability" must be mentioned and conspicuous.

Question 1 of 5

A car dealer tells a buyer, "This engine has only 20,000 miles on it." The statement is false. What warranty, if any, is created?

Question 2 of 5

Which seller is required for the implied warranty of merchantability to attach?

Question 3 of 5

A buyer tells a paint clerk she needs paint that will adhere to a metal boat hull below the waterline. The clerk selects a paint that peels off underwater. Which warranty is breached?

Question 4 of 5

A neighbor sells his used bicycle in a one-time private sale, saying nothing about its quality. The brakes fail soon after. Which is correct?

Question 5 of 5

Which statement is most likely non-actionable puffery rather than an express warranty?