01 / 20

Venue
and Transfer

Where can a federal case properly be heard, and when can it move? Master venue rules and the three transfer statutes.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is Venue?

Venue answers a simple question: which particular federal district court is the proper place to file a lawsuit. Many districts may have personal jurisdiction, but venue narrows the choice to the most convenient and connected forum.

Three Doors Before Trial

Subject-Matter Jurisdiction Can court hear it? Personal Jurisdiction Power over party? Venue Right district? Proper Forum

Key Terms

District
A federal judicial subdivision. Every state has at least one; large states have several.
Resides
For an individual, the district of domicile. For a corporation, where it is subject to personal jurisdiction.
Transfer
Moving a case from one federal district to another while keeping it in the federal system.

The General Venue Rule

Under 28 U.S.C. § 1391(b), venue is proper in a district where either basis is met:

1
Residence basis: Any district where any defendant resides, if all defendants reside in the same state.
2
Events basis: Any district where a substantial part of the events or omissions giving rise to the claim occurred, or where the property is located.

The Fallback Rule

If no district qualifies under either the residence or events basis, § 1391(b)(3) provides a safety net:

Probability that a federal action has at least one proper venue is essentially \( P = 1 \) because the fallback nearly always captures a district.

Residence Basis vs. Events Basis

Residence Events
Looks atWhere defendants liveWhere the dispute arose
Multiple defendantsMust all reside in same stateNo residence requirement
TriggerDefendant's domicile/PJSubstantial part of events
Property casesN/AWhere property sits

How to Analyze Venue

1
Identify the district where the case was filed.
2
Check residence: Do all defendants reside in the forum state? If so, is one in this district?
3
Check events: Did a substantial part of the claim arise here?
4
If both fail, apply the fallback rule.
5
If venue improper, consider transfer or dismissal under § 1406.

Three Transfer Statutes

§ 1404(a)
Venue is proper, but another district is more convenient. Transfer for convenience.
§ 1406(a)
Venue is improper. Court may transfer to a proper district or dismiss.
§ 1631
Court lacks jurisdiction. Transfer to cure the jurisdictional defect.

§ 1404 vs. § 1406

Venue PROPER but inconvenient Venue IMPROPER wrong district § 1404(a) § 1406(a) Transferor law follows the case Transferee law applies fresh

Worked Example 1

A driver from the Northern District of Illinois sues a driver from the Southern District of Illinois over a crash that happened in the Central District of Illinois. Where is venue proper?

1
Residence: The lone defendant resides in the Southern District. ✓
2
Events: The crash occurred in the Central District. ✓

Worked Example 2

Plaintiff files in a district where venue is proper, but every witness, the defendant, and all evidence are located 1,000 miles away. Defendant moves to transfer. Which statute?

Worked Example 3

A plaintiff mistakenly files in a district where no defendant resides and no events occurred. The defendant objects to venue. What can the court do?

1
Venue is improper — both bases fail and no fallback district matches here.
2
Under § 1406(a), the court may dismiss or, in the interest of justice, transfer to a proper district.

Common Mistakes

✕ Confusing venue with jurisdiction
A court can have personal jurisdiction yet still be an improper venue.
✕ Forgetting the same-state rule
Residence venue requires all defendants to reside in the forum state.
✕ Mixing up § 1404 and § 1406
1404 is for proper venue; 1406 is for improper venue.
✕ Ignoring choice-of-law transfer
In § 1404, transferor law follows; in § 1406, it does not.

Transfer Summary

Statute Venue? Choice of Law
§ 1404(a)Proper, inconvenientTransferor follows
§ 1406(a)ImproperTransferee applies
§ 1631Jurisdiction lackingTransferee applies

Question 1 of 5

Venue determines which of the following?

Question 2 of 5

Under § 1391(b), residence-based venue requires that:

Question 3 of 5

Which statute governs the defendant's motion?

Question 4 of 5

In a § 1404(a) transfer, whose choice-of-law rules apply after the case moves?

Question 5 of 5

A plaintiff files in a district where no defendant resides and no events occurred. The court may best: