01 / 20

Unprotected
Speech

The First Amendment shields most expression, but some categories receive no protection at all. Learn to spot them.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

The Free Speech Default

The First Amendment provides that government "shall make no law... abridging the freedom of speech." The default rule is that content-based restrictions on speech face strict scrutiny and are presumptively invalid.

Protected vs. Unprotected

Protected Speech (strict scrutiny applies) Unprotected Categories (no protection)

The Core Categories

1
Incitement to imminent lawless action
2
Fighting words and true threats
3
Obscenity (the Miller test)
4
Defamation of private/public figures
5
Child pornography

Incitement: The Brandenburg Test

Speech advocating illegal action is unprotected only if it satisfies all three prongs of Brandenburg v. Ohio (1969):

1
The speech is directed to inciting lawless action (intent)
2
The lawless action is imminent (not future or abstract)
3
The speech is likely to actually produce that action

Obscenity: The Miller Test

From Miller v. California (1973). Material is obscene only if all three are met:

1
The average person, applying contemporary community standards, would find it appeals to the prurient interest
2
It depicts sexual conduct in a patently offensive way
3
Taken as a whole, it lacks serious literary, artistic, political, or scientific value

Advocacy vs. Incitement

Protected Advocacy
"Someday, we should overthrow this unjust system." Abstract, future-oriented advocacy of ideas is fully protected.
Unprotected Incitement
"Grab those torches and burn that building down right now!" to an angry mob ready to act. Imminent and likely.

A Step-by-Step Approach

1
Identify the speech. What exactly is being said, written, or expressed?
2
Check for an unprotected category. Does it fit incitement, true threats, fighting words, obscenity, defamation, or child pornography?
3
Apply the specific test. e.g., Brandenburg for incitement, Miller for obscenity.
4
If no category fits, treat it as protected and analyze under the appropriate scrutiny level.

Worked Example: True Threats

Facts: A person posts online: "I am going to come to your house tonight and kill you," directed at a named individual, with detail showing seriousness.

Worked Example: Fighting Words

Facts: A protester walks up to a single bystander, face-to-face, and screams personal insults designed to provoke an immediate violent fight.

Worked Example: Defamation

Facts: A newspaper publishes a false statement that a city mayor accepted bribes. The mayor sues for defamation.

Common Mistakes

✕ Offensive = Unprotected
Speech is not unprotected merely because it is offensive, hateful, or disturbing. There is no "hate speech" exception.
✕ Skipping Imminence
Treating any call for illegal action as incitement. Brandenburg requires imminence AND likelihood, not abstract advocacy.
✕ Obscene = Indecent
Indecent or pornographic material is not automatically obscene. The Miller test must be satisfied in full.
✕ All False Speech Loses
A false statement is not automatically defamatory or unprotected; the right standard (e.g., actual malice) must be met.

Category Summary

CategoryGoverning Test / Case
IncitementBrandenburg: intent + imminent + likely
True ThreatsSerious intent to commit violence
Fighting WordsChaplinsky: immediate breach of peace (narrow)
ObscenityMiller test (3 prongs)
DefamationSullivan: actual malice (public figures)
Child PornographyCategorically unprotected

Quick Recap

Question 1 of 5

Which test governs whether speech advocating illegal action is unprotected incitement?

Question 2 of 5

A speaker tells a peaceful crowd: "Someday, this corrupt government should be overthrown." Is this protected?

Question 3 of 5

Under the Miller test, which is NOT required for material to be obscene?

Question 4 of 5

A newspaper falsely reports that a U.S. Senator took bribes. To recover for defamation, the Senator must prove:

Question 5 of 5

A city passes a law banning all speech that is "hateful and deeply offensive." This law is most likely:

You've Got This