Unconscionability
Procedural & Substantive
When a contract is so unfair and the bargaining so oppressive that courts refuse to enforce it.
What Is Unconscionability?
Unconscionability is a contract defense that allows a court to refuse enforcement of a contract, or a clause within it, when the agreement is so one-sided and unfair that it "shocks the conscience" of the court.
The Two Prongs
Most courts require both a procedural and a substantive component before declaring a contract unconscionable, though they apply a sliding scale.
Procedural Unconscionability
Substantive Unconscionability
Substantive unconscionability looks at the actual terms of the contract. Are the terms so harsh, oppressive, or one-sided that no fair-minded person would agree to them?
The Sliding Scale Rule
Distinguish from Other Defenses
How to Apply It
Court Remedies
Under UCC § 2-302, if a court finds a contract or clause unconscionable, it has three options:
Worked Example 1
Worked Example 2
Worked Example 3
Common Mistakes
Summary Comparison
| Procedural | Substantive | |
|---|---|---|
| Focus | The bargaining process | The contract terms |
| Key idea | Oppression & surprise | Harsh & one-sided |
| Example | Fine print, adhesion | Excessive price |
| Question | How was it made? | What does it say? |
| Test timing | At contract formation | |
| Decided by | The court (matter of law) | |
Question 1 of 5
Procedural unconscionability focuses primarily on which of the following?
Question 2 of 5
Under the prevailing approach, what must generally be shown to declare a contract unconscionable?
Question 3 of 5
At what point in time is unconscionability measured?
Question 4 of 5
A consumer with limited English signs a rent-to-own contract presented as a one-page "summary." Buried in a referenced separate document is a clause requiring the consumer to pay a total of $2,800 for a television with a retail value of $650, plus a waiver of all warranties. The salesperson never mentioned these terms and refused to let the consumer take the form home.
Which best describes this scenario?
Question 5 of 5
If a court finds a single clause unconscionable, which remedy is permitted under UCC § 2-302?