UCC Performance
Delivery & Risk of Loss
Master the Article 2 rules for tender of delivery, the perfect tender rule, and who bears the loss when goods are damaged or destroyed.
What is UCC Article 2?
The Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) Article 2 governs contracts for the sale of goods: tangible, movable property. It replaces common-law contract rules whenever goods are involved.
Three Core Terms
The Perfect Tender Rule
Under the UCC, if the goods or tender of delivery fail in any respect to conform to the contract, the buyer may:
Shipment vs. Destination Contracts
Risk of Loss: The Hierarchy
Always ask these questions in order to locate the risk:
No Carrier? Merchant Status Decides
When the buyer picks up goods directly (no shipment), the seller's merchant status sets the moment risk shifts:
Title vs. Risk of Loss
A classic trap: students assume risk follows title. Under the UCC, risk of loss is independent of title.
How to Analyze a Problem
Example 1: Shipment Contract
Seller in Ohio agrees to ship widgets "F.O.B. Cleveland" to Buyer in Texas. The truck crashes in Kentucky and the goods are destroyed.
Example 2: Buyer Pickup
A merchant appliance store sells Buyer a refrigerator. Buyer pays and says, "I'll come Saturday." On Friday night, a fire destroys the store and the fridge.
If the seller had been a non-merchant (e.g., a neighbor selling a used fridge), risk would have passed on tender — and the buyer would bear the loss.
Example 3: Breach Shifts Risk
Seller ships nonconforming goods. Before the buyer cures or accepts, a flood destroys them at the buyer's warehouse.
Common Mistakes
Risk of Loss Summary
| Scenario | Risk Passes When | |
|---|---|---|
| Shipment | F.O.B. seller | Goods given to carrier |
| Destination | F.O.B. buyer | Goods reach destination |
| Pickup (merchant) | Buyer picks up | Buyer's actual receipt |
| Pickup (non-merchant) | Buyer picks up | Tender of goods |
| Breach | Nonconforming tender | Stays on breaching party |
Question 1 of 5
In a shipment contract (F.O.B. seller's city), when does risk of loss pass to the buyer?
Question 2 of 5
A merchant seller sells goods for buyer pickup. With no carrier involved, risk passes when?
Question 3 of 5
Under the perfect tender rule, if goods fail in any respect to conform, the buyer may NOT:
Question 4 of 5
Seller tenders goods that fail to conform to the contract. Before the buyer accepts or the seller cures the defect, the goods are destroyed by an unexpected flood while in transit.
The buyer sues for a refund; the seller argues risk had already passed.
Who bears the risk of loss for the destroyed nonconforming goods?
Question 5 of 5
Which statement about title and risk of loss under the UCC is correct?