01 / 20

Tort Damages
Making the Plaintiff Whole

How courts calculate the money a defendant must pay to compensate for harm: \( D = C + P \), where \( C \) is compensatory and \( P \) is punitive.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Are Damages?

Damages are the monetary award a court orders a defendant to pay a plaintiff who has suffered a legal wrong. In tort law, the goal is to make the plaintiff whole: to restore them, as nearly as money can, to the position they would have occupied had the tort never occurred.

The Three Categories of Damages

Tort Damages Compensatory Repay the loss Nominal Token sum Punitive Punish the wrong Economic measurable Non-economic pain, suffering

Compensatory: Two Components

Economic (Special)
Objectively measurable losses with receipts or records: medical bills, lost wages, property repair, future earnings.
Non-Economic (General)
Intangible losses without a market price: pain and suffering, emotional distress, loss of enjoyment of life.

The Core Compensation Rule

A plaintiff recovers the full extent of losses proximately caused by the defendant's tort. The formal statement of total recovery is:

Each loss must be proven with reasonable certainty. Speculative or remote losses are not recoverable, and damages cannot be duplicated across categories.

Adjusting for Plaintiff's Fault

Under comparative negligence, the award is reduced by the plaintiff's own share of fault. If the plaintiff is \( f \) percent at fault, recovery is:

Recovered: 70% Barred: 30% $0 $100,000

Compensatory vs. Punitive

Compensatory Punitive
PurposeRestore the plaintiffPunish & deter
TriggerAny proven lossMalice or recklessness
MeasureActual loss \( E + N \)Proportional to wrong
AvailabilityAlwaysExceptional cases only

How to Calculate Damages

1
Total the economic loss \( E \). Add medical bills, lost wages, property damage, and proven future losses.
2
Add non-economic loss \( N \). Estimate pain, suffering, and emotional distress.
3
Subtract avoidable losses. Apply the duty to mitigate; remove costs the plaintiff could reasonably have avoided.
4
Apply comparative fault. Multiply by \( (1 - f) \) for the plaintiff's share of fault.
5
Add punitive damages \( P \) only if the conduct was malicious or reckless.

Example 1: Simple Compensatory

A negligent driver injures Pat. Medical bills are \( \$12{,}000 \), lost wages are \( \$8{,}000 \), and the jury awards \( \$15{,}000 \) for pain and suffering. No comparative fault applies. What is Pat's total recovery?

Example 2: With Comparative Fault

Sam suffers \( \$80{,}000 \) in economic loss and \( \$40{,}000 \) in non-economic loss. A jury finds Sam 25% at fault under pure comparative negligence. What does Sam recover?

Example 3: Adding Punitive

A company knowingly sells a defective product, injuring Lee. Compensatory damages total \( \$200{,}000 \). The jury, finding the conduct reckless, sets punitive damages at 3 times the compensatory award. What is the total?

Common Mistakes

✕ Double Counting
Awarding the same loss under two categories, such as counting lost wages in both economic and pain-and-suffering.
✕ Forgetting to Reduce
Failing to apply comparative fault before stating the final recovery figure.
✕ Speculative Losses
Awarding future damages not proven with reasonable certainty.
✕ Punitive by Default
Adding punitive damages where conduct was merely negligent, not malicious or reckless.

Damages Summary

Type Symbol When Awarded
Economic\( E \)Provable financial loss
Non-economic\( N \)Pain & suffering
Compensatory\( C = E + N \)Any proven harm
Nominal—Wrong but no loss
Punitive\( P \)Malice / recklessness

Question 1 of 5

A plaintiff has \( \$10{,}000 \) in medical bills, \( \$5{,}000 \) in lost wages, and \( \$6{,}000 \) for pain and suffering, with no comparative fault. What is the total compensatory award?

Question 2 of 5

A plaintiff with \( \$100{,}000 \) in total damages is found 40% at fault under pure comparative negligence. What is the recovery?

Question 3 of 5

Which type of damages is awarded when a legal right is violated but the plaintiff suffers no actual loss?

Question 4 of 5

Compensatory damages are \( \$50{,}000 \). The jury sets punitive damages at 2 times that amount for reckless conduct. What is the total judgment?

Question 5 of 5

Compensatory damages are \( \$200{,}000 \). The plaintiff is found 10% at fault, and the jury adds \( \$30{,}000 \) in punitive damages. What is the final recovery?

Key Takeaways

1
Make whole. Damages restore the plaintiff to their pre-tort position.
2
Compensatory = \( E + N \). Economic plus non-economic loss.
3
Reduce, then add punitive. Apply \( (1-f) \) before adding \( P \).
4
Punitive is rare. Reserved for malicious or reckless conduct.

You Can Calculate Damages

Remember the master formula: $$ R = (E + N)(1 - f) + P $$ Identify each component, reduce for fault, then add punitive only when justified.