01 / 20

Title Defects
in Real Property

Learn to spot the flaws that make a title unmarketable and the doctrines that resolve competing claims.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is Title?

Title is the legal evidence of a person's ownership rights in real property. It is the bundle of rights describing who owns the land and the extent of that ownership.

The Standard: Marketable Title

Every land-sale contract contains an implied covenant of marketable title. The seller must deliver title that a reasonable, well-informed buyer would accept free from reasonable doubt of litigation.

Three Sources of Defects

Chain of Title
Gaps, forged deeds, missing links, or wild deeds in the recorded ownership history.
Encumbrances
Mortgages, liens, easements, covenants, or encroachments that burden the land.
Adverse Claims
Adverse possession, undisclosed heirs, or competing buyers from a double sale.

A Broken Chain of Title

Adams 1980 Baker 1995 Carter 2010 valid deed no deed? Gap: Baker to Carter is unrecorded No instrument connects Baker's ownership to Carter. Carter cannot prove an unbroken chain — title is defective.

Core Rule: Recording Acts

When two parties claim the same land, recording acts determine priority. At common law, the first grantee wins. Statutes change this to protect subsequent bona fide purchasers (BFPs) who pay value and record.

Three Types of Statutes

1
Race: First to record wins, regardless of notice. Notice is irrelevant.
2
Notice: A subsequent BFP who takes without notice wins, even if they never record.
3
Race-Notice: A subsequent BFP wins only if they take without notice and record first.

Distinction: Notice vs. Race-Notice

Notice Statute
BFP without notice prevails. Recording is not required to win — but recording protects against later claimants.
Race-Notice Statute
BFP must be without notice and be the first to record. Both elements are required.

Encumbrances That Cloud Title

Liens & Mortgages
Outstanding debts secured by the land that must be satisfied or released.
Easements
A third party's right to use the land (unless visible/beneficial and agreed to).
Encroachments
A structure that crosses the boundary line, burdening the title.

How to Spot a Defect

1
Trace the chain. Identify each transfer and look for gaps, forgeries, or wild deeds.
2
List encumbrances. Note liens, mortgages, easements, and covenants on the land.
3
Check for adverse claims. Adverse possessors, undisclosed heirs, double sales.
4
Apply the recording act. Determine priority by identifying the statute type and BFP status.

Example 1: Double Sale

Owner sells Blackacre to B1 on March 1 (B1 does not record). Owner then sells the same parcel to B2 on April 1; B2 pays value, has no notice of B1, and records immediately. The jurisdiction has a notice statute.

Example 2: Race-Notice Twist

Same facts, but the jurisdiction has a race-notice statute. B2 pays value without notice of B1 — but B1 races to the courthouse and records on April 2, before B2 records on April 5.

Example 3: Inquiry Notice

B2 buys land where a stranger is openly living and farming the property. B2 pays value and records first under a race-notice statute, but never asked who the occupant was.

Common Mistakes

✕ Forgetting Notice Types
Notice can be actual, constructive (record), or inquiry. Visible possession triggers inquiry notice.
✕ Ignoring "Records First"
In race-notice, recording first is essential — being a BFP alone is not enough.
✕ Donees as BFPs
A gift recipient pays no value and is not a BFP, so they cannot use the recording act.

Statute Comparison

Notice Required? Record First?
RaceNoYes
NoticeYes (without notice)No
Race-NoticeYes (without notice)Yes

Question 1 of 5

Which standard does a land-sale contract impliedly require the seller to deliver?

Question 2 of 5

Under a pure race statute, who prevails between competing claimants?

Question 3 of 5

Who has superior title?

Question 4 of 5

A buyer purchases land on which a stranger is openly living and farming. The buyer never investigates. The buyer is charged with what kind of notice?

Question 5 of 5

Which person cannot qualify as a bona fide purchaser under a recording act?