01 / 20

Third Party
Beneficiaries

When two parties make a contract for the benefit of someone else: who can sue, and when?

Bar Exam (Uniform)

A Contract for Someone Else

Normally only the parties to a contract can enforce it. But sometimes two people contract specifically to benefit a third person who is not a party. That outsider is a third party beneficiary (TPB).

The Three Players

Promisor
The party who makes the promise that benefits the third party. Must perform.
Promisee
The party who secures the promise. Bargained for the benefit to go to the TPB.
Beneficiary
The third party who is to receive the benefit of the promisor's performance.

Mapping the Relationships

Promisee (A) Promisor (B) Beneficiary (C) Contract performance intent

The Core Rule: Intended vs Incidental

Only an intended beneficiary can sue to enforce the contract. An incidental beneficiary: someone who merely benefits by chance: has no rights.

Intended
The parties intended to benefit this person. Has enforceable rights once those rights vest.
Incidental
Benefits only as a side effect. No standing to sue on the contract.

Testing for Intent

A beneficiary is intended when the parties' intent shows they meant to benefit that person. Courts look for these signs:

1
Named or identified in the contract.
2
Performance runs directly to the beneficiary.
3
The beneficiary has a relationship with the promisee showing intent to benefit (creditor or donee).

Two Kinds of Intended Beneficiary

Creditor Beneficiary
Promisee owes the TPB a debt; the contract is meant to satisfy it. C may sue both the promisor and the promisee.
Donee Beneficiary
Promisee intends a gift to the TPB. C may sue the promisor only (no debt owed by promisee).

When Rights Vest

Before rights vest, the original parties can modify or rescind the contract freely. Once vested, they need the beneficiary's consent. Rights vest when the TPB:

1
Materially relies on the promise (changes position).
2
Manifests assent to the promise in a manner requested.
3
Brings suit to enforce the promise.

A Four-Step Approach

1
Identify the players: who is promisor, promisee, beneficiary?
2
Intended or incidental? Only intended beneficiaries have rights.
3
Have rights vested? Reliance, assent, or suit by the TPB.
4
Defenses? Promisor may raise any defense good against the promisee.

The Promisor's Defenses

When the TPB sues the promisor, the promisor stands in the same shoes as if the promisee were suing. So the promisor can assert any defense arising from the contract.

Worked Example 1

Anna hires Bob to paint Carl's house as a birthday gift to Carl. Bob refuses to perform. Can Carl sue Bob?

Anna Bob Carl paints

Worked Example 2

A city hires a contractor to build a stadium. A nearby restaurant expects more customers. The contractor breaches. Can the restaurant sue?

Worked Example 3

Dana owes Ed $500. Dana contracts with Fran: Fran will pay Ed the $500 in exchange for Dana's services. Fran refuses to pay. Whom can Ed sue?

Common Mistakes

✕ Skipping the intent test
Assuming any benefited party can sue. Only intended beneficiaries have rights.
✕ Ignoring vesting
Forgetting that parties may modify the deal before the TPB's rights vest.
✕ Forgetting defenses
The promisor keeps all contract defenses good against the promisee.

Quick Summary

IntendedIncidental
Can sue?YesNo
ExamplesNamed beneficiary, creditor, doneeBystander who happens to gain
Rights vest whenRelies, assents, or suesNever (no rights)
Promisor defensesAll from underlying contractN/A

Question 1 of 5

Which type of beneficiary can enforce a contract?

Question 2 of 5

A restaurant hopes a new public stadium will bring more diners. If the builder breaches, the restaurant is a:

Question 3 of 5

Dana owes Ed money and contracts with Fran to have Fran pay Ed. Ed is a:

Question 4 of 5

Before a third party beneficiary's rights vest, the original parties may:

Question 5 of 5

When an intended beneficiary sues the promisor, the promisor may raise: