Third Party
Beneficiaries
When two parties make a contract for the benefit of someone else: who can sue, and when?
A Contract for Someone Else
Normally only the parties to a contract can enforce it. But sometimes two people contract specifically to benefit a third person who is not a party. That outsider is a third party beneficiary (TPB).
The Three Players
Mapping the Relationships
The Core Rule: Intended vs Incidental
Only an intended beneficiary can sue to enforce the contract. An incidental beneficiary: someone who merely benefits by chance: has no rights.
Testing for Intent
A beneficiary is intended when the parties' intent shows they meant to benefit that person. Courts look for these signs:
Two Kinds of Intended Beneficiary
When Rights Vest
Before rights vest, the original parties can modify or rescind the contract freely. Once vested, they need the beneficiary's consent. Rights vest when the TPB:
A Four-Step Approach
The Promisor's Defenses
When the TPB sues the promisor, the promisor stands in the same shoes as if the promisee were suing. So the promisor can assert any defense arising from the contract.
Worked Example 1
Anna hires Bob to paint Carl's house as a birthday gift to Carl. Bob refuses to perform. Can Carl sue Bob?
Worked Example 2
A city hires a contractor to build a stadium. A nearby restaurant expects more customers. The contractor breaches. Can the restaurant sue?
Worked Example 3
Dana owes Ed $500. Dana contracts with Fran: Fran will pay Ed the $500 in exchange for Dana's services. Fran refuses to pay. Whom can Ed sue?
Common Mistakes
Quick Summary
| Intended | Incidental | |
|---|---|---|
| Can sue? | Yes | No |
| Examples | Named beneficiary, creditor, donee | Bystander who happens to gain |
| Rights vest when | Relies, assents, or sues | Never (no rights) |
| Promisor defenses | All from underlying contract | N/A |
Question 1 of 5
Which type of beneficiary can enforce a contract?
Question 2 of 5
A restaurant hopes a new public stadium will bring more diners. If the builder breaches, the restaurant is a:
Question 3 of 5
Dana owes Ed money and contracts with Fran to have Fran pay Ed. Ed is a:
Question 4 of 5
Before a third party beneficiary's rights vest, the original parties may:
Question 5 of 5
When an intended beneficiary sues the promisor, the promisor may raise: