Tenant Rights
Landlord & Tenant Law
Master the core duties, defenses, and remedies that govern the landlord-tenant relationship for the bar exam.
What Is a Leasehold?
A leasehold is a possessory interest in land for a limited time. The landlord retains the reversion; the tenant holds the right to exclusive possession. Their relationship is defined by both the lease contract and underlying property law.
The Four Tenancies
The Relationship at a Glance
Implied Warranty of Habitability
In residential leases, the landlord must maintain the premises in a condition fit for human habitation — meeting bare living requirements (heat, water, plumbing, no serious code violations). This warranty cannot be waived.
Quiet Enjoyment & Constructive Eviction
Every lease implies a covenant of quiet enjoyment: the landlord won't substantially interfere with the tenant's use. A serious breach can amount to constructive eviction.
Assignment vs. Sublease
How to Attack a Question
Example 1: Holdover Tenant
A tenant under a one-year term of years stays past the end date and keeps paying rent, which the landlord accepts. What tenancy now exists?
Example 2: No Heat in Winter
A residential tenant's heat fails in January. The landlord, properly notified, refuses to repair it for weeks. What can the tenant do?
Example 3: The Transfer Trap
Tenant T has 2 years left on a lease. T transfers all 2 years to A, but A then defaults on rent. Whom may the landlord sue?
Common Mistakes
Remedies Summary
| Trigger | Tenant Remedy | |
|---|---|---|
| Habitability | Unfit residential premises | Withhold / repair-deduct / terminate |
| Quiet Enjoyment | Substantial interference | Vacate & claim constructive eviction |
| Failure to Deliver | Possession not given | Terminate or sue (majority rule) |
| Security Deposit | Wrongful withholding | Sue for amount + statutory penalties |
Ready to Test Yourself?
Question 1 of 5
A tenant holds a month-to-month periodic tenancy. How much notice is generally required to terminate?
Question 2 of 5
The implied warranty of habitability applies to which leases?
Question 3 of 5
A tenant claims constructive eviction after the landlord ignored a serious water leak. What must the tenant also do?
Question 4 of 5
Tenant T transfers the entire remaining term to A, who later defaults on rent. Whom may the landlord pursue?
Question 5 of 5
A residential landlord refuses to repair broken heat after proper notice. Which is NOT an available tenant remedy?
You've Got the Framework
Classify the tenancy, spot the breached duty, distinguish residential from commercial, and match the right remedy. That's tenant rights mastery.