Takings
Analysis
When does government action become a taking requiring just compensation under the Fifth Amendment?
The Takings Clause
The clause does not forbid government from taking property. It permits taking so long as two conditions are met: the taking must be for a public use, and the owner must receive just compensation.
Three Threshold Questions
Two Kinds of Takings
Rule: Physical Takings
Rule: Regulatory Takings
If the regulation falls short of total wipeout, courts apply the Penn Central balancing test, weighing three factors. Let the economic impact be measured by the value loss ratio:
The Penn Central Factors
Taking vs. Valid Regulation
| Taking | Valid Police Power | |
|---|---|---|
| Compensation | Required | None owed |
| Value loss | Severe / total | Modest, use remains |
| Purpose | Public use | Health, safety, welfare |
| Example | Forced occupation | Zoning, nuisance control |
How to Apply the Analysis
Example 1: Cable Box
A state law forces a landlord to permit a cable company to install a small box and wires on the roof of an apartment building, occupying about one cubic foot of space.
Example 2: Beachfront Ban
An owner buys two beachfront lots for $975,000 intending to build homes. A new state law then bars all construction in that coastal zone, leaving the land essentially worthless.
Example 3: Landmark Law
A city designates a railroad terminal a historic landmark, blocking a planned office tower above it. The owner can still operate the terminal profitably and use transferable development rights.
Common Mistakes
Decision Summary
| Situation | Test | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Permanent physical occupation | Loretto | Per se taking |
| All economic value destroyed | Lucas | Per se taking |
| Partial value loss | Penn Central | Balance factors |
| Ordinary zoning / nuisance | Police power | No taking |
Question 1 of 5
A city requires landlords to allow a small permanent utility meter on each building's exterior wall. A landlord sues, claiming a taking. What is the likely result?
Question 2 of 5
A new environmental law bars all development on a parcel, leaving it economically worthless. Which test applies and what is the result?
Question 3 of 5
A zoning ordinance reduces the value of a commercial lot by about 25% but the owner can still operate the existing business. Is this likely a taking?
Question 4 of 5
When applying the Penn Central balancing test, which is not one of the three factors courts weigh?
Question 5 of 5
The government clearly takes private land to build a public highway and pays fair market value. Has the owner suffered an unconstitutional taking?