Summary
Judgment
When the facts are undisputed, a case can be decided without trial. Learn to apply the no genuine dispute of material fact standard.
What Is Summary Judgment?
A summary judgment is a court's decision on the merits before trial. Under FRCP 56, a court grants it when there is no genuine dispute as to any material fact and the moving party is entitled to judgment as a matter of law.
The Two Requirements
Key Terms
The Rule (FRCP 56)
We can express the standard logically. Let \( G \) = "a genuine dispute of material fact exists." Summary judgment is proper exactly when:
$$ \neg G \;\wedge\; (\text{movant entitled as a matter of law}) $$
The Burden-Shifting Framework
Summary Judgment vs. Other Motions
| Summary Judgment | Motion to Dismiss (12(b)(6)) | |
|---|---|---|
| What it tests | The evidence | The pleadings |
| Timing | After discovery | Before answer |
| Considers evidence? | Yes | No |
| Standard | No genuine dispute | Fails to state a claim |
How to Apply the Standard
Example 1: Clear Grant
In a breach-of-contract suit, both parties agree the contract was signed, agree on its terms, and agree the defendant never delivered the goods. The defendant offers no defense and no factual dispute exists.
Example 2: Genuine Dispute
In a car accident case, the plaintiff testifies the light was green; the defendant testifies it was red. Both submit sworn affidavits. The color of the light is dispositive of liability.
Example 3: Immaterial Dispute
In the same contract suit, the parties dispute what color the defendant's car was on the delivery day. They agree on every contract element. The car's color has no bearing on breach.
Logically, the test fails only if \( G \) is true: here \( G \) is false because the disputed fact is not material, so \( \neg G \) holds and the motion succeeds.
Common Mistakes
Quick Summary
| Scenario | Genuine? | Material? | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| All facts agreed | No | — | Grant |
| Conflicting affidavits on key fact | Yes | Yes | Deny |
| Dispute on irrelevant fact | Yes | No | Grant |
| Nonmovant rests on allegations | No | — | Grant |
Who Can Move?
Either party may move for summary judgment, and a court may grant it on all or part (partial summary judgment) of a claim. Under FRCP 56, a motion may generally be filed until 30 days after the close of discovery, unless a local rule or court order sets a different time.
Question 1 of 5
What are the two requirements for granting summary judgment?
Question 2 of 5
In a negligence suit, the plaintiff and defendant agree on every fact except one: whether the warehouse floor was wet at the time of the fall. The plaintiff submits an affidavit saying it was wet; the defendant submits an affidavit saying it was dry. Under the governing law, whether the floor was wet determines the outcome.
Should the court grant summary judgment?
Question 3 of 5
When ruling on a summary judgment motion, the court must draw all reasonable inferences in favor of whom?
Question 4 of 5
A factual dispute exists, but resolving it either way would not change the outcome under the governing law. This dispute is best described as:
Question 5 of 5
How does summary judgment differ from a motion to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(6)?