01 / 20

Summary
Judgment

When the facts are undisputed, a case can be decided without trial. Learn to apply the no genuine dispute of material fact standard.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is Summary Judgment?

A summary judgment is a court's decision on the merits before trial. Under FRCP 56, a court grants it when there is no genuine dispute as to any material fact and the moving party is entitled to judgment as a matter of law.

The Two Requirements

Prong 1 No genuine dispute of material fact Prong 2 Entitled to judgment as a matter of law BOTH required to grant summary judgment

Key Terms

Genuine Dispute
Evidence is such that a reasonable jury could return a verdict for either party.
Material Fact
A fact that could affect the outcome under the governing substantive law.
Matter of Law
Given the undisputed facts, the law dictates one result for the moving party.

The Rule (FRCP 56)

We can express the standard logically. Let \( G \) = "a genuine dispute of material fact exists." Summary judgment is proper exactly when:

$$ \neg G \;\wedge\; (\text{movant entitled as a matter of law}) $$

The Burden-Shifting Framework

1
Movant's initial burden. Show the absence of a genuine dispute, either with affirmative evidence or by pointing out the nonmovant lacks evidence on an essential element.
2
Burden shifts to nonmovant. The nonmovant must come forward with specific facts showing a genuine issue for trial: it cannot rest on mere allegations.
3
Court views evidence favorably to nonmovant. All reasonable inferences are drawn in the nonmoving party's favor.

Summary Judgment vs. Other Motions

Summary Judgment Motion to Dismiss (12(b)(6))
What it testsThe evidenceThe pleadings
TimingAfter discoveryBefore answer
Considers evidence?YesNo
StandardNo genuine disputeFails to state a claim

How to Apply the Standard

1
Identify the substantive law and its elements: this defines which facts are material.
2
List the disputed facts and ask: would resolving each one differently change the outcome?
3
Test "genuine." Is there evidence from which a reasonable jury could find for the nonmovant?
4
Apply law to undisputed facts. If only one outcome is possible, grant the motion.

Example 1: Clear Grant

In a breach-of-contract suit, both parties agree the contract was signed, agree on its terms, and agree the defendant never delivered the goods. The defendant offers no defense and no factual dispute exists.

All facts agreed No dispute Grant SJ for plaintiff

Example 2: Genuine Dispute

In a car accident case, the plaintiff testifies the light was green; the defendant testifies it was red. Both submit sworn affidavits. The color of the light is dispositive of liability.

Plaintiff: green sworn affidavit Defendant: red sworn affidavit DENY SJ — trial needed

Example 3: Immaterial Dispute

In the same contract suit, the parties dispute what color the defendant's car was on the delivery day. They agree on every contract element. The car's color has no bearing on breach.

Logically, the test fails only if \( G \) is true: here \( G \) is false because the disputed fact is not material, so \( \neg G \) holds and the motion succeeds.

Common Mistakes

✕ Weighing evidence
The judge does not decide who is more credible — that is the jury's job at trial.
✕ Ignoring materiality
Treating any factual disagreement as fatal. Only material disputes defeat the motion.
✕ Wrong inferences
Drawing inferences for the movant. Inferences must favor the nonmoving party.

Quick Summary

Scenario Genuine? Material? Result
All facts agreedNo—Grant
Conflicting affidavits on key factYesYesDeny
Dispute on irrelevant factYesNoGrant
Nonmovant rests on allegationsNo—Grant

Who Can Move?

Either party may move for summary judgment, and a court may grant it on all or part (partial summary judgment) of a claim. Under FRCP 56, a motion may generally be filed until 30 days after the close of discovery, unless a local rule or court order sets a different time.

Question 1 of 5

What are the two requirements for granting summary judgment?

Question 2 of 5

Should the court grant summary judgment?

Question 3 of 5

When ruling on a summary judgment motion, the court must draw all reasonable inferences in favor of whom?

Question 4 of 5

A factual dispute exists, but resolving it either way would not change the outcome under the governing law. This dispute is best described as:

Question 5 of 5

How does summary judgment differ from a motion to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(6)?

You've Got the Standard