01 / 20

Substantive
Due Process

How the Constitution protects fundamental rights from government interference, regardless of the procedures used.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is Due Process?

The Due Process Clauses appear in two amendments. The Fifth Amendment binds the federal government, and the Fourteenth Amendment binds the states. Both forbid depriving any person of life, liberty, or property without due process of law.

Two Branches of Due Process

Due Process 14th & 5th Amendments Procedural How? Notice + hearing Substantive Whether? Protects rights Fundamental Rights

Why It Matters

Limits Power
Stops the government from passing laws that intrude on the most personal choices.
Protects Liberty
Recognizes rights not spelled out in the text but central to ordered liberty.
Sets the Test
The right's classification decides how hard the law is to defend in court.

The Core Rule

1
Fundamental right involved? Apply strict scrutiny: the law must be necessary to achieve a compelling government interest.
2
No fundamental right? Apply rational basis: the law must be rationally related to a legitimate government interest.

The Scrutiny Fork

Is a fundamental right burdened? YES NO Strict Scrutiny Hard to survive Rational Basis Easy to survive Necessary & narrowly tailored to a compelling interest Rationally related to a legitimate interest

Identifying Fundamental Rights

A right is fundamental when it is deeply rooted in this Nation's history and tradition and implicit in the concept of ordered liberty. Courts recognize a limited list.

Privacy & Family
Marriage, procreation, contraception, child rearing, family living arrangements.
Personal Liberty
Travel between states, voting, and the refusal of unwanted medical treatment.

Substantive vs. Procedural

Substantive DP Procedural DP
Question Asked May the law exist? Was fair process used?
Focus Content of the law Notice & hearing
Typical Remedy Law struck down Better procedures ordered
Trigger Burden on liberty Deprivation of interest

How to Apply It

1
Identify the liberty. What right or interest does the law burden?
2
Classify the right. Is it fundamental (deeply rooted) or non-fundamental?
3
Select the test. Fundamental → strict scrutiny; otherwise → rational basis.
4
Apply the test. Match the government interest and means-fit to the standard, then conclude.

Example 1: Marriage Ban

Facts: A state law forbids two people from marrying. A couple challenges it under substantive due process.

Example 2: Economic Rule

Facts: A city requires every food truck to be licensed and to operate at least 200 feet from restaurants. A vendor claims it violates substantive due process.

Example 3: Medical Refusal

Facts: A statute forces a competent adult to undergo a non-emergency medical procedure against her will.

Common Mistakes

✕ Confusing the Branches
Treating a "fair hearing" issue (procedural) as if it were a substantive challenge to the law itself.
✕ Wrong Scrutiny
Applying strict scrutiny to economic or social welfare laws, which only get rational basis.
✕ Inventing Rights
Calling any liberty "fundamental." Only deeply rooted rights qualify for strict scrutiny.
✕ Flipping the Burden
Under strict scrutiny the government carries the burden; under rational basis the challenger does.

Scrutiny Summary

Strict Scrutiny Rational Basis
When Fundamental right Non-fundamental right
Interest Compelling Legitimate
Means-Fit Necessary / narrowly tailored Rationally related
Burden Government Challenger
Outcome Usually struck down Usually upheld

Question 1 of 5

Substantive due process primarily asks which question?

Question 2 of 5

A law burdens a fundamental right. Which test applies?

Question 3 of 5

Which of the following is generally treated as a fundamental right?

Question 4 of 5

Under rational basis review, who carries the burden of proof?

Question 5 of 5

Which standard should the court apply, and what is the likely result?

Key Takeaways

1
Substantive due process asks whether a law may exist; procedural asks whether fair process was used.
2
Classify the right first. Fundamental rights trigger strict scrutiny; all others get rational basis.
3
Fundamental rights are those deeply rooted in history and implicit in ordered liberty.
4
The burden of proof shifts with the test: government under strict scrutiny, challenger under rational basis.