01 / 20

Subject Matter
Jurisdiction

Determine whether a federal court has the power to hear a case through federal question or diversity jurisdiction.

Bar Exam

What Is Subject Matter Jurisdiction?

Subject matter jurisdiction (SMJ) is a court's power to hear a particular type of case. Without it, the court literally cannot decide the dispute, no matter how the parties feel about it.

Two Paths Into Federal Court

Federal SMJ Power to hear the case? Federal Question Claim arises under federal law Diversity
Different states +
amount \( > \$75{,}000 \)
Either path gives the federal court power to hear the case

Federal Question Jurisdiction

Under 28 U.S.C. § 1331, federal courts have jurisdiction over civil actions "arising under" the Constitution, federal laws, or treaties of the United States.

Diversity Jurisdiction

Under 28 U.S.C. § 1332, two requirements must both be met:

1
Complete diversity: no plaintiff may share a state of citizenship with any defendant.
2
Amount in controversy exceeds \( \$75{,}000 \), exclusive of interest and costs.

Determining Citizenship

Individuals
Citizen of their domicile: physical presence + intent to remain indefinitely.
Corporations
Citizen of both its state of incorporation and its principal place of business (nerve center).
Partnerships / LLCs
Citizen of every state in which any member or partner is a citizen.

The Complete Diversity Rule

Plaintiffs P1 (New York) Defendants D1 (Texas) D2 (California) ✓ Complete diversity exists No plaintiff shares a state with any defendant If any defendant were a New York citizen, diversity would be destroyed

SMJ vs. Personal Jurisdiction

Subject Matter Personal
What it governsPower over the casePower over the parties
Can be waived?NeverYes
Raised when?Any time, even on appealMust be raised early
Court acts on own?Yes (sua sponte)No

A Step-by-Step Approach

1
Federal question? Does the plaintiff's well-pleaded complaint arise under federal law?
2
Diversity present? Identify each party's citizenship and check for complete diversity.
3
Amount met? Does the claim exceed \( \$75{,}000 \) (good-faith pleading governs)?
4
Supplemental? If one claim qualifies, can related claims piggyback under § 1367?

Worked Example 1

A worker in Ohio sues her employer under the federal Title VII anti-discrimination statute, seeking \( \$40{,}000 \). Both are Ohio citizens. Is there federal SMJ?

Worked Example 2

A Florida citizen sues a Georgia citizen for breach of contract (state law), claiming \( \$90{,}000 \) in damages. Is there federal SMJ?

Worked Example 3

A New York citizen sues two defendants for negligence (state law), seeking \( \$200{,}000 \). One defendant is a Texas citizen; the other is a New York citizen. Is there diversity SMJ?

Common Mistakes

✕ "Minimal" diversity
§ 1332 requires complete diversity. Even one overlapping citizenship defeats it.
✕ Counting defenses
A federal defense or counterclaim does not create federal question jurisdiction.
✕ Forgetting corporate dual citizenship
Corporations are citizens of both incorporation state and principal place of business.
✕ "Equals $75,000"
The amount must exceed \( \$75{,}000 \). Exactly \( \$75{,}000 \) is not enough.

Federal SMJ at a Glance

Federal Question Diversity
Statute§ 1331§ 1332
TriggerClaim arises under federal lawDiverse parties
Amount needed?No\( > \$75{,}000 \)
Citizenship matters?NoYes (complete)
TestWell-pleaded complaintComplete diversity

Question 1 of 5

Which statute is the source of federal diversity jurisdiction?

Question 2 of 5

For diversity jurisdiction, the amount in controversy must:

Question 3 of 5

A California citizen sues a corporation incorporated in Delaware with its principal place of business in California, for \( \$500{,}000 \) on a state-law claim. Is there diversity jurisdiction?

Question 4 of 5

Under the well-pleaded complaint rule, a federal question exists when:

Question 5 of 5

Which statement about subject matter jurisdiction is true?

Key Takeaways

1
Two paths: federal question (§ 1331) or diversity (§ 1332).
2
Diversity needs both: complete diversity AND amount exceeding \( \$75{,}000 \).
3
SMJ cannot be waived and may be raised at any time.