Strict
Liability
Liability without fault. Learn when a defendant is responsible for harm even when they exercised reasonable care.
What Is Strict Liability?
In negligence, a plaintiff must prove the defendant breached a duty of care. In strict liability, fault is irrelevant. If the defendant's activity or product caused harm, liability attaches: even if every precaution was taken.
Three Categories
Why Strict Liability Exists
The Prima Facie Case
For any strict liability claim, the plaintiff must establish the same logical structure: \( \text{Liability} = \text{Category} + \text{Causation} + \text{Damages} \).
Abnormally Dangerous Activities
An activity is abnormally dangerous when it satisfies these factors (Restatement test):
Strict Liability vs. Negligence
| Strict Liability | Negligence | |
|---|---|---|
| Fault required? | No | Yes (breach of duty) |
| Focus of inquiry | Activity / product | Defendant's conduct |
| Reasonable care defense? | No | Yes |
| Causation needed? | Yes | Yes |
| Damages needed? | Yes | Yes |
How to Apply the Rules
Liability for Animals
Worked Example 1
Facts: A demolition company uses dynamite to clear a site. Despite following every safety protocol, vibrations crack a neighbor's foundation 200 feet away.
Worked Example 2
Facts: A manufacturer sells a space heater. A hidden wiring defect causes it to ignite during normal use, burning the buyer's home. The manufacturer had no way to detect the defect.
Worked Example 3
Facts: A homeowner keeps a domesticated golden retriever that has never shown aggression. One day it unexpectedly bites a visiting neighbor.
Common Mistakes
Category Summary
| Category | Key Trigger | Watch For |
|---|---|---|
| Wild animals | Dangerous propensity | Harm must flow from wild nature |
| Domestic animals | Known propensity | Owner's prior knowledge |
| Abnormally dangerous | High risk + uncommon | Common usage exclusion |
| Defective products | Defect + commercial seller | Defect at time of sale |
Question 1 of 5
A fireworks company conducts a display following every safety regulation. A stray spark still burns a spectator. The company is sued. What is the best basis for liability?
Question 2 of 5
An owner's pet poodle, which has never bitten anyone, suddenly nips a guest. On what theory is the owner most likely liable?
Question 3 of 5
Which statement about strict liability is most accurate?
Question 4 of 5
A chemical plant lawfully stores a large quantity of a toxic gas in compliance with all permits and using state-of-the-art containment. During a magnitude-6 earthquake never before recorded in the region, a tank ruptures and the gas injures nearby residents.
The residents sue the plant for strict liability. The plant argues that the earthquake was an unforeseeable act of nature that caused the rupture.
What is the plant's strongest argument against strict liability?
Question 5 of 5
A friend sells a used lawnmower at a yard sale. A latent defect injures the buyer. The buyer brings a strict products liability claim. What is the likely result?