01 / 20

Strict
Liability

Liability without fault. Learn when a defendant is responsible for harm even when they exercised reasonable care.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is Strict Liability?

In negligence, a plaintiff must prove the defendant breached a duty of care. In strict liability, fault is irrelevant. If the defendant's activity or product caused harm, liability attaches: even if every precaution was taken.

Three Categories

Animals
Wild animals and dangerous domestic animals with known propensities.
Abnormally Dangerous Activities
Activities that create a foreseeable, highly significant risk even with care.
Defective Products
Products sold in a defective condition unreasonably dangerous to users.

Why Strict Liability Exists

Dangerous Activity / Product Harm to Plaintiff causes Liability Attaches No fault needed

The Prima Facie Case

For any strict liability claim, the plaintiff must establish the same logical structure: \( \text{Liability} = \text{Category} + \text{Causation} + \text{Damages} \).

1
Category. The harm arises from an activity or product that falls within a strict liability class.
2
Causation. The defendant's activity/product was the actual and proximate cause of the harm.
3
Damages. The plaintiff suffered actual injury to person or property.

Abnormally Dangerous Activities

An activity is abnormally dangerous when it satisfies these factors (Restatement test):

1
Creates a foreseeable and highly significant risk of harm even when reasonable care is exercised.
2
The activity is not one of common usage in the community.

Strict Liability vs. Negligence

Strict Liability Negligence
Fault required?NoYes (breach of duty)
Focus of inquiryActivity / productDefendant's conduct
Reasonable care defense?NoYes
Causation needed?YesYes
Damages needed?YesYes

How to Apply the Rules

1
Identify the category. Is it an animal, an abnormally dangerous activity, or a defective product?
2
Confirm the elements. Match the facts to the specific test for that category.
3
Check the scope. Harm must flow from the dangerous propensity: not an unrelated risk.
4
Consider defenses. Assumption of risk and misuse can reduce or bar recovery; reasonable care cannot.

Liability for Animals

Wild Animals
Strict liability for harm caused by a dangerous propensity, even with precautions.
Domestic Animals
Strict liability only if the owner knew of a dangerous propensity (the "one-bite" rule).

Worked Example 1

Facts: A demolition company uses dynamite to clear a site. Despite following every safety protocol, vibrations crack a neighbor's foundation 200 feet away.

Blasting w/ all care vibrations Cracked Foundation

Worked Example 2

Facts: A manufacturer sells a space heater. A hidden wiring defect causes it to ignite during normal use, burning the buyer's home. The manufacturer had no way to detect the defect.

Worked Example 3

Facts: A homeowner keeps a domesticated golden retriever that has never shown aggression. One day it unexpectedly bites a visiting neighbor.

Common Mistakes

✕ Allowing a care defense
Concluding the defendant wins because they were careful. Reasonable care is never a defense in strict liability.
✕ Ignoring the scope rule
Imposing liability for harm unrelated to the dangerous propensity of the activity or animal.
✕ Forgetting causation
Strict liability still requires actual and proximate cause plus actual damages.
✕ Missing the commercial seller rule
Products liability applies only to those in the business of selling, not casual sellers.

Category Summary

Category Key Trigger Watch For
Wild animalsDangerous propensityHarm must flow from wild nature
Domestic animalsKnown propensityOwner's prior knowledge
Abnormally dangerousHigh risk + uncommonCommon usage exclusion
Defective productsDefect + commercial sellerDefect at time of sale

Question 1 of 5

A fireworks company conducts a display following every safety regulation. A stray spark still burns a spectator. The company is sued. What is the best basis for liability?

Question 2 of 5

An owner's pet poodle, which has never bitten anyone, suddenly nips a guest. On what theory is the owner most likely liable?

Question 3 of 5

Which statement about strict liability is most accurate?

Question 4 of 5

What is the plant's strongest argument against strict liability?

Question 5 of 5

A friend sells a used lawnmower at a yard sale. A latent defect injures the buyer. The buyer brings a strict products liability claim. What is the likely result?

Key Takeaways

1
Strict liability means liability without fault: reasonable care is never a defense.
2
Three categories: animals, abnormally dangerous activities, and defective products.
3
Always confirm \( \text{Causation} + \text{Damages} \), and check the scope of the danger.