Strategic
Recommendation
Recommend the right claims, remedies, defenses, and provisions that align with what your client actually wants and needs.
What Is a Strategic Recommendation?
A strategic recommendation is the lawyer's advice on what action to take: which claim to bring, which remedy to pursue, which defense to raise, what evidence to gather, or which contract term to include.
The Three Client Inputs
The Filtering Process
The Core Rule
We can express the test as a logical conjunction. Let \( L \) mean "legally viable" and \( A \) mean "advances client objectives within constraints." A recommendation \( R \) is sound when:
What Can You Recommend?
Objectives vs. Interests
These are easy to confuse but they drive different recommendations. Objectives are the stated goal; interests are the deeper reasons behind it.
| Objective | Interest | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | The concrete outcome | The underlying need |
| Example | "Win the lawsuit" | "Protect reputation" |
| Question | What does client want? | Why do they want it? |
| Drives | Choice of remedy | Tone & method |
How to Apply It
Example 1: Choosing a Remedy
A buyer contracted to purchase a unique antique clock. The seller refuses to deliver. The buyer wants the clock itself, not a refund.
Example 2: Choosing a Claim
A client was sold a defective car. You could plead breach of warranty (easy to prove) or fraud (harder, but allows punitive damages). The client's interest is a fast, low-cost resolution.
| Claim | Provable? | Fits Interest? |
|---|---|---|
| Breach of warranty | Easily | Yes ✓ |
| Fraud | Hard (intent) | No ✕ |
Example 3: A Contract Provision
You're drafting a services agreement for a startup. The client's interest is avoiding costly litigation and preserving the business relationship if a dispute arises.
Common Mistakes
Recommendation Checklist
| Step | Ask | Output |
|---|---|---|
| Objective | What result? | Stated goal |
| Interests | Why? | Priorities |
| Constraints | What limits? | Boundaries |
| Options | What's viable? | Option list (\( L \)) |
| Match | Which fits all? | \( R = L \land A \) |
Question 1 of 5
A recommendation is "sound" under the rule \( R_{\text{sound}} = L \land A \). Which situation makes a recommendation unsound?
Question 2 of 5
A client wants a unique heirloom painting that a seller refuses to deliver. The buyer does not want money. What is the best remedy to recommend?
Question 3 of 5
Which best describes the difference between a client's objective and their interest?
Question 4 of 5
A small business client was injured by a competitor's conduct. You can plead two claims:
Claim A — Tortious Interference: Solid evidence exists and it is provable, but litigation would take 18 months and cost more than the client's modest budget.
Claim B — Quick Settlement Demand: Legally supportable, resolves in weeks, fits the budget, and the client's chief interest is restoring cash flow fast.
Given the client's interest in a fast, low-cost resolution, what should you recommend?
Question 5 of 5
A startup client wants to avoid costly public litigation and preserve relationships in any future dispute. Which transactional provision best fits?