The Statute of Frauds
When Writing Is Required
Certain contracts are unenforceable unless put in writing. Learn how to spot when the statute of frauds applies — and when it doesn't.
What Is the Statute of Frauds?
The statute of frauds (SOF) is a legal rule requiring that certain types of contracts be evidenced by a signed writing in order to be enforceable. Its purpose is to prevent fraud and perjury by requiring reliable evidence of the most important agreements.
Contracts Within the Statute
Remember the mnemonic "MY LEGS" for the six categories of contracts that must be in writing:
Why the Writing Matters
What the Writing Must Contain
A sufficient writing does not need to be a formal contract. It must satisfy the following essentials:
Common Law vs. UCC Triggers
| Common Law | UCC (Goods) | |
|---|---|---|
| Trigger | MY LEGS categories | Sale of goods \( \geq \$500 \) |
| Writing detail | All essential terms | Quantity term only |
| Merchant rule | None | Confirmatory memo binds both |
| Key exceptions | Part performance, full performance | Specially made, admission, payment/receipt |
The One-Year Rule Trap
A contract falls within the SOF only if it is impossible to complete within one year by its terms. If there is any possibility of completion within a year, no writing is required.
A Step-by-Step Approach
Key Exceptions
Example 1: The Land Sale
Facts: Anna orally agrees to sell her cabin to Ben. Ben pays \( \$10{,}000 \), moves in, and builds a new deck. Anna refuses to convey title.
Example 2: The Goods Deal
Facts: Carla, a furniture merchant, orally agrees to buy \( \$2{,}000 \) of lumber from Dan, also a merchant. Dan mails a signed confirmation; Carla reads it but never objects. Carla then denies the deal.
Example 3: The Two-Year Job
Facts: Erin orally agrees to work for a company for a fixed term of two years. After eight months, the company fires her and claims no enforceable contract.
Common Mistakes
SOF Summary Map
| Category | Within SOF? | Notable Exception |
|---|---|---|
| Land sale | Yes | Part performance |
| Goods \( \geq \$500 \) | Yes | Admission, payment/receipt |
| > 1 year to perform | Yes | Full performance |
| Suretyship | Yes | Main purpose rule |
| Goods < \( \$500 \) | No | Oral is fine |
Question 1 of 5
A seller orally agrees to sell a parcel of land. Which MY LEGS category applies?
Question 2 of 5
An oral contract for the sale of goods worth \( \$450 \). Does the statute of frauds apply?
Question 3 of 5
An oral agreement to employ someone "for the rest of their life." Within the one-year rule?
Question 4 of 5
Facts: A buyer orally agrees to purchase land. She pays a substantial portion of the price, takes possession of the property, and constructs a permanent garage. The seller now refuses to convey, claiming there is no written contract.
Which exception most likely allows enforcement?
Question 5 of 5
A contract is within the statute of frauds but lacks a writing. What is its legal status?
Putting It All Together
To determine whether the statute of frauds applies, always work the checklist in order: