01 / 20

The State Action
Requirement

The Constitution restrains government, not private parties. Learn to decide whether the conduct in question is state action before any constitutional claim can proceed.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is State Action?

Most constitutional protections in the Bill of Rights and the Fourteenth Amendment apply only against the government. Before any constitutional right can be enforced, a litigant must show that a governmental actor caused the harm.

Why It Matters First

Private Party No state action Government State action Claim ✕ Dismissed ✓ Proceeds

When Private Conduct Counts

A private party can be treated as a state actor under two recognized doctrines:

Public Function
The private entity performs a task traditionally and exclusively reserved to the state.
Entanglement
The government is so significantly involved with the private actor that it shares responsibility for the conduct.

The Public Function Rule

✓ Qualifies
Running elections (primaries), operating a company town, managing a municipal park.
✕ Fails
Running a private school, a nursing home, a shopping mall, or a utility.

The Entanglement Rule

State action also exists when the government affirmatively facilitates, encourages, or authorizes the private conduct. Mere licensing or regulation is not enough.

1
Joint participation. A court enforces a racially restrictive covenant, or a state leases space to a discriminatory restaurant.
2
Government command. The state compels or significantly encourages the challenged private decision.
3
Entwinement. Public and private actors are so intertwined that the private body is effectively part of the state.

Regulation vs. Entanglement

Mere Regulation Licensing Subsidies General laws NOT state action Entanglement Joint action Compulsion Entwinement IS state action

How to Apply It

1
Identify the actor. Is the defendant a government body or official? If yes, state action exists. Stop.
2
If private, ask whether the public function doctrine applies (traditionally and exclusively governmental task).
3
Then ask whether the entanglement doctrine applies (significant government involvement, joint action, or compulsion).
4
If neither, there is no state action and the constitutional claim fails at the threshold.

Example 1: The Company Town

A corporation owns and operates an entire town, including its streets, post office, and sidewalks. It bars a person from distributing leaflets on the main street.

Example 2: The Restaurant Lease

A privately owned restaurant leases space in a public parking garage owned and operated by a state agency. The restaurant refuses to serve customers based on race.

Example 3: The Regulated Utility

A heavily regulated private electric company, granted a state monopoly, terminates a customer's service without a hearing. The customer claims a due process violation.

Common Mistakes

✕ Regulation = Action
Assuming heavy regulation, licensing, or subsidies automatically convert a private actor into a state actor. They do not.
✕ "Traditionally" Only
Forgetting that the public function must be both traditionally and exclusively governmental, not just commonly governmental.
✕ Skipping the Threshold
Jumping straight to the merits of a constitutional claim without first confirming that state action exists.

Quick Reference

Public Function Entanglement
TriggerTraditionally & exclusively governmental taskSignificant government involvement
ExamplesElections, company townJoint action, compulsion, leasing
Not enoughCommon but non-exclusive tasksMere licensing or regulation
ResultState actionState action

Question 1 of 5

A private shopping mall ejects protesters from its property. The protesters sue, claiming a First Amendment violation. Most likely result?

Question 2 of 5

Which of the following is most likely to be treated as state action?

Question 3 of 5

A state court enforces a privately agreed racially restrictive covenant on a home. Is there state action?

Question 4 of 5

The state grants a private utility a monopoly and approves its rates, but does not direct its decision to cut off a customer. State action?

Question 5 of 5

A litigant alleges a private employer fired her for her political views, violating her free speech rights. What is the threshold problem?

Putting It Together

1
Government actor? If yes, state action is automatic.
2
Public function? Traditionally and exclusively governmental tasks count.
3
Entanglement? Significant government involvement, joint action, or compulsion counts.
4
Neither? No state action, and the constitutional claim ends.

You've Got the Threshold