Standing
Analysis
Determine whether a plaintiff has the constitutional right to bring a claim to federal court.
What Is Standing?
Standing is a threshold requirement rooted in Article III of the U.S. Constitution. It asks: is this the right plaintiff to bring this lawsuit? A court cannot reach the merits of a case unless the plaintiff first establishes standing.
Why Standing Matters
The Standing Gateway
The Three Elements
Under Lujan v. Defenders of Wildlife, constitutional standing requires that all three elements be met. We can express this as a logical conjunction:
Breaking Down the Elements
Element 1: Injury in Fact
Key Distinction: Standing vs. Mootness
| Standing | Mootness | |
|---|---|---|
| Timing | Measured at filing | Arises after filing |
| Question | Right plaintiff? | Live controversy? |
| Concept | "Standing at the start" | "Standing set in time" |
| Result if fails | Dismissed | Dismissed (with exceptions) |
How to Apply the Test
Special Standing Rules
Example 1: Clear Standing
Facts: A factory dumps chemicals into a river. A homeowner downstream can no longer use her well water and pays for bottled water. She sues the factory.
Example 2: No Standing
Facts: An environmental group sues over endangered species abroad, alleging members "someday intend" to visit and observe the animals. No travel plans are concrete.
Example 3: The Redressability Trap
Facts: A mother sues a state prosecutor to force criminal child-support enforcement against the father. She has a real injury, but courts cannot compel discretionary prosecution.
Common Mistakes
Standing Summary
| Element | Satisfied When | Fails When |
|---|---|---|
| Injury in Fact | Concrete & imminent harm | Speculative / shared by all |
| Causation | Traceable to defendant | Caused by third party |
| Redressability | Ruling fixes harm | Remedy is uncertain |
Question 1 of 5
Which three elements must a plaintiff establish for constitutional standing?
Question 2 of 5
A citizen sues alleging the government is "wasting tax money" generally. Standing most likely fails because the injury is:
Question 3 of 5
If a plaintiff has a real injury and causation, but a court ruling would not actually fix the harm, which element fails?
Question 4 of 5
An organization wishes to sue on behalf of its members. Which is NOT a requirement for organizational (associational) standing?
Question 5 of 5
When is standing measured, and how does it differ from mootness?