01 / 20

Standard of Care
The Reasonable Person

In negligence, conduct is measured against what an ordinarily prudent person would do under the same circumstances.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is the Standard of Care?

Every negligence claim turns on a single question: did the defendant act with reasonable care? To answer it, courts compare the defendant's conduct to a legal yardstick called the standard of care.

Key Terms

Duty
A legal obligation to conform to the standard of care toward foreseeable plaintiffs.
Standard
The level of care required — the reasonably prudent person under like circumstances.
Breach
Falling below the standard; conduct an ordinary person would not have engaged in.

The Conduct Spectrum

Reasonable Care Line Careful No breach Careless Breach More care Less care

The Reasonable Person Rule

The standard is objective. It does not ask whether this defendant tried their best. It asks what a hypothetical careful person would have done facing the same situation.

An Objective Measure

Defendant's Actual Conduct What they actually did compare Reasonable Person Standard What a prudent person would do If actual conduct falls below the standard → breach

Objective vs. Subjective

Objective (Used)
Measures conduct against an external, hypothetical reasonable person. Good intentions do not excuse a breach.
Subjective (Not Used)
Would ask what this particular defendant believed or intended. Generally irrelevant to breach.

"Same Circumstances" Factors

1
Physical characteristics of the defendant (e.g., blindness) are considered.
2
Emergency situations — reasonable person facing a sudden emergency, not created by the defendant.
3
Superior skill or knowledge raises the bar to that of a reasonable expert.
4
Mental deficiencies and intoxication are generally not considered — they do not lower the standard.

How to Apply the Test

1
Identify the defendant's conduct — what exactly did they do or fail to do?
2
Describe the circumstances the reasonable person would be facing.
3
Ask what a reasonable person would do in those exact circumstances.
4
Compare — if the conduct fell below that, breach is established.

The Hand Formula

Courts sometimes weigh breach using Judge Learned Hand's cost-benefit test. A defendant breaches when the burden of precaution is less than the probability of harm times the severity:

Worked Example 1

Facts: A driver texts while driving through a school zone and strikes a child crossing at the crosswalk.

Worked Example 2

Facts: A defendant suffers a sudden, unforeseeable heart attack while driving and loses control, hitting a parked car.

Worked Example 3

Facts: A factory could install a \( \$500 \) guard rail. Without it, there is a \( 10\% \) chance per year of a \( \$100{,}000 \) injury.

Common Mistakes

✕ Using a Subjective Test
Asking what the defendant believed was reasonable, instead of what a reasonable person would do.
✕ Excusing Low Intelligence
Mental deficiencies and voluntary intoxication do not lower the standard of care.
✕ Ignoring Circumstances
Forgetting that the standard is "under the circumstances," including emergencies and physical traits.

Standard Summary

Considered? Effect on Standard
Physical disabilityYesTailored to person
Superior skillYesRaises the bar
Sudden emergencyYesRelaxes for haste
Low intelligenceNoStandard unchanged
Voluntary intoxicationNoStandard unchanged

Question 1 of 5

The standard of care in negligence is best described as:

Question 2 of 5

Which characteristic does the law generally refuse to consider when setting the standard?

Question 3 of 5

Under the Hand Formula, a defendant breaches when:

Question 4 of 5

How will the court most likely measure Dana's conduct?

Question 5 of 5

A driver swerves to avoid a child who darts into the road and damages a parked car. The emergency was not the driver's fault. The court will most likely: