01 / 20

Special Duties
in Tort Law

When a special relationship exists, the law imposes heightened or affirmative duties beyond ordinary care. Learn how the relationship dictates the duty.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

The Duty of Care Element

Every negligence claim begins with a duty: a legal obligation to conform to a standard of conduct. The default standard is to act as a reasonably prudent person would under the circumstances.

What Creates a Special Duty?

A special relationship between two parties can impose an affirmative duty to aid, protect, or control. The nature of the relationship determines the scope of the duty.

Custodial
Parent–child, jailer–prisoner, hospital–patient: control over a dependent person.
Commercial
Innkeeper–guest, common carrier–passenger, business–invitee.
Assumed
One who voluntarily begins to render aid assumes a duty to continue reasonably.

Mapping the Relationship to Duty

Special Relationship Duty to Protect from harm by others Duty to Aid render assistance Duty to Control third persons Duty to Warn of known dangers

The Core Rule

The probability of liability rises with the strength of the relationship. We can model the likelihood of a duty being recognized as a function of relationship strength \( s \):

$$ P(\text{duty}) = \frac{1}{1 + e^{-(s - s_0)}} $$

Landowner Duties by Entrant Status

A landowner's duty depends on the status of the person entering the property: the relationship classification drives the standard of care.

1
Invitee. Highest duty: inspect for hidden dangers and make safe, plus warn.
2
Licensee. Duty to warn of known concealed dangers; no duty to inspect.
3
Trespasser. Generally only a duty to refrain from willful/wanton harm.

Duty to Protect vs. Duty to Control

Duty to Protect
Owed to the plaintiff. The defendant must shield a person in its care from foreseeable harm (e.g., school protecting a student).
Duty to Control
Owed regarding a dangerous third party. The defendant must control someone under its supervision (e.g., parent controlling a child).

How to Apply the Analysis

1
Identify the parties and any relationship between them.
2
Classify the relationship (custodial, commercial, assumed, or none).
3
Determine the duty triggered: aid, protect, control, or warn.
4
Test foreseeability: was the harm a foreseeable risk of the relationship?
5
Assess breach: did the defendant take reasonable action under the heightened standard?

Example 1: Common Carrier

Bus Company (common carrier) high duty Passenger (plaintiff)

Example 2: Assumed Duty

A bystander sees a swimmer struggling and begins a rescue, pulling the swimmer halfway to shore, then abandons the effort, leaving the swimmer worse off.

Example 3: Duty to Control

Employer (defendant) Employee (controlled) Victim (plaintiff)

Common Mistakes

✕ Assuming a general duty to rescue
There is no duty to aid a stranger absent a special relationship or assumed undertaking.
✕ Ignoring foreseeability
Even with a relationship, the harm must be a foreseeable risk for liability to attach.
✕ Confusing protect with control
A duty to protect runs to the plaintiff; a duty to control concerns a dangerous third party.
✕ Forgetting entrant status
For premises cases, the duty depends on whether the entrant is an invitee, licensee, or trespasser.

Relationship & Duty Summary

Relationship Duty Imposed
Common carrierCarrier–passengerHighest care; protect
InnkeeperInnkeeper–guestAid & protect guests
CustodialJailer–prisonerProtect & provide care
EmployerEmployer–employeeControl dangerous employee
TherapistTherapist–patientWarn/protect identifiable victim
RescuerAssumed undertakingContinue reasonably

Question 1 of 5

A swimmer at a public beach is drowning. A passerby with no relationship to the swimmer does nothing. Is the passerby liable?

Question 2 of 5

A hotel guest is assaulted in a poorly lit, unmonitored parking lot after the hotel ignored repeated prior attacks. What duty did the hotel likely breach?

Question 3 of 5

A driver stops to help a stranded motorist, begins changing the tire, then abandons the task midway, leaving the car jacked up unsafely. The motorist is injured. Result?

Question 4 of 5

A licensee (a social guest) is injured by a loose stair the homeowner knew about but never mentioned. What was the homeowner's duty?

Question 5 of 5

Which best describes the duty at issue?

Putting It Together

1
No relationship generally means no affirmative duty to act.
2
Special relationships impose duties to aid, protect, control, or warn.
3
Voluntarily assuming a duty obligates reasonable performance.
4
Foreseeability bounds the scope of every special duty.

You're Ready for Special Duties

Always begin with the relationship: it determines whether a duty exists and what that duty requires. Then test for foreseeability and breach.