Sovereign Immunity
The Eleventh Amendment
Learn when a state can be sued in federal court, the key exceptions, and how to spot the issue on the exam.
What Is Sovereign Immunity?
Sovereign immunity is the principle that a government cannot be sued without its consent. For states, this protection is most famously rooted in the Eleventh Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.
The Text of the Amendment
On its face, the text only bars suits by citizens of another state. But in Hans v. Louisiana (1890), the Court extended immunity to suits by a state's own citizens, treating the Amendment as confirming a broader background principle.
Who the State Is Protected From
The Core Rule
The Eleventh Amendment, plus the broader doctrine of state sovereign immunity, generally bars a private party from suing a state government (or a state agency) for money damages in federal court.
The Four Exceptions
A private suit against a state may proceed only if it fits within a recognized exception. Remember these as WICE:
State vs. Local Government
The single most tested distinction: immunity protects states and arms of the state, but not municipalities, counties, or school districts.
The Ex parte Young Fiction
How to Apply the Rule
Worked Example 1
Analysis: The defendant is a state agency — an arm of the state. The plaintiff is a private citizen seeking money damages from the treasury. No waiver, no Young (no prospective relief), no Section 5 abrogation.
Worked Example 2
Analysis: The suit is against a state officer, not the state itself, and seeks prospective injunctive relief to halt an ongoing federal-law violation. This fits squarely within Ex parte Young.
Worked Example 3
Analysis: The defendant is a municipality, not a state or arm of the state. The Eleventh Amendment never protects local governments. No immunity issue arises.
Common Mistakes
Summary Table
| Allowed | Barred | |
|---|---|---|
| Defendant | City / county / officer | State / state agency |
| Plaintiff | U.S. / another state | Private citizen |
| Relief | Prospective injunction | Damages from treasury |
| Consent | Express waiver | No waiver |
| Abrogation | Section 5 of 14th Am. | Article I commerce power |
Question 1 of 5
A private citizen sues the State of Texas in federal court for $500,000 in damages, and Texas has not consented. Which result is correct?
Question 2 of 5
A plaintiff sues the City of Phoenix in federal court for damages. The city raises the Eleventh Amendment as a defense. The defense should:
Question 3 of 5
A citizen sues a state official by name seeking an injunction to stop ongoing enforcement of a state law that violates federal law. This suit is:
Question 4 of 5
Under which constitutional power may Congress validly abrogate a state's sovereign immunity?
Question 5 of 5
A private citizen sues a state official by name in federal court. The complaint seeks: (1) an injunction ordering the official to stop applying an unconstitutional state policy going forward, and (2) an award of $300,000 in back-pay to be paid out of the state treasury for past harm.
The state argues the entire suit is barred by sovereign immunity.
How should the court rule on the two requests?