01 / 20

Sovereign Immunity
The Eleventh Amendment

Learn when a state can be sued in federal court, the key exceptions, and how to spot the issue on the exam.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is Sovereign Immunity?

Sovereign immunity is the principle that a government cannot be sued without its consent. For states, this protection is most famously rooted in the Eleventh Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.

The Text of the Amendment

On its face, the text only bars suits by citizens of another state. But in Hans v. Louisiana (1890), the Court extended immunity to suits by a state's own citizens, treating the Amendment as confirming a broader background principle.

Who the State Is Protected From

STATE (Immune) Own Citizen BARRED Other-State Citizen BARRED Foreign Citizen BARRED United States CAN SUE

The Core Rule

The Eleventh Amendment, plus the broader doctrine of state sovereign immunity, generally bars a private party from suing a state government (or a state agency) for money damages in federal court.

1
Who is protected: States, state agencies, and "arms of the state." NOT counties or cities (local governments).
2
What is barred: Suits for damages from the state treasury, and certain injunctive suits naming the state itself.
3
Where: Federal court — but the doctrine also bars suits in the state's own courts and before federal agencies.

The Four Exceptions

A private suit against a state may proceed only if it fits within a recognized exception. Remember these as WICE:

W
Waiver: The state explicitly and unequivocally consents to suit.
I
Injunctive relief — Ex parte Young: Suit against a state officer for prospective relief to stop ongoing violations of federal law.
C
Congressional abrogation: Congress abrogates immunity using its Section 5 enforcement power under the Fourteenth Amendment.
E
Excluded parties: Suits by the U.S. or by other states are not barred.

State vs. Local Government

The single most tested distinction: immunity protects states and arms of the state, but not municipalities, counties, or school districts.

Immune
State of Florida, state university, state department of corrections, state highway agency.
Not Immune
City of Miami, Dade County, local school board, municipal police department.

The Ex parte Young Fiction

Sue the STATE BARRED Sue the OFFICER ALLOWED prospective relief to stop ongoing violation Future-looking injunction only No retroactive damages from treasury

How to Apply the Rule

1
Is the defendant a state? If a city/county/individual, immunity does not apply — stop here.
2
Is the plaintiff a private party? If the U.S. or another state is suing, no bar.
3
Does an exception apply? Check waiver, Ex parte Young, and Section 5 abrogation.
4
What relief is sought? Damages from the treasury are barred; prospective injunctions against officers are allowed.

Worked Example 1

Analysis: The defendant is a state agency — an arm of the state. The plaintiff is a private citizen seeking money damages from the treasury. No waiver, no Young (no prospective relief), no Section 5 abrogation.

Worked Example 2

Analysis: The suit is against a state officer, not the state itself, and seeks prospective injunctive relief to halt an ongoing federal-law violation. This fits squarely within Ex parte Young.

Worked Example 3

Analysis: The defendant is a municipality, not a state or arm of the state. The Eleventh Amendment never protects local governments. No immunity issue arises.

Common Mistakes

✕ Forgetting cities
Applying immunity to counties and municipalities. Local governments are never protected.
✕ Money via Young
Thinking Ex parte Young allows retroactive damages from the treasury. It only allows prospective relief.
✕ Wrong abrogation power
Congress cannot abrogate immunity under Article I commerce power — only under Section 5 of the 14th Amendment.
✕ State-court myth
Assuming the bar is only in federal court. The doctrine also bars private suits in the state's own courts.

Summary Table

Allowed Barred
DefendantCity / county / officerState / state agency
PlaintiffU.S. / another statePrivate citizen
ReliefProspective injunctionDamages from treasury
ConsentExpress waiverNo waiver
AbrogationSection 5 of 14th Am.Article I commerce power

Question 1 of 5

A private citizen sues the State of Texas in federal court for $500,000 in damages, and Texas has not consented. Which result is correct?

Question 2 of 5

A plaintiff sues the City of Phoenix in federal court for damages. The city raises the Eleventh Amendment as a defense. The defense should:

Question 3 of 5

A citizen sues a state official by name seeking an injunction to stop ongoing enforcement of a state law that violates federal law. This suit is:

Question 4 of 5

Under which constitutional power may Congress validly abrogate a state's sovereign immunity?

Question 5 of 5

How should the court rule on the two requests?

Key Takeaways

1
States are immune from private suits for damages — cities and counties are not.
2
WICE exceptions: Waiver, Injunctive relief (Young), Congressional abrogation (Section 5), Excluded parties (U.S. / states).
3
Young = prospective only. No treasury damages through an officer suit.