I'll generate a complete, self-contained HTML slide deck on "Source Weight Analysis" following the design system exactly. ```html Source Weight Analysis — Bar Exam
01 / 20

Source Weight
Analysis

Learn to identify the role, relevance, and authoritative weight of legal sources to build sound arguments.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is Source Weight?

Every legal source has a different authoritative weight — how much power it has to control or persuade a court. A skilled lawyer reads each source and asks: does this bind the court, or merely persuade it?

Two Core Categories

Mandatory (Binding)
Authority a court must follow. Comes from a higher court or governing body in the same jurisdiction.
Persuasive
Authority a court may consider but is not required to follow. From other jurisdictions or secondary sources.

Primary vs. Secondary Sources

Primary Sources
The law itself: constitutions, statutes, regulations, and court opinions. Can be binding or persuasive.
Secondary Sources
Commentary about the law: treatises, law reviews, Restatements. Always persuasive, never binding.

The Authority Hierarchy

Constitution Statutes Regulations Case Law (Common Law) Secondary Sources (Persuasive only) higher lower

The Core Rule of Weight

In symbolic terms, a source \( S \) binds court \( C \) when both predicates hold: $$ \text{Binding}(S, C) \iff \text{SameJurisdiction}(S, C) \;\wedge\; \text{Higher}(S, C) $$ If either condition fails, the source is at most persuasive.

Vertical vs. Horizontal Authority

Vertical Horizontal
Source courtHigher court, same systemSame level, prior decision
Binding?Yes — mandatoryUsually, but flexible
ExampleState supreme court binds trial courtCourt following its own precedent

How to Analyze a Source

1
Identify the type. Is it a constitution, statute, regulation, case, or secondary commentary?
2
Check the jurisdiction. Does it govern the court in question, or come from elsewhere?
3
Locate it in the hierarchy. Is the issuing body higher than, equal to, or lower than the deciding court?
4
Conclude the weight. Binding only if \( \text{SameJurisdiction} \wedge \text{Higher} \); otherwise persuasive.

Worked Example 1

A state trial court in Ohio is deciding a contract dispute. Counsel cites a decision from the Ohio Supreme Court. What is the weight?

Ohio Supreme Court (higher, same state) binds Ohio Trial Court (deciding court)

Worked Example 2

The same Ohio trial court is now offered a decision from the California Supreme Court on an identical issue. What is its weight?

California Supreme Court (other jurisdiction) persuades only Ohio Trial Court (deciding court)

Worked Example 3

In a federal diversity case, a brief relies on the Restatement (Second) of Contracts and a law review article. How should the court treat them?

Restatement
Secondary source. Highly persuasive and often adopted, but not binding until a court actually adopts it.
Law Review
Secondary source. Persuasive only, with weight tied to the author's reputation and reasoning.

Common Mistakes

✕ Confusing persuasive with binding
A famous opinion from another state is still only persuasive. Reputation does not create binding force.
✕ Treating secondary as primary
Restatements and treatises describe the law — they are never the law and cannot bind a court.
✕ Ignoring jurisdiction
Even a higher court's ruling is only persuasive if it sits in a different jurisdiction.

Weight Summary Table

Source Type Possible Weight
ConstitutionPrimaryBinding (highest)
StatutePrimaryBinding
RegulationPrimaryBinding
Case (same jurisdiction, higher)PrimaryBinding
Case (other jurisdiction)PrimaryPersuasive
Restatement / TreatiseSecondaryPersuasive only

Question 1 of 5

Which condition pair must both be true for a source to bind a court?

Question 2 of 5

A treatise on tort law is cited in a brief. What is the most it can ever be?

Question 3 of 5

A Texas trial court is offered an opinion from the Florida Supreme Court. The weight is:

Question 4 of 5

Within one jurisdiction, two primary sources conflict. Which controls?

Question 5 of 5

Which source is binding on the district court?

Key Takeaways

1
Weight = hierarchy + jurisdiction, not how persuasive the writing is.
2
Primary sources can be binding; secondary sources never are.
3
Binding requires \( \text{SameJurisdiction} \wedge \text{Higher} \) — fail either and it is persuasive.
4
When primaries conflict, the higher source in the hierarchy wins.

You Can Now Weigh Sources

You can identify a source's type, check its jurisdiction, place it in the hierarchy, and conclude whether it is binding or persuasive. Apply this framework to every authority you read.

``` This complete, self-contained HTML slide deck covers Source Weight Analysis for the Bar Exam with all 20 slides, including the title, concept introduction, core rule, hierarchy diagram, vertical/horizontal distinction, step-by-step application, three worked examples, common mistakes, summary table, 5 assessment questions (one with a collapsible passage), and a closing slide. All math uses KaTeX, the design system tokens are exactly followed, and full navigation, assessment logic, accordion behavior, and accessibility features are implemented.