Source Weight
Analysis
Learn to identify the role, relevance, and authoritative weight of legal sources to build sound arguments.
What Is Source Weight?
Every legal source has a different authoritative weight — how much power it has to control or persuade a court. A skilled lawyer reads each source and asks: does this bind the court, or merely persuade it?
Two Core Categories
Primary vs. Secondary Sources
The Authority Hierarchy
The Core Rule of Weight
In symbolic terms, a source \( S \) binds court \( C \) when both predicates hold: $$ \text{Binding}(S, C) \iff \text{SameJurisdiction}(S, C) \;\wedge\; \text{Higher}(S, C) $$ If either condition fails, the source is at most persuasive.
Vertical vs. Horizontal Authority
| Vertical | Horizontal | |
|---|---|---|
| Source court | Higher court, same system | Same level, prior decision |
| Binding? | Yes — mandatory | Usually, but flexible |
| Example | State supreme court binds trial court | Court following its own precedent |
How to Analyze a Source
Worked Example 1
A state trial court in Ohio is deciding a contract dispute. Counsel cites a decision from the Ohio Supreme Court. What is the weight?
Worked Example 2
The same Ohio trial court is now offered a decision from the California Supreme Court on an identical issue. What is its weight?
Worked Example 3
In a federal diversity case, a brief relies on the Restatement (Second) of Contracts and a law review article. How should the court treat them?
Common Mistakes
Weight Summary Table
| Source | Type | Possible Weight |
|---|---|---|
| Constitution | Primary | Binding (highest) |
| Statute | Primary | Binding |
| Regulation | Primary | Binding |
| Case (same jurisdiction, higher) | Primary | Binding |
| Case (other jurisdiction) | Primary | Persuasive |
| Restatement / Treatise | Secondary | Persuasive only |
Question 1 of 5
Which condition pair must both be true for a source to bind a court?
Question 2 of 5
A treatise on tort law is cited in a brief. What is the most it can ever be?
Question 3 of 5
A Texas trial court is offered an opinion from the Florida Supreme Court. The weight is:
Question 4 of 5
Within one jurisdiction, two primary sources conflict. Which controls?
Question 5 of 5
A federal district court in the Ninth Circuit is deciding a federal statutory question. Counsel offers four sources:
(1) A U.S. Supreme Court opinion directly on point.
(2) A Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals opinion on point.
(3) A Second Circuit opinion reaching the opposite result.
(4) A law review article supporting source (3).
Which source is binding on the district court?
Key Takeaways
You Can Now Weigh Sources
You can identify a source's type, check its jurisdiction, place it in the hierarchy, and conclude whether it is binding or persuasive. Apply this framework to every authority you read.