01 / 19

Source Rule
Extraction

Learn to pull the dispositive language, standards, elements, and factors out of any legal source and turn it into a usable rule.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is a Source Rule?

A source is any legal authority you are handed: a statute, a case holding, a regulation, or a Restatement section. The rule is the operative legal standard buried inside that text.

Why It Matters

Accurate Analysis
If you extract the wrong rule, every step of your IRAC analysis is built on sand.
Earns Points
Graders award credit for stating the correct elements and applying them to facts.
Speed
A clean rule statement frames your essay quickly and keeps your reasoning organized.

Four Kinds of Operative Language

1
Elements: Components that must all be proven for a claim to succeed (negligence: duty, breach, causation, damages).
2
Factors: Considerations a court weighs and balances; no single one is required (fair-use factors).
3
Standards: The threshold or level of proof (reasonable person, clear and convincing, beyond a reasonable doubt).
4
Definitions: Terms the source itself defines, which control how the rule applies.

From Source Text to Usable Rule

Raw Source A person is liable if they intentionally cause harmful contact with another, where intent means purpose or substantial certainty. Consent is a defense. extract Structured Rule Battery requires: • intent (element) • harmful contact (element)
\( \text{intent} = \text{purpose OR} \)
\( \text{substantial certainty (def.)} \)
defense: consent

The Core Extraction Principle

Your job is to find the conditions \( C_i \) (the elements or factors) and the result \( R \) (the legal consequence). Watch for connecting words that tell you how the conditions combine.

Read the Signal Words

Signal Word What It Tells You
"and"All conditions required — conjunctive elements \( (C_1 \wedge C_2) \)
"or"Any one suffices — disjunctive \( (C_1 \vee C_2) \)
"shall" / "must"Mandatory duty or requirement
"may"Discretionary — court is permitted, not required
"unless" / "except"Introduces an exception or defense
"means" / "includes"A controlling definition

Elements vs. Factors

Elements
Each must be satisfied. Miss one and the claim fails. Joined by "and". Think checklist: \( C_1 \wedge C_2 \wedge C_3 \).
Factors
Weighed together; none is dispositive alone. Often signaled by "the court considers" a list. Think balancing scale.

A Four-Step Method

1
Find the operative sentence. Locate where the source states a consequence ("is liable," "is guilty," "shall be void").
2
List the conditions. Pull out each element, factor, or threshold tied to that consequence.
3
Mark the connectors. Note "and," "or," "unless" to see how conditions combine and where defenses sit.
4
Capture definitions. Record any term the source defines, since it controls how the rule applies.

Worked Example: A Statute

Extraction. Consequence \( R \): commits theft. Conditions joined implicitly by "and":

Worked Example: A Factor Test

Watch out: the word "and" appears, but the lead-in "courts consider" signals these are factors, not elements. No single factor is dispositive.

Worked Example: A Case Holding

Extraction. The word "both ... and" and "only where" are decisive. This is a conjunctive two-element test.

Common Mistakes

✕ Mixing Elements and Factors
Treating a balancing test as a checklist (or vice versa) leads to the wrong analysis.
✕ Ignoring "Unless"
Missing the exception or defense clause that can defeat an otherwise valid claim.
✕ Skipping Definitions
Overlooking a controlling "means/includes" definition that narrows the rule.
✕ Confusing "and" with "or"
Reading disjunctive conditions as conjunctive changes who wins.

Extraction Cheat Sheet

Elements Factors
Combine by"and" (all required)"considers" (weighed)
Miss oneclaim failsmay still win
Logic\( C_1 \wedge C_2 \)balance \( \Sigma \)
Signal"only if," "both""in determining"

Question 1 of 5

What role does the "unless" clause play?

Question 2 of 5

A plaintiff proves duty, breach, and causation but no damages. What is the result?

Question 3 of 5

How should you classify these three items?

Question 4 of 5

What does the word "or" tell you about the signing requirement?

Question 5 of 5

Which extraction is most accurate?