Source Rule
Extraction
Learn to pull the dispositive language, standards, elements, and factors out of any legal source and turn it into a usable rule.
What Is a Source Rule?
A source is any legal authority you are handed: a statute, a case holding, a regulation, or a Restatement section. The rule is the operative legal standard buried inside that text.
Why It Matters
Four Kinds of Operative Language
From Source Text to Usable Rule
The Core Extraction Principle
Your job is to find the conditions \( C_i \) (the elements or factors) and the result \( R \) (the legal consequence). Watch for connecting words that tell you how the conditions combine.
Read the Signal Words
| Signal Word | What It Tells You |
|---|---|
| "and" | All conditions required — conjunctive elements \( (C_1 \wedge C_2) \) |
| "or" | Any one suffices — disjunctive \( (C_1 \vee C_2) \) |
| "shall" / "must" | Mandatory duty or requirement |
| "may" | Discretionary — court is permitted, not required |
| "unless" / "except" | Introduces an exception or defense |
| "means" / "includes" | A controlling definition |
Elements vs. Factors
A Four-Step Method
Worked Example: A Statute
Extraction. Consequence \( R \): commits theft. Conditions joined implicitly by "and":
Worked Example: A Factor Test
Watch out: the word "and" appears, but the lead-in "courts consider" signals these are factors, not elements. No single factor is dispositive.
Worked Example: A Case Holding
Extraction. The word "both ... and" and "only where" are decisive. This is a conjunctive two-element test.
Common Mistakes
Extraction Cheat Sheet
| Elements | Factors | |
|---|---|---|
| Combine by | "and" (all required) | "considers" (weighed) |
| Miss one | claim fails | may still win |
| Logic | \( C_1 \wedge C_2 \) | balance \( \Sigma \) |
| Signal | "only if," "both" | "in determining" |
Question 1 of 5
Statute: "A landlord shall return the security deposit within 30 days unless the tenant caused damage beyond ordinary wear and tear."
What role does the "unless" clause play?
Question 2 of 5
Rule: "Negligence requires duty, breach, causation, and damages."
A plaintiff proves duty, breach, and causation but no damages. What is the result?
Question 3 of 5
Rule: "In deciding custody, the court considers the child's wishes, each parent's stability, and the child's ties to the community."
How should you classify these three items?
Question 4 of 5
Statute: "A document is a 'will' if it is signed by the testator or by another at the testator's direction."
What does the word "or" tell you about the signing requirement?
Question 5 of 5
Holding: "A contract is unconscionable only where it is both procedurally and substantively unconscionable. 'Procedural' means unfairness in the bargaining process."
Which extraction is most accurate?