01 / 20

Shareholder Actions
Direct vs Derivative

Learn to tell apart a shareholder's personal lawsuit from a suit brought on behalf of the corporation.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

Two Ways a Shareholder Can Sue

A shareholder who believes a wrong has occurred can bring a lawsuit, but the law sorts these claims into two categories based on who was actually harmed.

Who Holds the Right to Sue?

DIRECT Shareholder Defendant Recovery goes to the shareholder DERIVATIVE Corporation Defendant Recovery goes to the corporation

Key Terms

Direct Action
Enforces a shareholder's own rights for an injury distinct from the corporation.
Derivative Action
A shareholder steps into the corporation's shoes to enforce a corporate claim.
Demand
A required pre-suit request that the board pursue the claim itself.

The Core Test

Most jurisdictions (following the modern Delaware approach) ask two questions to classify the claim:

1
Who suffered the harm? The corporation, or the shareholder individually?
2
Who would receive the recovery? The corporation, or the shareholder directly?

A Useful Formula

Think of total shareholder harm as a sum of two distinct components:

The Demand Requirement

Because a derivative claim belongs to the corporation, the shareholder must first give the board a chance to act:

1
Make demand on the board to pursue the claim, or plead that demand would be futile.
2
Be a contemporaneous shareholder who owned stock at the time of the wrong and throughout the suit.
3
Fairly and adequately represent the corporation's interests.

Direct vs Derivative at a Glance

Direct Derivative
Who is injuredShareholderCorporation
Who recoversShareholderCorporation
Demand on boardNot requiredRequired (or futility)
Contemporaneous ownershipNot requiredRequired

How to Classify a Claim

1
Identify the wrong. What conduct allegedly caused harm?
2
Locate the injury. Did it hit the corporation's assets, or the shareholder's personal rights?
3
Trace the recovery. Who should be made whole by a remedy?
4
Check procedure. If derivative, confirm demand and standing requirements are met.

Typical Fact Patterns

Usually Direct
Denial of voting rights, refusal to allow inspection of books, or a breach of the shareholder's own contract.
Usually Derivative
Director self-dealing, waste of corporate assets, or breach of fiduciary duty that lowers share value.

Worked Example 1

Facts: The CEO diverts a lucrative corporate contract to her own side company. Every shareholder's stock loses value.

Worked Example 2

Facts: The board refuses to count a single shareholder's votes at the annual meeting, denying her the directors she was entitled to elect.

Worked Example 3

Facts: Directors approve a merger that unfairly dilutes a minority shareholder's voting power while preserving the majority's control.

Common Mistakes

✕ Confusing recovery
Forgetting that derivative recovery goes to the corporation, not the suing shareholder.
✕ Skipping demand
Treating a derivative suit like a direct one and ignoring the demand requirement.
✕ "Lost value" trap
Calling every share-value drop direct, when shared losses are usually derivative.

Quick Summary

Scenario Classification
Denied voting rightsDirect
Refused inspection of recordsDirect
Director self-dealing / wasteDerivative
Breach of fiduciary duty to firmDerivative
Breach of shareholder's own contractDirect

Question 1 of 5

In a derivative action, who receives any recovery obtained?

Question 2 of 5

A shareholder is wrongly refused inspection of corporate records. What kind of claim is this?

Question 3 of 5

Which procedural step is required for a derivative suit but not a direct one?

Question 4 of 5

A director wastes corporate assets, lowering the stock price for all owners equally. This is best classified as:

Question 5 of 5

How should the two claims be classified?