01 / 20

Servitudes
Enforcing Land Burdens

How easements, real covenants, and equitable servitudes run with the land — and when a successor is bound.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is a Servitude?

A servitude is a non-possessory right or restriction tied to land. It burdens one parcel for the benefit of another (or of a person). The key bar question is always: does it bind future owners who never signed the original agreement?

Dominant vs. Servient Estates

DOMINANT SERVIENT Lot A enjoys benefit Lot B bears burden right of way Owner of A may cross B's driveway to reach the road.

Three Servitude Categories

Easement
A right to use another's land (e.g., a path or pipeline).
Real Covenant
A written promise about land use, enforced at law by money damages.
Equitable Servitude
A promise enforced in equity by injunction.

Creating an Easement

1
Express: Written grant or reservation satisfying the Statute of Frauds.
2
Implication: Prior apparent, continuous use existing before a parcel was severed.
3
Necessity: Landlocked parcel created by a severance — strict necessity required.
4
Prescription: Open, continuous, hostile use for the statutory period (like adverse possession, minus exclusivity).

Real Covenant: Burden Running

For the burden of a real covenant to bind a successor, all five elements must be met. Memorize them as WITHN:

W
Writing: the original promise was in writing.
I
Intent that the covenant run with the land.
T
Touch and concern the land.
H
Horizontal & vertical privity (burden needs both, and full vertical privity).
N
Notice to the successor (actual, inquiry, or record).

Burden vs. Benefit Running

The benefit side is easier to run than the burden. It requires writing, intent, touch-and-concern, and vertical privity only — no horizontal privity and no notice.

Equitable Servitude: The Easier Path

When privity is missing, plaintiffs pivot to an equitable servitude and seek an injunction. Its elements are WITN — like a real covenant but no privity required.

Writing
Or a common scheme (implied).
Intent
To bind successors.
Touch & Concern
Relates to land use.
Notice
Bona fide purchaser must have notice.

How to Analyze Enforceability

1
Identify the remedy: damages → real covenant; injunction → equitable servitude.
2
Decide burden or benefit: is the defendant a successor (burden) or the plaintiff (benefit)?
3
Run the elements: writing, intent, touch-and-concern, privity (covenants only), notice.
4
Check defenses & termination: changed conditions, merger, release, abandonment, estoppel.

Example 1: Injunction Sought

O sells Lot B to X with a deed promising "residential use only," intending to bind successors. X sells to Y, who has record notice and starts a store. The neighbor on Lot A seeks an injunction.

Example 2: Damages Sought

A and B sign a written agreement: B will maintain a shared fence. B sells to C without any deed connecting the burden, and the original promise was a standalone contract (no land transfer between A and B). A sues C for money damages.

Example 3: Common Scheme

Lot 1 Lot 2 Lot 3 Lot 4 no written restriction Subdivision: 1-3 restricted "residential only" May Lot 4's restriction be implied from the common scheme?

Termination & Defenses

Changed Conditions
Neighborhood so altered the restriction has lost all value.
Merger
Dominant and servient estates come under one owner.
Release / Abandonment
Written release, or conduct showing intent to abandon.
Estoppel / Laches
Reliance on assurances, or unreasonable delay in equity.

Common Mistakes

✕ Same elements both ways
Forgetting the burden needs horizontal privity + notice, while the benefit does not.
✕ Ignoring the remedy
Applying real-covenant privity when the party only seeks an injunction (equity).
✕ Skipping notice
A bona fide purchaser without notice takes free of an equitable servitude.
✕ Confusing privity types
Horizontal = relationship between original parties; vertical = succession to an estate.

Summary Comparison

Real CovenantEquitable Servitude
RemedyMoney damagesInjunction
WritingRequiredRequired (or common scheme)
IntentRequiredRequired
Touch & concernRequiredRequired
PrivityRequiredNot required
NoticeBurden sideRequired (BFP)

Question 1 of 5

A neighbor seeks an injunction to stop a successor owner from violating a written use restriction, but cannot prove horizontal privity. Which theory should she invoke?

Question 2 of 5

Which element is required for the burden of a real covenant to run, but NOT for the benefit?

Question 3 of 5

A buyer purchases a lot with no notice of an existing equitable servitude and pays value. Is the servitude enforceable against him?

Question 4 of 5

A landlocked parcel was created when an owner subdivided and sold the outer lot. What easement most likely arises?

Question 5 of 5

A defendant argues that the surrounding neighborhood has so completely changed that a residential-only restriction now has no value. This is which defense?