Seizure Analysis
Fourth Amendment
Learn when a police encounter becomes a seizure, what justification each level requires, and how to apply arrest and stop rules on exam questions.
What Counts as a Seizure?
A seizure of a person occurs when, under the totality of the circumstances, a reasonable person would not feel free to leave or otherwise terminate the encounter — and the person actually submits to the show of authority or is physically restrained.
The Encounter Spectrum
Two Levels of Justification
The Mendenhall Free-to-Leave Test
A seizure occurs only if, in view of all the circumstances, a reasonable innocent person would have believed that he was not free to leave.
The Terry Stop & Frisk
When Is It an Arrest?
An arrest requires probable cause. In a public place, an officer may arrest without a warrant for a felony or for a misdemeanor committed in the officer's presence.
Stop vs. Arrest
| Terry Stop | Arrest | |
|---|---|---|
| Justification | Reasonable suspicion | Probable cause |
| Duration | Brief, diligent | Indefinite (booking) |
| Scope of search | Pat-down for weapons | Search incident to arrest |
| Movement | Detained on scene | Taken into custody |
A Step-by-Step Approach
Worked Example: Consensual or Seizure?
An officer approaches a person on a public sidewalk, says "Good morning, may I ask you a few questions?" and the person stops to chat. The officer does not block the path or draw a weapon.
Worked Example: Valid Terry Stop?
At 2 a.m., officers see a man repeatedly peer into a closed jewelry store window, confer with two others, and pace back and forth. They stop him to investigate.
Worked Example: Stop Into Arrest
Officers lawfully stop a driver on reasonable suspicion, then handcuff him and transport him 30 miles to the station for two hours of questioning — without developing more evidence.
Common Mistakes
Quick Reference
| Action | Required Justification | Warrant? |
|---|---|---|
| Consensual encounter | None | No |
| Terry stop | Reasonable suspicion | No |
| Frisk | Suspicion: armed & dangerous | No |
| Public arrest | Probable cause | No |
| Home arrest | Probable cause | Arrest warrant |
Question 1 of 5
Under the Mendenhall test, a seizure of a person occurs when:
Question 2 of 5
A valid Terry stop requires which level of justification?
Question 3 of 5
Facts: Officers lawfully stop a pedestrian on reasonable suspicion of shoplifting. One officer immediately pats down the suspect's outer clothing, feeling for weapons, without any indication that the suspect is armed.
The pat-down reveals a small bag of contraband, which the officer seizes.
Was the frisk valid?
Question 4 of 5
To make a routine, non-exigent arrest of a suspect inside his own home, police generally need:
Question 5 of 5
Facts: Police lawfully stop a driver based on reasonable suspicion of involvement in a robbery. Without gaining additional evidence, they handcuff him, place him in a squad car, drive him 25 miles to the station, and interrogate him for three hours.
How should this detention be characterized?