01 / 20

Seizure Analysis
Fourth Amendment

Learn when a police encounter becomes a seizure, what justification each level requires, and how to apply arrest and stop rules on exam questions.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Counts as a Seizure?

A seizure of a person occurs when, under the totality of the circumstances, a reasonable person would not feel free to leave or otherwise terminate the encounter — and the person actually submits to the show of authority or is physically restrained.

The Encounter Spectrum

Consensual Encounter No suspicion needed Terry Stop Brief detention Reasonable suspicion Arrest Full custody Probable cause

Two Levels of Justification

Reasonable Suspicion
Specific, articulable facts suggesting criminal activity is afoot. More than a hunch, less than probable cause. Justifies a brief Terry stop.
Probable Cause
A fair probability that a crime was committed and this person committed it. Required for a full arrest and most warrants.

The Mendenhall Free-to-Leave Test

A seizure occurs only if, in view of all the circumstances, a reasonable innocent person would have believed that he was not free to leave.

1
Show of authority. Threatening presence of several officers, displayed weapon, or commanding tone.
2
Physical touching of the person, or blocking a path of exit.
3
Submission required. The person must yield to the authority — running away delays the seizure.

The Terry Stop & Frisk

Stop Reasonable suspicion of criminal activity Frisk Reasonable suspicion person is armed Limited Scope Brief, pat-down of outer clothing only

When Is It an Arrest?

An arrest requires probable cause. In a public place, an officer may arrest without a warrant for a felony or for a misdemeanor committed in the officer's presence.

Stop vs. Arrest

Terry Stop Arrest
JustificationReasonable suspicionProbable cause
DurationBrief, diligentIndefinite (booking)
Scope of searchPat-down for weaponsSearch incident to arrest
MovementDetained on sceneTaken into custody

A Step-by-Step Approach

1
Was there a seizure? Apply Mendenhall — would a reasonable person feel free to leave, and did the person submit?
2
Classify the level. Consensual encounter, Terry stop, or full arrest?
3
Match the justification. No suspicion, reasonable suspicion, or probable cause?
4
Check scope & warrants. Did the search/arrest stay within permissible bounds?

Worked Example: Consensual or Seizure?

An officer approaches a person on a public sidewalk, says "Good morning, may I ask you a few questions?" and the person stops to chat. The officer does not block the path or draw a weapon.

Worked Example: Valid Terry Stop?

At 2 a.m., officers see a man repeatedly peer into a closed jewelry store window, confer with two others, and pace back and forth. They stop him to investigate.

Worked Example: Stop Into Arrest

Officers lawfully stop a driver on reasonable suspicion, then handcuff him and transport him 30 miles to the station for two hours of questioning — without developing more evidence.

Common Mistakes

✕ Auto-Frisk
Assuming every valid stop allows a frisk. A frisk needs its own suspicion that the person is armed and dangerous.
✕ Forgetting Submission
Treating a fleeing suspect as "seized" the moment police signal. No seizure occurs until submission or capture.
✕ Wrong Threshold
Demanding probable cause for a brief stop, or accepting reasonable suspicion for a full arrest.

Quick Reference

Action Required Justification Warrant?
Consensual encounterNoneNo
Terry stopReasonable suspicionNo
FriskSuspicion: armed & dangerousNo
Public arrestProbable causeNo
Home arrestProbable causeArrest warrant

Question 1 of 5

Under the Mendenhall test, a seizure of a person occurs when:

Question 2 of 5

A valid Terry stop requires which level of justification?

Question 3 of 5

Was the frisk valid?

Question 4 of 5

To make a routine, non-exigent arrest of a suspect inside his own home, police generally need:

Question 5 of 5

How should this detention be characterized?

Key Takeaways

1
Seizure = no freedom to leave + submission or restraint (objective Mendenhall test).
2
Match justification to intrusion: none, reasonable suspicion, or probable cause.
3
Frisks and warrants each have their own requirements — never assume they follow automatically.