01 / 20

Search Analysis
The Fourth Amendment

Learn to determine whether a "search" occurred by applying the reasonable expectation of privacy test under the Fourth Amendment.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Counts as a Search?

The Fourth Amendment protects against unreasonable searches and seizures. But the protection only applies if government conduct qualifies as a "search" in the constitutional sense.

Two Paths to a Search

1. Privacy Test
Government conduct violates a reasonable expectation of privacy (Katz v. United States).
2. Trespass Test
Government physically intrudes on a constitutionally protected area to obtain information (United States v. Jones).

The Katz Privacy Test

Prong 1: Subjective Person actually expected privacy Prong 2: Objective Society recognizes that expectation as reasonable + Both prongs required = SEARCH

The Core Rule

We can model the analysis as a logical disjunction. A search exists when:

$$ \text{Search} = (\text{Subjective} \land \text{Objective}) \lor \text{Trespass} $$

Where Privacy Is Strongest

HOME Highest protection Curtilage (protected) Open fields (NO protection)

Search vs. Non-Search

Likely a SearchNot a Search
Inside the homeThermal imaging of heat—
Information given to others—Bank records, dialed numbers
Physical placementGPS attached to carVisual surveillance
Discarded items—Garbage left at curb
Open observation—Plain view / open fields

The Step-by-Step Approach

1
Identify the government conduct. Pinpoint exactly what the police did and what information they obtained.
2
Apply the trespass test. Did they physically intrude on a person, house, papers, or effects to get information?
3
Apply the Katz test. Did the defendant have a subjective expectation of privacy society finds reasonable?
4
Conclude. If either test is met, a search occurred. If not, the Fourth Amendment does not apply.

Example 1: Thermal Imaging

Police aim a thermal-imaging device at a home from a public street, detecting unusual heat consistent with a marijuana grow operation. No physical entry occurs.

Example 2: Curbside Garbage

House (protected) Property line Trash at curb (public area)

Example 3: GPS Tracker

Police physically attach a GPS device to the underside of a suspect's car and monitor its movements on public roads for four weeks.

Common Mistakes

✕ Skipping the threshold
Jumping to warrant analysis without first asking whether a search even occurred.
✕ Ignoring trespass
Forgetting that physical intrusion (Jones) is an independent path to finding a search.
✕ Privacy in shared info
Assuming privacy in info voluntarily given to third parties like banks or phone companies.

Summary Cheat Sheet

DoctrineTriggerResult
Katz testReasonable expectation violatedSearch
Jones trespassPhysical intrusion for infoSearch
Third-partyInfo shared with othersNo search
Open fieldsLand beyond curtilageNo search
Plain viewLawful vantage pointNo search

Question 1 of 5

Police walk to a suspect's front door, knock, and observe drugs in plain view through an open doorway. Has a search occurred?

Question 2 of 5

The government obtains a suspect's bank records directly from the bank. Has a search occurred?

Question 3 of 5

Officers attach a GPS device to a car and track it for a month. Which doctrine best establishes that a search occurred?

Question 4 of 5

Police use a thermal imager from the street to detect heat patterns inside a home. Is this a search?

Question 5 of 5

A farmer posts "No Trespassing" signs around a field 100 yards from his house. Police walk into the field and find marijuana. Search?

Key Takeaways

1
Always start at the threshold: ask whether a search occurred before anything else.
2
Two independent paths: the Katz privacy test and the Jones trespass test.
3
What you expose to the public generally loses protection — garbage, shared info, open fields.
4
The home is special: sense-enhancing tech reaching inside it is a search.

You Can Now Spot a Search

Apply the trespass and privacy tests in order, and the threshold question becomes routine on exam day.