Search Analysis
The Fourth Amendment
Learn to determine whether a "search" occurred by applying the reasonable expectation of privacy test under the Fourth Amendment.
What Counts as a Search?
The Fourth Amendment protects against unreasonable searches and seizures. But the protection only applies if government conduct qualifies as a "search" in the constitutional sense.
Two Paths to a Search
The Katz Privacy Test
The Core Rule
We can model the analysis as a logical disjunction. A search exists when:
$$ \text{Search} = (\text{Subjective} \land \text{Objective}) \lor \text{Trespass} $$Where Privacy Is Strongest
Search vs. Non-Search
| Likely a Search | Not a Search | |
|---|---|---|
| Inside the home | Thermal imaging of heat | — |
| Information given to others | — | Bank records, dialed numbers |
| Physical placement | GPS attached to car | Visual surveillance |
| Discarded items | — | Garbage left at curb |
| Open observation | — | Plain view / open fields |
The Step-by-Step Approach
Example 1: Thermal Imaging
Police aim a thermal-imaging device at a home from a public street, detecting unusual heat consistent with a marijuana grow operation. No physical entry occurs.
Example 2: Curbside Garbage
Example 3: GPS Tracker
Police physically attach a GPS device to the underside of a suspect's car and monitor its movements on public roads for four weeks.
Common Mistakes
Summary Cheat Sheet
| Doctrine | Trigger | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Katz test | Reasonable expectation violated | Search |
| Jones trespass | Physical intrusion for info | Search |
| Third-party | Info shared with others | No search |
| Open fields | Land beyond curtilage | No search |
| Plain view | Lawful vantage point | No search |
Question 1 of 5
Police walk to a suspect's front door, knock, and observe drugs in plain view through an open doorway. Has a search occurred?
Question 2 of 5
The government obtains a suspect's bank records directly from the bank. Has a search occurred?
Question 3 of 5
Officers attach a GPS device to a car and track it for a month. Which doctrine best establishes that a search occurred?
Question 4 of 5
Police use a thermal imager from the street to detect heat patterns inside a home. Is this a search?
Question 5 of 5
A farmer posts "No Trespassing" signs around a field 100 yards from his house. Police walk into the field and find marijuana. Search?
Key Takeaways
You Can Now Spot a Search
Apply the trespass and privacy tests in order, and the threshold question becomes routine on exam day.