Rule 403
Balancing
When relevant evidence may still be excluded because its danger of unfair prejudice substantially outweighs its probative value.
What is Rule 403?
Federal Rule of Evidence 403 is a discretionary screening tool. Even when evidence is relevant and otherwise admissible, the judge may exclude it if certain dangers are too great.
Two Key Terms
The Balancing Image
The Formal Standard
The Six Dangers
Prejudicial vs. Unfairly Prejudicial
How to Apply the Test
Example 1: Routine Photo
Facts: In a car-accident case, the plaintiff offers a clear photo of the damaged vehicles to show point of impact.
Example 2: Gruesome Photos
Facts: The prosecution offers ten graphic autopsy photos. The cause of death is already admitted by the defense, so the photos add little.
Example 3: Close Call
Facts: A single graphic photo is essential to prove the defendant's intent (a contested element) and there is no less inflammatory alternative.
Common Mistakes
Quick Reference
| Probative Value | Unfair Prejudice | |
|---|---|---|
| Question asked | Does it prove a real fact? | Does it provoke a gut reaction? |
| Effect of conceded fact | Lowers value | Danger stands out |
| Standard symbol | \( P \) | \( D \) |
| Result if \( D \gg P \) | — | Excluded |
| Result otherwise | Admitted | — |
Question 1 of 5
Under Rule 403, relevant evidence is excluded only when its danger of unfair prejudice does what to its probative value?
Question 2 of 5
Which best describes "unfair prejudice" for Rule 403 purposes?
Question 3 of 5
In a murder trial, the defendant has already stipulated that the victim died from a gunshot wound. The prosecution nonetheless seeks to admit twelve large, color autopsy photographs depicting the wounds in graphic detail.
The defense objects under Rule 403, arguing the photos add nothing to the conceded cause of death while inflaming the jury.
How should the court most likely rule?
Question 4 of 5
Before a court reaches a Rule 403 analysis, the evidence must first be:
Question 5 of 5
A single graphic photo is the only way to prove a hotly contested element of the crime. There is no less inflammatory substitute. How should the court most likely rule?
Key Takeaways
You've Mastered Rule 403
Remember the asymmetry: relevant evidence stays in unless its danger substantially outweighs its probative value.