Rule 11
Compliance
Every paper you sign carries a certification. Learn to spot when an attorney crosses the line into a Rule 11 violation.
What Is Rule 11?
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 11 governs the signing of pleadings, motions, and other papers filed in court. Its purpose is to deter frivolous filings and ensure attorneys take responsibility for what they submit.
The Four Certifications
Who and What It Covers
The Rule, Stated
The Reasonable Inquiry Standard
Rule 11 uses an objective standard. The question is not whether the attorney acted in good faith, but whether a competent attorney would have made the same filing after reasonable investigation.
Frivolous vs. Nonfrivolous
| Violation (Frivolous) | Compliant (Nonfrivolous) | |
|---|---|---|
| Legal Theory | No support and no good-faith argument to change the law | Existing law, or a reasoned argument to extend it |
| Facts | Knowingly false or wholly unsupported | Has support, or likely will after discovery |
| Purpose | To harass, delay, or run up costs | To advance a legitimate claim or defense |
| Inquiry | None, or plainly inadequate | Reasonable under the circumstances |
How to Spot a Violation
The 21-Day Safe Harbor
Example 1: Factual Failure
An attorney files a complaint alleging the defendant signed a contract on a specific date. The attorney never reviewed the contract and had no basis to believe it existed.
Example 2: Improper Purpose
A lawyer files a series of repetitive motions, each clearly meritless, with the stated goal of driving up the opponent's legal fees until they settle.
Example 3: A Close Call
An attorney files a motion urging the court to overturn settled precedent, openly acknowledging that current law is against the client but presenting a reasoned argument for change.
Common Mistakes
Sanctions Summary
| Key Point | |
|---|---|
| Nature | Discretionary; the court "may" impose them |
| Goal | Deterrence, not compensation or punishment |
| Who is liable | Attorney, law firm, or party responsible |
| Forms | Nonmonetary directives, penalties, or fees |
| Safe harbor | 21 days for party motions; not required for court action |
Question 1 of 5
Which document is NOT governed by Rule 11?
Question 2 of 5
An attorney sincerely believes a claim is valid but did no investigation. The claim turns out baseless. Is this a Rule 11 violation?
Question 3 of 5
A lawyer files a motion arguing for a good-faith change to existing law, openly noting that current precedent is contrary. Has she violated Rule 11?
Question 4 of 5
Under the safe harbor, how many days must a party give an opponent to withdraw a paper before filing a Rule 11 motion?
Question 5 of 5
What is the primary purpose of Rule 11 sanctions?