Right to Counsel
When Does It Apply?
The Constitution guarantees the assistance of a lawyer — but the source, timing, and scope of that right depend on which amendment applies.
Two Distinct Rights to Counsel
The phrase "right to counsel" actually refers to two separate constitutional rights. They come from different amendments, attach at different times, and protect against different things.
Key Terms
When Each Right Attaches
The Sixth Amendment Rule
The Sixth Amendment guarantees: "In all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right... to have the Assistance of Counsel for his defence."
The Fifth Amendment (Miranda) Rule
Under Miranda v. Arizona, a suspect in custody must be warned of the right to remain silent and the right to counsel before interrogation.
Offense-Specific vs. Not
A Step-by-Step Approach
What Counts as a Critical Stage?
Example 1: Interrogation
Police arrest Dana for burglary. Before questioning at the station, she says, "I want a lawyer." Officers keep questioning her anyway. Which right was violated?
Example 2: Post-Charge Lineup
After being indicted for armed robbery, Marcus is placed in a physical lineup at the police station. His appointed attorney is not notified and is absent. Is this a problem?
Example 3: Unrelated Crime
Lena is charged with theft and has counsel. While in jail, police read fresh Miranda warnings and question her about an unrelated arson. She waives her rights and confesses to the arson. Admissible?
Common Mistakes
Summary Comparison
| 5th Amendment | 6th Amendment | |
|---|---|---|
| Trigger | Custodial interrogation | Formal charges filed |
| Source | Miranda v. Arizona | Sixth Amendment text |
| Offense-specific? | No | Yes |
| How invoked | Must be asserted | Attaches automatically |
| Protects | Against self-incrimination | Fair adversarial trial |
Quick Review
Now test your ability to determine when the right to counsel applies in the following scenarios.
Question 1 of 5
When does the Sixth Amendment right to counsel attach?
Question 2 of 5
A suspect in custody clearly says, "I want my lawyer." Which right is being invoked?
Question 3 of 5
Defendant is charged with theft and has counsel. Police question her about an unrelated burglary after a valid Miranda waiver. Is her burglary confession admissible?
Question 4 of 5
Which of the following is NOT a critical stage requiring counsel under the Sixth Amendment?
Question 5 of 5
A man is questioned at a police station after voluntarily walking in, free to leave at any time, and is not yet charged. Does any right to counsel apply?