Research
Sufficiency
Knowing when you have enough authority to answer a legal question — and when you must keep digging.
What Is Research Sufficiency?
Research sufficiency is the judgment of whether the legal sources in front of you are complete enough to resolve the issue — or whether material gaps remain that demand further research.
Key Terms
Why It Matters
A lawyer who stops researching too early gives wrong advice. A lawyer who researches forever wastes time and client money. Sufficiency is the skill of finding the stopping point.
The Sufficiency Test
Here \( E_i \) is each element of the rule and \( G \) is the set of remaining gaps. If even one element lacks support, or \( G \neq \varnothing \), research is insufficient.
Mapping Elements to Authority
Sufficient vs. Complete
How to Apply It
Worked Example One
Issue: Is an oral contract for the sale of goods worth $800 enforceable? Provided sources: UCC § 2-201 (Statute of Frauds, threshold $500) and a case interpreting the writing requirement.
Worked Example Two
Issue: Did the defendant negligently injure the plaintiff? Provided sources establish duty, breach, and causation — but contain nothing on the measure of damages.
Worked Example Three
Issue: May the state ban a roadside protest sign? Sources: an on-point statute and a 1998 appellate case upholding the ban — but the case has a dissent flagging a pending Supreme Court issue.
Common Mistakes
Sufficiency Summary
| Sufficient | Insufficient | |
|---|---|---|
| Elements covered | All | One or more missing |
| Counter-authority | Resolved | Unresolved |
| Gap set \( G \) | \( G = \varnothing \) | \( G \neq \varnothing \) |
| Next action | Conclude | Keep researching |
Quick Recap
Question 1 of 5
Research is sufficient when:
Question 2 of 5
Sources establish duty, breach, and causation for a negligence claim but say nothing about damages. The research is:
Question 3 of 5
The difference between sufficient and complete research is best described as:
Question 4 of 5
You have located an on-point statute and a 1998 appellate decision upholding the rule. The decision contains a strong dissent noting that the issue is currently pending before the state Supreme Court and that the majority's reasoning may not survive review.
Is the research sufficient to give a confident answer?
Question 5 of 5
The "point of diminishing returns" in research is best captured by:
You've Got Enough
Decompose, map, test for gaps, and stop when \( G = \varnothing \). Sufficiency means answering with confidence — no more, no less.