Research Question
Framing
Learn to break a legal matter into the precise research questions that must be answered before you can advise a client.
What Is a Research Question?
A research question is a narrow, answerable legal issue that you must resolve to move a matter forward. Good lawyering begins not with looking things up, but with knowing exactly what to look up.
Why Framing Comes First
Anatomy of a Good Question
The Framing Formula
We can express this as a relation where the answer depends on the rule applied to the facts: $$A = R(F)$$ The answer \(A\) is the result of applying the legal rule \(R\) to the material facts \(F\).
Decomposing a Matter
Issue vs. Research Question
A Step-by-Step Approach
Worked Example: Contracts
Worked Example: Torts
Worked Example: Multiple Issues
Common Mistakes
Weak vs. Strong Questions
| Weak | Strong | |
|---|---|---|
| Scope | Whole area of law | Single disputed element |
| Facts | Generic or absent | Material facts included |
| Jurisdiction | Unstated | Clearly named |
| Answer type | Open-ended essay | Yes / no / how much |
Quick Recap
Question 1 of 5
Which of the following is the best-framed research question?
Question 2 of 5
A single legal issue can generate how many research questions?
Question 3 of 5
Which element is missing from: "Does a text message satisfy the writing requirement?"
Question 4 of 5
In the relation \(A = R(F)\), what does \(F\) represent?
Question 5 of 5
Memo from supervising attorney: Our client, a small bakery, signed a year-long commercial lease. Six months in, the landlord shut off heat for two weeks during winter, forcing the bakery to close. The client wants out of the lease and back rent for the closed period.
Which is the strongest first research question to frame?
You Can Now Frame Questions
Always isolate the law, the disputed element, the key facts, and the outcome before you research.