01 / 20

Research Question
Framing

Learn to break a legal matter into the precise research questions that must be answered before you can advise a client.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is a Research Question?

A research question is a narrow, answerable legal issue that you must resolve to move a matter forward. Good lawyering begins not with looking things up, but with knowing exactly what to look up.

Why Framing Comes First

Client Facts Frame Questions Research Answers

Anatomy of a Good Question

1
Jurisdiction & body of law. Which court, statute, or doctrine governs?
2
The legal standard. The rule or element being tested.
3
The material facts. The facts that actually trigger the rule.
4
The needed outcome. A yes/no or how-much answer you can act on.

The Framing Formula

We can express this as a relation where the answer depends on the rule applied to the facts: $$A = R(F)$$ The answer \(A\) is the result of applying the legal rule \(R\) to the material facts \(F\).

Decomposing a Matter

The Matter "Can client recover?" Issue 1 Duty owed? Issue 2 Breach? Issue 3 Causation? Research Question

Issue vs. Research Question

An Issue
A broad area of dispute. Example: "Was there a valid contract?" Often too wide to research directly.
A Research Question
A narrow, fact-specific query. Example: "Does a text message satisfy the writing requirement under the Statute of Frauds?"

A Step-by-Step Approach

1
Spot the claims and defenses. List every legal theory in play.
2
Break each into elements. Identify which element is actually disputed.
3
Tie facts to the element. Attach the specific facts that make it close.
4
Phrase as a yes/no question. State jurisdiction, standard, and facts.

Worked Example: Contracts

Worked Example: Torts

Q1
Duty: Does a store owe a business invitee a duty to warn of a wet floor?
Q2
Breach: Is failing to post a sign a breach of the reasonable-care standard?

Worked Example: Multiple Issues

RQ-A
Does firing for reporting safety violations fall under the public-policy exception to at-will employment?
RQ-B
Does an unexpired written term contract override at-will status here?
RQ-C
Are unpaid bonuses recoverable as contract damages on early termination?

Common Mistakes

✕ Too Broad
"What is contract law?" is not answerable. Narrow to a disputed element.
✕ No Facts
Omitting the key facts hides what makes the question genuinely contested.
✕ Wrong Jurisdiction
Failing to specify the governing law can lead you to inapplicable authority.

Weak vs. Strong Questions

Weak Strong
ScopeWhole area of lawSingle disputed element
FactsGeneric or absentMaterial facts included
JurisdictionUnstatedClearly named
Answer typeOpen-ended essayYes / no / how much

Quick Recap

Question 1 of 5

Which of the following is the best-framed research question?

Question 2 of 5

A single legal issue can generate how many research questions?

Question 3 of 5

Which element is missing from: "Does a text message satisfy the writing requirement?"

Question 4 of 5

In the relation \(A = R(F)\), what does \(F\) represent?

Question 5 of 5

Which is the strongest first research question to frame?

You Can Now Frame Questions

Always isolate the law, the disputed element, the key facts, and the outcome before you research.