01 / 20

Res Ipsa
Loquitur

"The thing speaks for itself" — proving negligence by circumstantial inference when direct evidence of breach is unavailable.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is Res Ipsa Loquitur?

In a typical negligence case, the plaintiff must produce direct evidence that the defendant breached a duty of care. But sometimes the accident itself is so unusual that it would not normally occur without negligence.

Why It Matters

Res ipsa loquitur is a doctrine of circumstantial evidence. It does not change the elements of negligence — it provides a way to satisfy the breach element when the plaintiff cannot point to exactly what the defendant did wrong.

The Problem
Plaintiff is injured but cannot prove how the defendant was careless.
The Solution
The accident's nature permits an inference of negligence.
The Effect
Gets the plaintiff past a directed verdict to the jury.

The Classic Example

Surgical Suite Patient unconscious Defendants in control Instrument left inside infer Negligence "Speaks for itself" The injury itself implies someone was careless — a sponge does not stay inside a body absent negligence.

The Three Elements

1
Type of accident. The event is of a kind that ordinarily does not occur in the absence of negligence.
2
Exclusive control. The instrumentality causing harm was in the exclusive control of the defendant.
3
Plaintiff not at fault. The injury was not due to any voluntary action or contribution by the plaintiff.

Formal Structure

Res Ipsa Established? Element 1 No-negligence? Element 2 Control Element 3 P not at fault all three met Inference of breach reaches the jury Plaintiff survives motion for directed verdict

Inference vs. Presumption

A crucial bar-exam distinction is the procedural effect of res ipsa. In most jurisdictions it creates a permissible inference — not a mandatory presumption.

Permissible Inference (majority)
Jury may find negligence but need not. Burden of proof stays with plaintiff.
Rebuttable Presumption (minority)
Burden of production shifts to defendant to explain the accident.

How to Apply It

1
Identify the gap. Note the plaintiff lacks direct evidence of the breach element.
2
Test element 1. Would this accident ordinarily happen without negligence?
3
Test element 2. Was the instrumentality in the defendant's exclusive control?
4
Test element 3. Rule out the plaintiff's own conduct as a cause.
5
State the effect. The inference reaches the jury; it does not shift the burden of persuasion.

Example 1: Falling Barrel

Byrne v. Boadle: A barrel of flour falls from a warehouse window and strikes a passerby below. No witness saw how it fell.

window Plaintiff (P) barrel falls

Example 2: Multiple Defendants

Ybarra v. Spangard: An unconscious surgical patient awakens with a shoulder injury unrelated to the operation. Several staff had access during surgery.

D1 D2 D3 Patient unconscious Each defendant had control at some point

Example 3: When It Fails

A customer slips on a wet floor in a busy supermarket. Many shoppers had walked through the aisle, and the cause of the spill is unknown.

The plaintiff must instead prove the store had actual or constructive notice of the hazard. Res ipsa is not a substitute for ordinary negligence proof when control is shared.

Common Mistakes

✕ Shifting the burden
Treating res ipsa as automatically shifting the burden of persuasion. In most states it only creates a permissible inference.
✕ Skipping control
Forgetting the exclusive-control element when multiple parties or the public had access to the instrumentality.
✕ Ignoring plaintiff's role
Overlooking that the plaintiff's own conduct must be ruled out as a contributing cause.
✕ Replacing all elements
Thinking res ipsa proves the whole case. It only addresses breach — duty, causation, and damages still apply.

Summary Table

Ordinary Negligence Res Ipsa Loquitur
Proof of breachDirect evidence requiredInferred from the accident
Plaintiff's burdenShow specific careless actShow the three elements
Procedural effectStandard burden of proofPermissible inference (majority)
ControlNot specifically requiredDefendant's exclusive control
Other elementsDuty, causation, damagesStill must be proven

Quick Recap

Element 1
Accident type does not usually occur without negligence.
Element 2
Defendant had exclusive control of the instrumentality.
Element 3
Plaintiff did not contribute to the injury.

Question 1 of 5

Which element is NOT required to invoke res ipsa loquitur?

Question 2 of 5

In the majority of jurisdictions, the procedural effect of res ipsa loquitur is to create:

Question 3 of 5

Will res ipsa loquitur most likely apply?

Question 4 of 5

Res ipsa loquitur, when it applies, satisfies which element of a negligence claim?

Question 5 of 5

Under Ybarra v. Spangard, what is the most likely result?

You've Mastered Res Ipsa