Res Ipsa
Loquitur
"The thing speaks for itself" — proving negligence by circumstantial inference when direct evidence of breach is unavailable.
What Is Res Ipsa Loquitur?
In a typical negligence case, the plaintiff must produce direct evidence that the defendant breached a duty of care. But sometimes the accident itself is so unusual that it would not normally occur without negligence.
Why It Matters
Res ipsa loquitur is a doctrine of circumstantial evidence. It does not change the elements of negligence — it provides a way to satisfy the breach element when the plaintiff cannot point to exactly what the defendant did wrong.
The Classic Example
The Three Elements
Formal Structure
Inference vs. Presumption
A crucial bar-exam distinction is the procedural effect of res ipsa. In most jurisdictions it creates a permissible inference — not a mandatory presumption.
How to Apply It
Example 1: Falling Barrel
Byrne v. Boadle: A barrel of flour falls from a warehouse window and strikes a passerby below. No witness saw how it fell.
Example 2: Multiple Defendants
Ybarra v. Spangard: An unconscious surgical patient awakens with a shoulder injury unrelated to the operation. Several staff had access during surgery.
Example 3: When It Fails
A customer slips on a wet floor in a busy supermarket. Many shoppers had walked through the aisle, and the cause of the spill is unknown.
The plaintiff must instead prove the store had actual or constructive notice of the hazard. Res ipsa is not a substitute for ordinary negligence proof when control is shared.
Common Mistakes
Summary Table
| Ordinary Negligence | Res Ipsa Loquitur | |
|---|---|---|
| Proof of breach | Direct evidence required | Inferred from the accident |
| Plaintiff's burden | Show specific careless act | Show the three elements |
| Procedural effect | Standard burden of proof | Permissible inference (majority) |
| Control | Not specifically required | Defendant's exclusive control |
| Other elements | Duty, causation, damages | Still must be proven |
Quick Recap
Question 1 of 5
Which element is NOT required to invoke res ipsa loquitur?
Question 2 of 5
In the majority of jurisdictions, the procedural effect of res ipsa loquitur is to create:
Question 3 of 5
A customer in a self-service grocery slips on a grape in the produce aisle. The store has dozens of shoppers per hour who handle the fruit, and there is no evidence of how long the grape was on the floor or who dropped it.
Will res ipsa loquitur most likely apply?
Question 4 of 5
Res ipsa loquitur, when it applies, satisfies which element of a negligence claim?
Question 5 of 5
An unconscious patient undergoes routine surgery and wakes with a serious burn on an area of the body unrelated to the operation. Several members of the surgical team had access to the patient, but the patient cannot identify which one caused the burn.
Under Ybarra v. Spangard, what is the most likely result?