01 / 20

Removal and
Remand

When can a defendant move a case from state court to federal court — and when must the federal court send it back?

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is Removal?

Removal lets a defendant transfer a civil case that was filed in state court into the federal district court for the district covering where the state action is pending.

What Is Remand?

Remand is the reverse: the federal court sends the removed case back to state court. This happens when removal was improper — either the federal court lacks subject-matter jurisdiction or a procedural rule was violated.

The Two-Way Path

State Court Federal Court REMOVAL REMAND Defendant removes → if improper, court remands

The Core Rule for Removal

A case is removable to federal court only if the federal court would have had original subject-matter jurisdiction over it. That means there must be either:

Federal Question
The plaintiff's claim arises under federal law (the well-pleaded complaint).
Diversity
Complete diversity of citizenship AND amount in controversy exceeds \( \$75{,}000 \).

Two Key Restrictions

1
Forum-Defendant Rule. In a diversity-only case, removal is barred if any properly joined and served defendant is a citizen of the state where the suit was filed.
2
One-Year Limit. A diversity case generally cannot be removed more than one year after the action was commenced (unless plaintiff acted in bad faith).

Removal Procedure

1
File within 30 days. The notice of removal must be filed within 30 days of receiving the initial pleading (or paper showing the case became removable).
2
Unanimity. All properly joined and served defendants must consent to removal.
3
Where to file. File the notice in the federal district court embracing the place where the state action is pending.

Two Grounds for Remand

No Jurisdiction
If the court lacks subject-matter jurisdiction, it must remand at any time — there is no time limit on this objection.
Procedural Defect
A defect in the removal procedure (e.g., late filing, no unanimity) must be raised by motion within 30 days of removal, or it is waived.

How to Analyze a Problem

1
Original jurisdiction? Would a federal court have had original jurisdiction (federal question or diversity)?
2
Diversity limits? If diversity-only, check the forum-defendant rule and the one-year limit.
3
Procedure? Timely notice (30 days), unanimous consent, correct court.
4
Remand? Any defect → is it jurisdictional (anytime) or procedural (30 days, then waived)?

Example 1: Clean Removal

A New York plaintiff sues a California defendant in New York state court for breach of contract, seeking \( \$200{,}000 \). The defendant removes within 20 days.

Example 2: Forum-Defendant Trap

A Texas plaintiff sues a Texas defendant in Texas state court, asserting only a state-law negligence claim for \( \$500{,}000 \). The defendant tries to remove based on diversity... wait, both are Texas citizens.

Example 3: Procedural Defect

A federal-question case is properly removable, but only one of three defendants signs the notice of removal. The plaintiff waits 45 days, then moves to remand for lack of unanimous consent.

Common Mistakes

✗ Plaintiff removing
Only defendants may remove. A plaintiff can never remove, even if a federal counterclaim is filed.
✗ Applying limits to FQ
The forum-defendant rule and one-year limit apply only to diversity cases, not federal-question cases.
✗ Confusing the clocks
Procedural defects waive after 30 days; jurisdictional defects can be raised anytime.

Quick Reference

Removal Remand
Who actsDefendantPlaintiff (motion)
DirectionState → FederalFederal → State
Time limit30 days from pleading30 days (procedural)
Jurisdictional defectBars removalAnytime, never waived
Diversity-only limitsForum-defendant; 1 yearGround for remand

Time to Apply It

You've learned the core rules of removal and remand. Now test whether removal or remand is proper across five scenarios.

Question 1 of 5

A plaintiff sues in state court asserting a federal patent claim. The defendant, a citizen of the forum state, files a timely notice of removal. Is removal proper?

Question 2 of 5

A Florida plaintiff sues a Georgia defendant on a state-law claim for \( \$90{,}000 \) in Florida state court. The defendant removes. Is removal proper?

Question 3 of 5

A removed diversity case has been in federal court for two months. The plaintiff now discovers the parties are not completely diverse and moves to remand. Will the court grant remand?

Question 4 of 5

In a properly removable diversity case, only one of two served defendants consented to removal. The plaintiff moves to remand 40 days after removal. Result?

Question 5 of 5

A diversity action was filed in state court 14 months ago. The case only recently became removable, and the plaintiff did not act in bad faith. The defendant removes. Proper?