01 / 20

Relevance
Federal Rules of Evidence

Learn how to determine whether evidence is relevant under FRE 401 & 402 — and when relevant evidence may still be excluded.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Does Relevant Mean?

Under the Federal Rules of Evidence, relevance is the threshold question for admitting any piece of evidence. Evidence that is not relevant is never admissible.

The Two Prongs of Relevance

Materiality Fact "of consequence" Does the fact matter to a legal issue in the case? Probative Value "Any tendency" Does it make the fact more or less probable? Both required = Relevant

A Very Low Bar

Relevance under FRE 401 sets a minimal threshold. The evidence does not have to prove anything by itself — it only needs any tendency to affect the probability of a consequential fact.

"Any Tendency"
Even a slight nudge in probability is enough. Evidence need not be sufficient — just helpful.
Brick ≠ Wall
A single brick is relevant even though it is not the whole wall. Each piece can build the case.

The Core Rule: FRE 402

Evidence offered Is it relevant? No Yes Inadmissible Admissible unless excluded by a rule

The FRE 403 Balancing Test

Even relevant evidence may be excluded. Under FRE 403, the court excludes evidence only if its probative value is substantially outweighed by a danger of unfair prejudice, confusion, or waste of time.

Relevant vs. Admissible

A classic exam trap: relevance and admissibility are not the same thing. All admissible evidence must be relevant, but not all relevant evidence is admissible.

Relevant
Passes FRE 401 — has any tendency to prove a consequential fact. The starting gate.
Admissible
Relevant AND not barred by FRE 403, hearsay, privilege, or another exclusionary rule.

How to Analyze Relevance

1
Identify the fact to be proved. What proposition does the offering party want the jury to believe?
2
Ask if the fact is "of consequence." Does it relate to an element, defense, or credibility issue? (Materiality)
3
Ask if the evidence has "any tendency." Does it make that fact even slightly more or less probable? (Probative value)
4
Apply FRE 403. Is probative value substantially outweighed by unfair prejudice or other dangers?

Worked Example One

In a car accident negligence case, plaintiff offers evidence that the defendant was texting at the moment of the crash. Is it relevant?

Worked Example Two

In a contract dispute over a software sale, defendant offers evidence that the plaintiff got a speeding ticket two years earlier. Is it relevant?

Worked Example Three

In an assault prosecution, the State offers gruesome, blood-soaked photos of the victim. The injuries are not disputed. Relevant? Admissible?

Common Mistakes

✕ Confusing relevant with admissible
Relevant evidence can still be excluded by FRE 403, hearsay, or privilege. Always check for a second bar.
✕ Demanding too much
FRE 401 only needs "any tendency." Don't require the evidence to prove the point on its own.
✕ Misreading FRE 403
Exclusion needs prejudice to "substantially outweigh." A simple "outweigh" is not enough.

Quick Reference

Rule Question Result
FRE 401Any tendency to prove a consequential fact?Defines relevance
FRE 402Is the evidence relevant?Relevant = admissible (default)
FRE 403Does prejudice substantially outweigh?May exclude relevant evidence

Question 1 of 5

Under FRE 401, evidence is relevant if it has which level of tendency to prove a consequential fact?

Question 2 of 5

Which rule provides that relevant evidence is admissible unless otherwise excluded?

Question 3 of 5

What is the strongest reason this evidence is likely not relevant?

Question 4 of 5

Under FRE 403, a court may exclude relevant evidence only when its probative value is:

Question 5 of 5

A piece of evidence is relevant but heavily prejudicial. Which statement is most accurate?

Putting It Together

1
Define relevance (401). Any tendency to prove a fact of consequence.
2
Admit relevant evidence (402). Relevant = admissible by default; irrelevant is never admissible.
3
Balance the dangers (403). Exclude only if prejudice substantially outweighs probative value.
4
Watch the trap. Relevant does not equal admissible.

You're Ready to Spot Relevance

Remember: 401 defines, 402 admits, 403 balances. Always ask whether the evidence moves the needle on a fact that matters — then check for a second bar.