01 / 20

Recording Acts
Who Takes Priority?

When the same land is sold twice, recording statutes decide who wins. Learn to resolve priority disputes among competing grantees.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

The Double Sale Problem

At common law, when an owner conveyed the same property to two different buyers, the first in time always won. This rule could ruin an innocent later buyer who had no way to know about the earlier deal.

Key Terms

Bona Fide Purchaser
A buyer who pays value and takes without notice of a prior claim. Donees and heirs are not protected.
Record
To file a deed in the public land records, giving the world constructive notice of the conveyance.
Notice
Knowledge of a prior interest. Can be actual, constructive (record), or inquiry (visible facts).
Value
Substantial consideration. A gift recipient pays no value and is not a protected purchaser.

Three Kinds of Notice

1
Actual notice: the buyer truly knows of the prior interest.
2
Constructive notice: a prior deed is properly recorded, so the law charges everyone with knowing it.
3
Inquiry notice: visible facts (e.g., someone living on the land) would prompt a reasonable buyer to investigate.

Three Types of Recording Statutes

Race First to RECORD wins Notice does not matter Notice Last BFP wins No need to record first Race-Notice BFP who records first wins Needs BOTH

Reading the Statute Language

R
Race: "first recorded." No mention of notice or good faith.
N
Notice: "without notice" or "in good faith." No requirement to record first.
RN
Race-Notice: "without notice ... whose conveyance is first recorded." Contains both phrases.

The Notice Statute Rule

O sells to A, then later to B O → A A fails to record O → B B has no notice B wins even if A records first afterward

The Race-Notice Rule

Condition 1 No notice of prior interest when buying + Condition 2 Records before prior grantee wins the race

Notice vs. Race-Notice

Notice Race-Notice
Must be BFP (no notice)?YesYes
Must record first?NoYes
If buyer never records?Can still winLoses
Who wins ties?Last BFPBFP who records first

How to Apply a Recording Act

1
Identify the statute type from its language: race, notice, or race-notice.
2
Find the subsequent purchaser and ask: did she pay value? Was she a donee or heir (not protected)?
3
Check notice at the time of purchase: actual, constructive, or inquiry.
4
If race-notice, check who recorded first. Then apply the statute to declare a winner.

Example 1: Notice Statute

O sells Blackacre to A, who does not record. O then sells the same land to B for value. B has no notice of A. Later, A records. Statute: notice.

O→A O→B (BFP) A records time →

Example 2: Race-Notice

O sells to A (unrecorded), then to B, a BFP without notice. A records before B does. Statute: race-notice.

O→A O→B (BFP) A records B records

Example 3: The Shelter Rule

B is a protected BFP who beats A under the recording act. B then sells to C, who actually knew about A. Does C lose because of his notice?

Common Mistakes

✕ Confusing statute types
Treating a notice statute like race-notice and wrongly requiring the buyer to record first.
✕ Protecting donees
Gift recipients and heirs pay no value, so they are never bona fide purchasers.
✕ Ignoring inquiry notice
A buyer who sees someone occupying the land has a duty to investigate possession.
✕ Wrong notice timing
Notice acquired after closing does not destroy BFP status; only notice at purchase counts.

Summary: Who Wins?

Race Notice Race-Notice
Need value?YesYesYes
Need no notice?NoYesYes
Record first?YesNoYes
WinnerFirst to recordLast BFPBFP first to record

Question 1 of 5

Which feature is unique to a race-notice statute compared to a pure notice statute?

Question 2 of 5

O sells to A (who does not record), then to B, a BFP without notice, in a notice jurisdiction. A records first. Who prevails?

Question 3 of 5

In a race-notice jurisdiction, O sells to A (unrecorded), then to B (a BFP without notice). A records before B. Who prevails?

Question 4 of 5

O gives Blackacre to his nephew N as a gift; N does not record. O then sells to B, a BFP. Why is N unprotected by the recording act?

Question 5 of 5

B is a protected BFP who defeated A. B then sells to C, who actually knew about A. In most jurisdictions, who prevails between C and A?