Recording Acts
Who Takes Priority?
When the same land is sold twice, recording statutes decide who wins. Learn to resolve priority disputes among competing grantees.
The Double Sale Problem
At common law, when an owner conveyed the same property to two different buyers, the first in time always won. This rule could ruin an innocent later buyer who had no way to know about the earlier deal.
Key Terms
Three Kinds of Notice
Three Types of Recording Statutes
Reading the Statute Language
The Notice Statute Rule
The Race-Notice Rule
Notice vs. Race-Notice
| Notice | Race-Notice | |
|---|---|---|
| Must be BFP (no notice)? | Yes | Yes |
| Must record first? | No | Yes |
| If buyer never records? | Can still win | Loses |
| Who wins ties? | Last BFP | BFP who records first |
How to Apply a Recording Act
Example 1: Notice Statute
O sells Blackacre to A, who does not record. O then sells the same land to B for value. B has no notice of A. Later, A records. Statute: notice.
Example 2: Race-Notice
O sells to A (unrecorded), then to B, a BFP without notice. A records before B does. Statute: race-notice.
Example 3: The Shelter Rule
B is a protected BFP who beats A under the recording act. B then sells to C, who actually knew about A. Does C lose because of his notice?
Common Mistakes
Summary: Who Wins?
| Race | Notice | Race-Notice | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Need value? | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Need no notice? | No | Yes | Yes |
| Record first? | Yes | No | Yes |
| Winner | First to record | Last BFP | BFP first to record |
Question 1 of 5
Which feature is unique to a race-notice statute compared to a pure notice statute?
Question 2 of 5
O sells to A (who does not record), then to B, a BFP without notice, in a notice jurisdiction. A records first. Who prevails?
Question 3 of 5
In a race-notice jurisdiction, O sells to A (unrecorded), then to B (a BFP without notice). A records before B. Who prevails?
Question 4 of 5
O gives Blackacre to his nephew N as a gift; N does not record. O then sells to B, a BFP. Why is N unprotected by the recording act?
Question 5 of 5
B is a protected BFP who defeated A. B then sells to C, who actually knew about A. In most jurisdictions, who prevails between C and A?