01 / 20

Proximate Cause
Legal Causation

When does a defendant's act count as the legal cause of harm? Master the test of foreseeability that limits liability in negligence.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

Two Kinds of Causation

Negligence requires the plaintiff to prove causation. Courts split this into two distinct questions, and a defendant escapes liability if either fails.

Actual Cause
"Cause in fact." Did the harm actually flow from the act? The but-for test: but for the defendant's conduct, would the harm have occurred?
Proximate Cause
"Legal cause." Even if the act was a factual cause, is it fair to hold the defendant liable for this particular harm?

Why Limit Liability?

A single negligent act can ripple outward and cause harm far beyond what anyone could expect. Proximate cause draws a line so defendants are not liable for every remote consequence.

The Causal Chain

Negligent Act Foreseeable Risk Harm to Plaintiff Unforeseeable harm = chain broken

The Foreseeability Test

The classic formulation comes from Palsgraf v. Long Island R.R.: liability extends only to those within the zone of foreseeable risk. The negligence is judged against the danger that could reasonably be anticipated.

Three Things Must Be Foreseeable

1
Foreseeable plaintiff. The injured person must be within the zone of danger created by the conduct.
2
Foreseeable type of harm. The general kind of injury must be a foreseeable result, even if the exact extent is not.
3
Foreseeable manner. The harm must arise in a way that is not bizarre or freakishly unexpected.

Direct vs. Intervening Causes

Direct Cause
An unbroken sequence from act to harm with no intervening force. Defendant is liable unless the harm is wholly unforeseeable.
Intervening Cause
A later force contributes to the harm. The key question: was that force foreseeable? If yes, liability continues.

Which Forces Stay In the Chain?

Usually Foreseeable
Ordinary negligence of rescuers, medical malpractice in treating the injury, normal forces of nature, and reactions to peril.
Often Superseding
Unforeseeable intentional torts or crimes by third parties, and grossly abnormal, extraordinary natural events.

How to Apply the Test

1
Confirm actual cause. Apply but-for. Proximate cause matters only if factual cause exists.
2
Identify the harm. State precisely what injury occurred and to whom.
3
Ask if it was foreseeable. Was this type of harm a foreseeable risk of the conduct?
4
Check for intervening forces. If foreseeable, liability continues; if superseding, the chain breaks.

Example 1: Direct & Foreseeable

A driver negligently runs a red light and strikes a pedestrian, breaking the pedestrian's leg. No third party intervenes.

Run red light Strikes pedestrian Broken leg

Example 2: Foreseeable Intervening

A defendant negligently injures the plaintiff. At the hospital, a physician negligently aggravates the injury during treatment.

Negligent injury Medical malpractice Worsened harm

Example 3: Superseding Cause

A defendant negligently leaves a parked car unlocked with the key inside. A thief steals it and, hours later, deliberately rams it into the plaintiff.

Unlocked car Intentional crime by thief Harm Chain broken — liability ends here

Common Mistakes

✕ Confusing the two causes
Treating but-for cause as the whole analysis. Always test proximate cause separately.
✕ Demanding exact foreseeability
The precise extent of harm need not be foreseeable — only the general type.
✕ Auto-superseding
Assuming any intervening cause breaks the chain. Foreseeable ones do not.

Quick Reference

Liability Continues Liability Cut Off
Harm typeForeseeable kindBizarre / freakish
PlaintiffIn zone of dangerWholly unforeseeable
Intervening forceForeseeableSuperseding
Medical negligenceOrdinary malpracticeGrossly extraordinary
Third-party actForeseeable negligenceUnforeseeable crime

Question 1 of 5

Proximate cause is best described as a question of:

Question 2 of 5

A defendant negligently starts a small fire. An ordinary gust of wind spreads it to a neighbor's house. Is the defendant the proximate cause of the neighbor's loss?

Question 3 of 5

Under the foreseeability test, the defendant must reasonably foresee:

Question 4 of 5

Is the taxi company likely the proximate cause of the passenger's injuries?

Question 5 of 5

A superseding cause is best defined as an intervening force that is:

Key Takeaways

1
Two causes. Prove both actual (but-for) and proximate (legal) cause.
2
Foreseeability rules. Liability extends to the foreseeable type, plaintiff, and manner of harm.
3
Intervening vs. superseding. Foreseeable forces continue liability; unforeseeable ones break the chain.