01 / 20

Property Torts
Trespass & Conversion

Master the intentional torts that protect possession of land and chattels: trespass to land, trespass to chattels, and conversion.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Are Property Torts?

Property torts are intentional torts that protect a person's interest in their property. They fall into two categories based on what is being protected:

Real Property
Land and things attached to it. Protected by trespass to land.
Personal Property
Chattels (movable goods). Protected by trespass to chattels and conversion.

The Three Property Torts

Trespass to Land Intrusion on real property Trespass to Chattels Minor interference with chattel Conversion Serious interference with chattel Severity of interference increases →

The Intent Requirement

All property torts require intent, but the intent is to do the act, not to cause harm or break the law.

1
Intent to enter or interfere. Defendant must intend the physical act, like walking onto land or taking a chattel.
2
Mistake is no defense. Honestly believing the land is yours does not excuse the trespass.
3
No bad faith needed. A good-faith intruder is still liable for the intentional act.

Rule: Trespass to Land

Plaintiff's Land Defendant enters

Trespass to Land: Key Points

Physical Invasion
Person, object, or anything tangible. Throwing a rock or flooding land counts.
No Damage Needed
Liability arises even with zero harm. Nominal damages protect the right to exclude.
Above & Below
Reasonable use extends to the airspace above and soil below the surface.

Trespass to Chattels vs. Conversion

Both involve interference with personal property. The difference is one of degree.

Trespass to Chattels
Minor interference. Requires actual damage, dispossession, or loss of use. Remedy = cost of repair or rental value.
Conversion
Serious interference so substantial the defendant must pay full value. Remedy = full market value (a forced sale).

How to Analyze a Property Tort

1
Identify the property. Land → trespass to land. Chattel → chattels or conversion.
2
Confirm intent. Did the defendant intend the physical act? (Mistake is irrelevant.)
3
Assess interference. For chattels, gauge severity to decide chattels vs. conversion.
4
Check damages & defenses. Land needs none; chattels needs harm. Consider consent or necessity.

Factors for Conversion

Courts weigh several factors to decide whether interference is serious enough to be conversion:

Duration
How long was the chattel withheld?
Extent of Harm
Was it damaged or destroyed?
Good or Bad Faith
Did the defendant act in bad faith?

Example 1: The Shortcut

Dana cuts across Pat's lawn each morning to reach the bus stop, believing the lawn is public park land. Pat suffers no actual damage.

Example 2: The Borrowed Bike

Without asking, Max takes Lee's bicycle for a two-hour ride and returns it slightly scratched. Lee was unable to use it during that time.

Example 3: The Sold Laptop

Robin takes a coworker's laptop, keeps it for three months, and then sells it to a third party who reformats the drive.

Common Mistakes

✕ Requiring harm for land
Trespass to land needs no actual damage. Nominal damages apply.
✕ Treating mistake as a defense
An honest belief about ownership does not excuse the trespass.
✕ Confusing the two chattel torts
Minor = chattels; serious = conversion. Severity decides.
✕ Calling noise a trespass
Intangible intrusions are usually nuisance, not trespass.

Summary Comparison

Trespass to Land Trespass to Chattels Conversion
PropertyReal (land)PersonalPersonal
IntentTo enterTo interfereTo interfere
Damage neededNoYesYes
SeverityAny entryMinorSerious
RemedyNominal+Repair/rentalFull value

Question 1 of 5

A hiker steps onto a private field, genuinely believing it is a public trail. The owner suffers no damage. Is the hiker liable for trespass to land?

Question 2 of 5

Without permission, Sam borrows a neighbor's ladder for an afternoon and returns it undamaged. The neighbor never noticed it was gone. What tort, if any?

Question 3 of 5

A defendant takes a painting, keeps it for a year, and refuses to return it after the owner demands it back. Which tort and remedy best fit?

Question 4 of 5

A factory's continuous loud noise and vibrations interfere with a neighbor's enjoyment of their land but never physically enter it. This is most likely:

Question 5 of 5

Driving a borrowed car, Alex accidentally dents the fender during a short permitted trip. Which best describes the interference for chattel purposes?